Social learning strategies and cooperative behaviour: evidence of payoff bias, but not prestige or conformity, in a social dilemma game. (English) Zbl 1484.91333


91D15 Social learning
91A90 Experimental studies


JAGS; Stan; brms; rethinking
Full Text: DOI


[1] Binmore, K.; ; Playing for Real: A Text on Game Theory: New York, NY, USA 2007; . · Zbl 1127.91015
[2] Dawes, R.M.; Social Dilemmas; Annu. Rev. Psychol.: 1980; Volume 31 ,169-193.
[3] Hamilton, W.D.; The Genetical Evolution of Social Behaviour. I; J. Theor. Biol.: 1964; Volume 7 ,1-16.
[4] Balliet, D.; Mulder, L.B.; Van Lange, P.A.M.; Reward, Punishment, and Cooperation: A Meta-Analysis; Psychol. Bull.: 2011; Volume 137 ,594-615.
[5] Trivers, R.L.; The Evolution of Reciprocal Altruism; Q. Rev. Biol.: 1971; Volume 46 ,35-57.
[6] Henrich, J.; Muthukrishna, M.; The Origins and Psychology of Human Cooperation; Annu. Rev. Psychol.: 2021; Volume 72 ,1-44.
[7] Kurzban, R.; Burton-Chellew, M.N.; West, S.; The Evolution of Altruism in Humans; Ann. Rev. Psychol.: 2015; Volume 66 ,575-599.
[8] Henrich, J.; Boyd, R.; Bowles, S.; Camerer, C.; Fehr, E.; Gintis, H.; McElreath, R.; Alvard, M.; Barr, A.; Ensminger, J.; “Economic Man” in Cross-Cultural Perspective: Behavioral Experiments in 15 Small-Scale Societies; Behav. Brain Sci.: 2005; Volume 28 ,795-815.
[9] Fehr, E.; Schurtenberger, I.; Normative Foundations of Human Cooperation; Nat. Hum. Behav.: 2018; Volume 2 ,458-468.
[10] Richerson, P.J.; Baldini, R.; Bell, A.V.; Demps, K.; Frost, K.; Hillis, V.; Mathew, S.; Newton, E.K.; Naar, N.; Newson, L.; Cultural Group Selection Plays an Essential Role in Explaining Human Cooperation: A Sketch of the Evidence; Behav. Brain Sci.: 2016; Volume 39 ,e30.
[11] Smith, D.; Cultural Group Selection and Human Cooperation: A Conceptual and Empirical Review; Evol. Hum. Sci.: 2020; Volume 2 ,1-29.
[12] Heyes, C.; Social Learning in Animals: Categories and Mechanisms; Biol. Rev. Camb. Philos. Soc.: 1994; Volume 69 ,207-231.
[13] Rieucau, G.; Giraldeau, L.A.; Exploring the Costs and Benefits of Social Information Use: An Appraisal of Current Experimental Evidence; Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.: 2011; Volume 366 ,949-957.
[14] Mesoudi, A.; The Cultural Dynamics of Copycat Suicide; PLoS ONE: 2009; Volume 4 .
[15] Boyd, R.; Richerson, P.J.; Why Does Culture Increase Human Adaptability?; Ethol. Sociobiol.: 1995; Volume 16 ,125-143.
[16] Schlag, K.H.; Why Imitate, and If So, How?: A boundedly rational approach to multi-armed bandits; J. Econ. Theory: 1998; Volume 78 ,130-156. · Zbl 0895.90003
[17] Laland, K.N.; Social Learning Strategies; Anim. Learn. Behav.: 2004; Volume 32 ,4-14.
[18] Morgan, T.J.H.; Rendell, L.E.; Ehn, M.; Hoppitt, W.; Laland, K.N.; The Evolutionary Basis of Human Social Learning; Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.: 2012; Volume 279 ,653-662.
[19] Henrich, J.; Boyd, R.; The Evolution of Conformist Transmission and the Emergence of Between-Group Differences; Evol. Hum. Behav.: 1998; Volume 19 ,215-241.
[20] Henrich, J.; Gil-White, F.J.; The Evolution of Prestige: Freely Conferred Deference as a Mechanism for Enhancing the Benefits of Cultural Transmission; Evol. Hum. Behav.: 2001; Volume 22 ,165-196.
[21] Kendal, R.; Boogert, N.J.; Rendell, L.; Laland, K.N.; Webster, M.; Jones, P.L.; Social Learning Strategies: Bridge-Building between Fields; Trends Cogn. Sci.: 2018; Volume 22 ,651-665.
[22] Powers, S.T.; Van Schaik, C.P.; Lehmann, L.; How Institutions Shaped the Last Major Evolutionary Transition to Large-Scale Human Societies; Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.: 2016; Volume 371 ,20150098.
[23] Henrich, J.; ; The Secret of Our Success: Princeton, NJ, USA 2018; .
[24] Lewis, P.R.; Ekart, A.; Social and Asocial Learning in Collective Action Problems: The Rise and Fall of Socially-Beneficial Behaviour; Proceedings of the Proceedings—2017 IEEE 2nd International Workshops on Foundations and Applications of Self* Systems, FAS*W 2017: ; ,91-96.
[25] Carpenter, J.P.; When in Rome: Conformity and the Provision of Public Goods; J. Socio-Econ.: 2004; Volume 33 ,395-408.
[26] Bardsley, N.; Sausgruber, R.; Conformity and Reciprocity in Public Good Provision; J. Econ. Psychol.: 2005; Volume 26 ,664-681.
[27] Romano, A.; Balliet, D.; Reciprocity Outperforms Conformity to Promote Cooperation; Psychol. Sci.: 2017; Volume 28 ,1490-1502.
[28] Henrich, J.; Chudek, M.; Boyd, R.; The Big Man Mechanism: How Prestige Fosters Cooperation and Creates Prosocial Leaders; Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.: 2015; Volume 370 ,20150013.
[29] Molleman, L.; Quiñones, A.E.; Weissing, F.J.; Cultural Evolution of Cooperation: The Interplay between Forms of Social Learning and Group Selection; Evol. Hum. Behav.: 2013; Volume 34 ,342-349.
[30] Lehmann, L.; Feldman, M.W.; The Co-Evolution of Culturally Inherited Altruistic Helping and Cultural Transmission under Random Group Formation; Theor. Popul. Biol.: 2008; Volume 73 ,506-516. · Zbl 1210.92020
[31] Gächter, S.; Nosenzo, D.; Renner, E.; Sefton, M.; Who Makes a Good Leader? Cooperativeness, Optimism, and Leading-by-Example; Econ. Inq.: 2012; Volume 50 ,953-967.
[32] Harrell, A.; Simpson, B.; The Dynamics of Prosocial Leadership: Power and Influence in Collective Action Groups; Soc. Forces: 2016; Volume 94 ,1283-1308.
[33] De Cremer, D.; Van Knippenberg, D.; How Do Leaders Promote Cooperation? The Effects of Charisma and Procedural Fairness; J. Appl. Psychol.: 2002; Volume 87 ,858-866.
[34] Offord, M.; Gill, R.; Kendal, J.; Leadership between Decks: A Synthesis and Development of Engagement and Resistance Theories of Leadership Based on Evidence from Practice in Royal Navy Warships; Leadersh. Organ. Dev. J.: 2016; Volume 37 ,289-304.
[35] Offord, M.; Gill, R.; Kendal, J.; The Effects of Prestige on Collective Performance and Information Flow in a Strictly Hierarchical Institution; Palgrave Commun.: 2019; Volume 5 ,1-11.
[36] Wood, N.T.; Herbst, K.C.; Political Star Power and Political Parties: Does Celebrity Endorsement Win First-Time Votes?; J. Political Mark.: 2007; Volume 6 ,141-158.
[37] John, P.; James, O.; Moseley, A.; Ryan, M.; Richardson, L.; Stoker, G.; The Impact of Peer, Politician, and Celebrity Endorsements on Volunteering: A Field Experiment with English Students; J. Nonprofit Public Sect. Mark.: 2019; Volume 31 ,328-346.
[38] Kumru, C.S.; Vesterlund, L.; The Effect of Status on Charitable Giving; J. Public Econ. Theory: 2010; Volume 12 ,709-735.
[39] Schlag, K.H.; Which One Should I Imitate?; J. Math. Econ.: 1999; Volume 31 ,493-522. · Zbl 0947.91025
[40] Taylor, P.D.; Jonker, L.B.; Evolutionary Stable Strategies and Game Dynamics; Math. Biosci.: 1978; Volume 40 ,145-156. · Zbl 0395.90118
[41] Grujić, J.; Lenaerts, T.; Do People Imitate When Making Decisions? Evidence from a Spatial Prisoner’s Dilemma Experiment: Do People Imitate When Making Decisions; R. Soc. Open Sci.: 2020; Volume 7 ,200618.
[42] Molleman, L.; van den Berg, P.; Weissing, F.J.; Consistent Individual Differences in Human Social Learning Strategies; Nat. Commun.: 2014; Volume 5 ,1-9.
[43] Burton-Chellew, M.N.; el Mouden, C.; West, S.A.; Social Learning and the Demise of Costly Cooperation in Humans; Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B Biol. Sci.: 2017; Volume 284 ,10-12.
[44] Burton-Chellew, M.N.; Nax, H.H.; West, S.A.; Payoff-Based Learning Explains the Decline in Cooperation in Public Goods Games; Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.: 2015; Volume 282 ,20142678.
[45] Burton-Chellew, M.N.; West, S.A.; Payoff-Based Learning Best Explains the Rate of Decline in Cooperation across 237 Public-Goods Games; Nat. Hum. Behav.: 2021; Volume 5 ,36-38.
[46] Neugebauer, T.; Perote, J.; Schmidt, U.; Loos, M.; Selfish-Biased Conditional Cooperation: On the Decline of Contributions in Repeated Public Goods Experiments; J. Econ. Psychol.: 2009; Volume 30 ,52-60.
[47] Szolnoki, A.; Chen, X.; Competition and Partnership between Conformity and Payoff-Based Imitations in Social Dilemmas; New J. Phys.: 2018; Volume 20 ,093008.
[48] Gürerk, Ö.; Irlenbusch, B.; Rockenbach, B.; The Competitive Advantage of Sanctioning Institutions; Science: 2006; Volume 312 ,108-112.
[49] Rapoport, A.; Prisoner’s Dilemma—Recollections and Observations; Game Theory as a Theory of a Conflict Resolution: Dordecht, The Netherlands 1974; ,17-34. · Zbl 0371.90124
[50] Doebeli, M.; Hauert, C.; Models of Cooperation Based on the Prisoner’s Dilemma and the Snowdrift Game; Ecol. Lett.: 2005; Volume 8 ,748-766.
[51] Axelrod, R.; Hamilton, W.D.; The Evolution of Cooperation; Evolution: 1981; Volume 211 ,1390-1396. · Zbl 1225.92037
[52] Kun, Á.; Boza, G.; Scheuring, I.; Asynchronous Snowdrift Game with Synergistic Effect as a Model of Cooperation; Behav. Ecol.: 2006; Volume 17 ,633-641.
[53] Souza, M.O.; Pacheco, J.M.; Santos, F.C.; Evolution of Cooperation under N-Person Snowdrift Games; J. Theor. Biol.: 2009; Volume 260 ,581-588. · Zbl 1402.91061
[54] Gore, J.; Youk, H.; Van Oudenaarden, A.; Snowdrift Game Dynamics and Facultative Cheating in Yeast; Nature: 2009; Volume 459 ,253-256.
[55] Smith, R.P.; Doiron, A.; Muzquiz, R.; Fortoul, M.C.; Haas, M.; Abraham, T.; Quinn, R.J.; Barraza, I.; Chowdhury, K.; Nemzer, L.R.; The Public and Private Benefit of an Impure Public Good Determines the Sensitivity of Bacteria to Population Collapse in a Snowdrift Game; Environ. Microbiol.: 2019; Volume 21 ,4330-4342.
[56] Keohane, R.O.; Victor, D.G.; Cooperation and Discord in Global Climate Policy; Nat. Clim. Chang.: 2016; Volume 6 ,570-575.
[57] Kümmerli, R.; Colliard, C.; Fiechter, N.; Petitpierre, B.; Russier, F.; Keller, L.; Human Cooperation in Social Dilemmas: Comparing the Snowdrift Game with the Prisoner’s Dilemma; Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.: 2007; Volume 274 ,2965-2970.
[58] Su, W.; Potenza, M.N.; Zhang, Z.; Hu, X.; Gao, L.; Wang, Y.; Do Individuals with Problematic and Non-Problematic Internet Game Use Differ in Cooperative Behaviors with Partners of Different Social Distances? Evidence from the Prisoner’s Dilemma and Chicken Game; Comput. Hum. Behav.: 2018; Volume 87 ,363-370.
[59] Hilbig, B.E.; Kieslich, P.J.; Henninger, F.; Thielmann, I.; Zettler, I.; Lead Us (Not) into Temptation: Testing the Motivational Mechanisms Linking Honesty-Humility to Cooperation; Eur. J. Personal.: 2018; Volume 32 ,116-127.
[60] Reed, L.I.; Best, C.K.; Hooley, J.M.; Cooperation with Characters: How a Partner’s Personality Disorder Decreases Cooperation in Two Economic Games; Personal. Individ. Differ.: 2018; Volume 126 ,33-37.
[61] Roberts, G.; Sherratt, T.N.; Development of Cooperative Relationships through Increasing Investment; Nature: 1998; Volume 394 ,175-179.
[62] Brown, J.S.; Vincent, T.L.; Evolution of Cooperation with Shared Costs and Benefits; Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.: 2008; Volume 275 ,1985-1994.
[63] Mcnamara, J.M.; Barta, Z.; Fromhage, L.; Houston, A.I.; The Coevolution of Choosiness and Cooperation; Nature: 2008; Volume 451 ,189-192.
[64] Zhong, L.X.; Qiu, T.; Xu, J.R.; Heterogeneity Improves Cooperation in Continuous Snowdrift Game; Chin. Phys. Lett.: 2008; Volume 25 ,2315-2318.
[65] Sasaki, T.; Okada, I.; Cheating Is Evolutionarily Assimilated with Cooperation in the Continuous Snowdrift Game; BioSystems: 2015; Volume 131 ,51-59.
[66] Zelmer, J.; Linear Public Goods Experiments: A Meta-Analysis; Exp. Econ.: 2003; Volume 6 ,299-310. · Zbl 1074.91517
[67] Kendal, J.R.; Rendell, L.; Pike, T.W.; Laland, K.N.; Nine-Spined Sticklebacks Deploy a Hill-Climbing Social Learning Strategy; Behav. Ecol.: 2009; Volume 20 ,238-244.
[68] Vale, G.L.; Flynn, E.G.; Kendal, J.; Rawlings, B.; Hopper, L.M.; Schapiro, S.J.; Lambeth, S.P.; Kendal, R.L.; Testing Differential Use of Payoff-Biased Social Learning Strategies in Children and Chimpanzees; Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.: 2017; Volume 284 ,20171751.
[69] Beheim, B.A.; Thigpen, C.; Mcelreath, R.; Strategic Social Learning and the Population Dynamics of Human Behavior: The Game of Go; Evol. Hum. Behav.: 2014; Volume 35 ,351-357.
[70] Barrett, B.J.; McElreath, R.L.; Perry, S.E.; Pay-off-Biased Social Learning Underlies the Diffusion of Novel Extractive Foraging Traditions in a Wild Primate; Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.: 2017; Volume 284 ,20170358.
[71] Bono, A.E.J.; Whiten, A.; van Schaik, C.; Krützen, M.; Eichenberger, F.; Schnider, A.; van de Waal, E.; Payoff- and Sex-Biased Social Learning Interact in a Wild Primate Population; Curr. Biol.: 2018; Volume 28 ,2800-2805.e4.
[72] Jiang, L.L.; Li, W.J.; Wang, Z.; Multiple Effect of Social Influence on Cooperation in Interdependent Network Games; Sci. Rep.: 2015; Volume 5 ,1-8.
[73] Diekmann, A.; Przepiorka, W.; Rauhut, H.; Lifting the Veil of Ignorance: An Experiment on the Contagiousness of Norm Violations; Ration. Soc.: 2015; Volume 27 ,309-333.
[74] Gino, F.; Ayal, S.; Ariely, D.; Contagion and Differentiation in Unethical Behavior the Effect of One Bad Apple on the Barrel; Psychol. Sci.: 2009; Volume 20 ,393-398.
[75] McElreath, R.; Bell, A.V.; Efferson, C.; Lubell, M.; Richerson, P.J.; Waring, T.; Beyond Existence and Aiming Outside the Laboratory: Estimating Frequency-Dependent and Pay-off-Biased Social Learning Strategies; Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.: 2008; Volume 363 ,3515-3528.
[76] Gächter, S.; Thöni, C.; Social Learning and Voluntary Cooperation Among Like-Minded People; J. Eur. Econ. Assoc.: 2005; Volume 3 ,303-314.
[77] Molleman, L.; Pen, I.; Weissing, F.J.; Effects of Conformism on the Cultural Evolution of Social Behaviour; PLoS ONE: 2013; Volume 8 .
[78] McElreath, R.; Henrich, J.; The Evolution of Cultural Evolution; Evol. Anthropol.: 2003; Volume 12 ,123-135.
[79] Brand, C.O.; Heap, S.; Morgan, T.J.H.; Mesoudi, A.; The Emergence and Adaptive Use of Prestige in an Online Social Learning Task; Sci. Rep.: 2020; Volume 10 ,1-11.
[80] Jiménez, Á.V.; Mesoudi, A.; Prestige-Biased Social Learning: Current Evidence and Outstanding Questions; Palgrave Commun.: 2019; Volume 5 ,1-12.
[81] Brand, C.O.; Mesoudi, A.; Prestige and Dominance-Based Hierarchies Exist in Naturally Occurring Human Groups, but Are Unrelated to Task-Specific Knowledge; R. Soc. Open Sci.: 2019; Volume 6 ,181621.
[82] Kelsey, C.; Vaish, A.; Grossmann, T.; Eyes, More Than Other Facial Features, Enhance Real-World Donation Behavior; Hum. Nat.: 2018; Volume 29 ,390-401.
[83] Yoeli, E.; Hoffman, M.; Rand, D.G.; Nowak, M.A.; Powering up with Indirect Reciprocity in a Large-Scale Field Experiment; Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA: 2013; Volume 110 ,10424-10429.
[84] Burton-Chellew, M.N.; El Mouden, C.; West, S.A.; Evidence for Strategic Cooperation in Humans; Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.: 2017; Volume 284 ,20170689.
[85] Fischbacher, U.; Gächter, S.; Social Preferences, Beliefs, and the Dynamics of Free Riding in Public Goods Experiments; Am. Econ. Rev.: 2010; Volume 100 ,541-556.
[86] Ferraro, P.J.; Vossler, C.A.; The Source and Significance of Confusion in Public Goods Experiments; BE J. Econ. Anal. Policy: 2010; Volume 10 .
[87] Gunnthorsdottir, A.; Houser, D.; McCabe, K.; Disposition, History and Contributions in Public Goods Experiments; J. Econ. Behav. Organ.: 2007; Volume 62 ,304-315.
[88] van den Berg, P.; Dewitte, P.; Aertgeerts, I.; Wenseleers, T.; How the Incentive to Contribute Affects Contributions in the One-Shot Public Goods Game; Sci. Rep.: 2020; Volume 10 ,8-12.
[89] Rawlings, B.; Flynn, E.; Kendal, R.; To Copy or To Innovate? The Role of Personality and Social Networks in Children’s Learning Strategies; Child Dev. Perspect.: 2017; Volume 11 ,39-44.
[90] Toyokawa, W.; Whalen, A.; Laland, K.N.; Social Learning Strategies Regulate the Wisdom and Madness of Interactive Crowds; Nat. Hum. Behav.: 2019; Volume 3 ,183-193.
[91] Flynn, E.; Turner, C.; Giraldeau, L.A.; Selectivity in Social and Asocial Learning: Investigating the Prevalence, Effect and Development of Young Children’s Learning Preferences; Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.: 2016; Volume 371 ,20150189.
[92] Skyrms, B.; ; The Stag Hunt and the Evolution of Social Structure: Cambridge, UK 2004; .
[93] Iyer, S.; Killingback, T.; Evolution of Cooperation in Social Dilemmas with Assortative Interactions; Games: 2020; Volume 11 . · Zbl 1457.91075
[94] Allcott, H.; Social Norms and Energy Conservation; J. Public Econ.: 2011; Volume 95 ,1082-1095.
[95] Waring, T.; Acheson, J.; Evidence of Cultural Group Selection in Territorial Lobstering in Maine; Sustain. Sci.: 2018; Volume 13 ,21-34.
[96] Dallinger Dallinger; ; .
[97] Fischbacher, U.; Gächter, S.; Fehr, E.; Are People Conditionally Cooperative? Evidence from a Public Goods Experiment; Econ. Lett.: 2001; Volume 71 ,397-404. · Zbl 0999.91001
[98] Team, R.C.; ; R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing: Vienna, Austria 2021; .
[99] Bürkner, P.C.; Brms: An R Package for Bayesian Multilevel Models Using Stan; J. Stat. Softw.: 2017; Volume 80 ,1-28.
[100] McElreath, R.; ; Statistical Rethinking: Boca Raton, FL, USA 2020; .
[101] Kruschke, J.K.; ; Doing Bayesian Data Analysis: A Tutorial with R, JAGS, and Stan: Cambridge, MA, USA 2015; .
[102] Kurzban, R.; Houser, D.; Individual Differences in Cooperation in a Circular Public Goods Game; Eur. J. Personal.: 2001; Volume 15 ,S37-S52.
[103] Andreoni, J.; Impure Altruism and Donations to Public Goods: A Theory of Warm-Glow Giving; Econ. J.: 1990; Volume 100 ,464-477.
[104] Heyes, C.; Who Knows? Metacognitive Social Learning Strategies; Trends Cogn. Sci.: 2016; Volume 20 ,204-213.
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.