×

Outline of a dynamical inferential conception of the application of mathematics. (English) Zbl 1307.83004

Summary: We outline a framework for analyzing episodes from the history of science in which the application of mathematics plays a constitutive role in the conceptual development of empirical sciences. Our starting point is the inferential conception of the application of mathematics, recently advanced by O.Bueno and M.Colyvan [Noûs 45, No. 2, 345–374 (2011)]. We identify and discuss some systematic problems of this approach. We propose refinements of the inferential conception based on theoretical considerations and on the basis of a historical case study. We demonstrate the usefulness of the refined, dynamical inferential conception using the well-researched example of the genesis of general relativity. Specifically, we look at the collaboration of the physicist Einstein and the mathematician Grossmann in the years 1912-1913, which resulted in the jointly published “Outline of a Generalized Theory of Relativity and a Theory of Gravitation,” a precursor theory of the final theory of general relativity. In this episode, independently developed mathematical theories, the theory of differential invariants and the absolute differential calculus, were applied in the process of finding a relativistic theory of gravitation. The dynamical inferential conception not only provides a natural framework to describe and analyze this episode, but it also generates new questions and insights. We comment on the mathematical tradition on which Grossmann drew, and on his own contributions to mathematical theorizing. The dynamical inferential conception allows us to identify both the role of heuristics and of mathematical resources as well as the systematic role of problems and mistakes in the reconstruction of episodes of conceptual innovation and theory change.

MSC:

83C05 Einstein’s equations (general structure, canonical formalism, Cauchy problems)
53C50 Global differential geometry of Lorentz manifolds, manifolds with indefinite metrics
83-03 History of relativity and gravitational theory
01A60 History of mathematics in the 20th century
00A79 Physics

Software:

Theories
PDFBibTeX XMLCite
Full Text: DOI

References:

[2] Bueno, O.; Colyvan, M., An inferential conception of the application of mathematics, Noûs, 45, 2, 345-374 (2011) · Zbl 1366.00022
[3] Carey, S., The theory of concepts (2009), Oxford University Press: Oxford University Press Oxford
[4] Christoffel, E. B., Über die Transformation der homogenen Differentialausdrücke zweiten Grades, Journal für die reine und angewandte Mathematik, 70, 1, 46-70 (1869) · JFM 02.0128.03
[5] Colyvan, M., Mathematics and the world, (Irvine, A. D., Handbook of the philosophy of science (2009), Elsevier: Elsevier North Holland), 651-702
[6] Earman, J.; Janssen, M., Einstein׳s explanation of the motion of Mercury׳s perihelion, (Earman, J.; Janssen, M.; Norton, J. D., The attraction of gravitation (1993), Birkhäuser: Birkhäuser Boston, Basel, Berlin), 129-172
[7] Einstein, A., Über das Relativitätsprinzip und die aus demselben gezogenen Folgerungen, Jahrbuch der Radioaktivität und Elektronik, 4, 4, 411-462 (1907), (reprinted in: Stachel, J. (Ed.). (1989). The collected papers of Albert Einstein. Vol. 2: The Swiss years: Writings 1900-1909. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, Doc. 47)
[9] Einstein, A.; Fokker, A. D., Die Nordströmsche Gravitationstheorie vom Standpunkt des absoluten Differentialkalküls, Annalen der Physik, 44, 321-328 (1914), (reprinted in: Klein, M. J., Kox, A. J., Renn, J., & Schulmann, R. (Eds.). (1995). The collected papers of Albert Einstein. Vol. 4: the Swiss years, 1912-1914. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, Doc. 28) · JFM 45.1117.03
[10] Einstein, A.; Grossmann, M., Entwurf einer verallgemeinerten Relativitätstheorie und einer Theorie der Gravitation, Zeitschrift für Mathematik und Physik, 62, 3, 225-261 (1913), (reprinted in: Klein, M. J., Kox, A. J., Renn, J., & Schulmann, R. (Eds.). (1995). The collected papers of Albert Einstein. Vol. 4: the Swiss years, 1912-1914. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, Docs. 13,26) · JFM 45.1114.02
[11] French, S., The Reasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics: Partial Structures and the Application of Group Theory to Physics, Synthese, 125, 103-120 (2000) · Zbl 1007.81005
[12] Galison, P., Image and logic. A material culture of microphysics (1997), University of Chicago Press: University of Chicago Press Chicago
[13] Grattan-Guinness, I., Solving Wigner׳s mysteryThe reasonable (though perhaps limited) effectiveness of mathematics in the natural sciences, The Mathematical Intelligencer, 30, 3, 7-17 (2008) · Zbl 1194.00024
[14] Graves, J. C., The conceptual foundations of contemporary relativity theory (1971), MIT Press: MIT Press Cambridge, Massachusetts
[15] Hilbert, D., Naturerkennen und Logik, Die Naturwissenschaften, 18, 47-49, 959-963 (1930) · JFM 56.0050.01
[16] Hughes, R., Models and representation, Philosophy of Science, 64, 325-336 (1997)
[17] Janssen, M.; Renn, J.; Sauer, T.; Norton, J. D.; Stachel, J., A commentary on the notes on gravity in the Zurich notebook, (Renn, J., The genesis of general relativity. Vol. 2. Einstein׳s Zurich Notebook. Commentary and essays (2007), Springer: Springer Dordrecht), 489-714
[18] Klein, F., Gesammelte Mathematische Abhandlungen, Erster Band (1921), Springer: Springer Berlin · JFM 48.0012.02
[21] Ladyman, J.; Ross, D., Every thing must go (2007), Oxford University Press: Oxford University Press Oxford, New York
[22] Laue, M.v., Das Relativitätsprinzip (1913), Friedr. Vieweg & Sohn: Friedr. Vieweg & Sohn Braunschweig · JFM 44.0772.02
[23] Minkowski, H., Die Grundgleichungen für die elektromagnetischen Vorgänge in bewegten Körpern, Königliche Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen, Mathematisch-physikalische Klasse, Nachrichten, 53-111 (1908) · JFM 39.0909.02
[24] Nersessian, N., Creating scientific concepts (2008), MIT press: MIT press Cambridge, MA
[25] Newcomb, S., The elements of the four inner planets and the fundamental constants of astronomy (1895), U.S. Govt. Printing Office: U.S. Govt. Printing Office Washington DC
[26] Norton, J. D., The Physical Content of General Covariance, (Eisenstaedt, J.; Kox, A. J., Studies in History of General Relativity (1992), Birkhäuser; Boston: Birkhäuser; Boston Basel, Berlin), 281-315
[27] Norton, J. D., How Einstein found his field equations, 1912-1915, Historical Studies in the Physical Sciences, 14, 253-316 (1984), (reprinted in Howard, D., Stachel, J. (Eds.). (1989) Einstein and the history of general relativity (pp. 101-159). Boston: Birkhäuser
[29] Pais, A., ‘Subtle is the Lord …’ the science and the life of Albert Einstein (1982), Oxford University Press: Oxford University Press Oxford
[30] Pincock, C., A revealing flaw in Colyvan׳s indispensability argument, Philosophy of Science, 71, 61-79 (2004)
[31] Pincock, C., Overextending Partial Structures: Idealization and Abstraction, Philosophy of Science, 72, 1248-1259 (2005)
[33] Reich, K., Levi-Civitasche Parallelverschiebung, affiner Zusammenhang, Übertragungsprinzip1916/17-1922/23, Archive for History of Exact Sciences, 44, 77-105 (1992) · Zbl 0767.01023
[34] Reich, K., Die Entwicklung des Tensorkalküls: Vom absoluten Differentialkalkül zur Relativitätstheorie (1994), Birkhäuser: Birkhäuser Basel, Boston, Berlin · Zbl 0820.01009
[35] Renn, J., Auf den Schultern von Riesen und Zwergen. Albert Einsteins unvollendete Revolution (2006), Wiley-VCH: Wiley-VCH Weinheim
[37] Renn, J.; Sauer, T., Heuristics and mathematical representation in Einstein׳s search for a gravitational field equation, (Goenner, H.; Renn, J.; Ritter, J.; Sauer, T., The expanding worlds of general relativity (1999), Birkhäuser: Birkhäuser Boston), 87-125 · Zbl 0943.83505
[41] Ricci-Curbastro, G., Direzione e invarianti principali in una varietà qualunque, Atti del Reale Instituto Veneto, 63, 2, 1233-1239 (1904) · JFM 35.0145.01
[42] Ricci, G.; Levi-Civita, T., Méthodes de calcul différentiel absolu et leurs applications, Mathematische Annalen, 54, 125-201 (1901) · JFM 31.0297.01
[44] Rosevaere, N., Mercury׳s perihelion. From Le Verrier to Einstein (1982), Clarendon Press: Clarendon Press Oxford · Zbl 0482.01014
[45] Sauer, T., The relativity of discoveryHilbert׳s first note on the foundations of physics, Archive for History of Exact Sciences, 53, 529-575 (1999) · Zbl 0926.01004
[46] Sauer, T., Marcel Grossmann and his contribution to the general theory of relativity, (R. T., Jantzen; K., Rosquist; R., Ruffini, Proceedings of the 13th Marcel Grossmann meeting on recent developments in theoretical and experimental general relativity, gravitation, and relativistic field theory (2015), World Scientific: World Scientific Singapore), arXiv:1312.4068
[47] (Sauer, T.; Majer, U., David Hilbert׳s lectures on the foundations of physics 1915-1927 (2009), Springer: Springer Dordrecht)
[48] Sommerfeld, A., Zur Relativitätstheorie. I. Vierdimensionale Vektoralgebra, Annalen der Physik, 32, 9, 749-776 (1910) · JFM 41.0758.02
[49] Sommerfeld, A., Zur Relativitätstheorie. II. Vierdimensionale Vektoranalysis, Annalen der Physik, 33, 14, 649-689 (1910) · JFM 41.0759.01
[51] Steiner, M., The applicability of mathematics as a philosophical problem (1998), Harvard University Press: Harvard University Press Cambridge Mass, London · Zbl 0945.00003
[52] Steiner, M., Mathematics - application and applicability, (Shapiro, S., The Oxford handbook of philosophy of mathematics and logic (2005), Oxford University Press: Oxford University Press Oxford), 625-650, (chapter 20) · Zbl 1081.03001
[53] Suárez, M., An inferential conception of scientific representation, Philosophy of Science, 71, 767-779 (2004)
[54] Suárez, M., Scientific representation: Against similarity and isomorphism, International Studies in the Philosophy of Science, 17, 3, 225-244 (2003)
[55] Suárez, M.; Cartwright, N., Theories: Tools versus models, Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics, 39, 62-81 (2008) · Zbl 1282.82054
[56] Wigner, E. P., The unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics in the natural sciences, Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics, 13, 1, 1-14 (1960), (Reprinted in Philosophical Reflections and Syntheses, pp. 534-549) · Zbl 0102.00703
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.