×

zbMATH — the first resource for mathematics

Should a manufacturer sell refurbished returns on the secondary market to incentivize retailers to reduce consumer returns? (English) Zbl 1430.90061
Summary: Consumer electronics returns are typically returned by the retailer to the manufacturer for a full refund of the wholesale price. This practice does not sufficiently motivate the retailer to reduce the volume of returns. Different mechanisms have been proposed to incentivize the retailer to reduce returns, such as a reduced wholesale price for returns below a target, but they do not consider the subsequent disposition of returns. The high value of returns usually justifies refurbishment and resale. We study how competition between refurbished returns sold by the manufacturer and new products sold at the retailer affects retailer behavior. We find that the retailer never exerts more effort to reduce returns when faced with competition through the online store. The manufacturer’s profitability, however, is always higher with an online store. The online store is also preferable to a strategy where the manufacturer only partially refunds the retailer for returns.
MSC:
90B06 Transportation, logistics and supply chain management
90B50 Management decision making, including multiple objectives
PDF BibTeX XML Cite
Full Text: DOI
References:
[1] Abbey, J. D.; Kleber, R.; Souza, G. C.; Voigt, G., The role of perceived quality risk in pricing remanufactured products, Production and Operations Management, 26, 1, 100-115 (2017)
[2] Abbey, J. D.; Meloy, M.; Guide, V. D.R.; Atalay, S., Remanufactured products in closed-loop supply chains for consumer goods, Production and Operations Management, 24, 3, 488-503 (2015)
[3] Agrawal, V. V.; Ferguson, M.; Souza, G. C., Trade-in rebates for price discrimination and product recovery, IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, 63, 3, 326-339 (2016)
[4] Akcay, Y.; Boyaci, T.; Zhang, D., Selling with money-back guarantees: The impact on prices, quantities, and retail profitability, Production and Operations Management, 22, 4, 777-791 (2013)
[5] Atasu, A.; Sarvary, M.; Van Wassenhove, L., Remanufacturing as a marketing strategy, Management Science, 54, 10, 1731-1746 (2008)
[6] Atasu, A.; Souza, G., How does product recovery affect quality choice?, Production and Operations Management, 22, 4, 376-393 (2013)
[7] Chiang, W.-Y. K.; Chhajed, D.; Hess, J. D., Direct marketing, indirect profits: A strategic analysis of dual-channel supply-chain design, Management Science, 49, 1, 1-20 (2003) · Zbl 1232.90231
[8] Choi, T. M.; Li, D.; Yan, H., Optimal returns policy for supply chain with e-marketplace, International Journal of Production Economics, 88, 2, 205-227 (2004)
[9] Chu, W.; Gerstner, E.; Hess, J., Managing dissatisfaction: How to decrease customer opportunism by partial refunds, Journal of Service Research, 1, 2, 140-155 (1998)
[10] Cooper, R., Winning at new products: Accelerating the process from idea to launch (2001), Perseus Publishing: Perseus Publishing Cambridge, MA
[11] Crocker, K. J.; Letizia, P., Optimal policies for recovering the value of consumer returns, Production and Operations Management, 23, 10, 1667-1680 (2014)
[12] Davis, S.; Hagerty, M.; Gerstner, E., Return policies and the optimal level of ‘Hassle’, Journal of Economics and Business, 50, 5, 445-460 (1998)
[13] Douthit, D., Flach, M., & Agrawal, V. (2011). A “Returning Problem”: Reducing the quantity and cost of product returns in consumer electronics. Accenture report. http://www.wrap.org.uk/sites/files/wrap/accenture-reducing-the-quantity-and-cost-of-customerreturns.pdf.
[14] Ferguson, M. E.; Fleischmann, M.; Souza, G. C., A profit-maximizing approach to disposition decisions for product returns, Decision Sciences, 42, 3, 773-798 (2011)
[15] Ferguson, M. E.; Guide, V. D.R.; Souza, G. C., Supply chain coordination for false failure returns, Manufacturing Service Operations Management, 8, 4, 376-393 (2006)
[16] Ferguson, M. E.; Toktay, L. B., The effect of competition on recovery strategies, Production and Operations Management, 15, 3, 351-368 (2006)
[17] Ferrer, G.; Swaminathan, J., Managing new and remanufactured products, Management Science, 52, 1, 15-26 (2006)
[18] Galbreth, M. R.; Boyaci, T.; Verter, V., Product reuse in innovative industries, Production and Operations Management, 22, 4, 1011-1033 (2013)
[19] Gan, S. S.; Pujawan, I.; Widodo, B., Pricing decision for the new and remanufactured product in a closed-loop supply chain with separate sales-channel, International Journal of Production Economics, 190, 120-132 (2017)
[20] Geyer, R.; Van Wassenhove, L. N.; Atasu, A., The economics of remanufacturing under limited component durability and finite product life cycles, Management Science, 53, 1, 88-100 (2007) · Zbl 1232.90179
[21] Ginsburg, J. (2001). Manufacturing: Once is not enough. Bloomsberg Business Week. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2001-04-15/manufacturing-once-is-not-enough.
[22] Guide, V.; Van Wassenhove, L. N., Managing product returns for remanufacturing, Production and Operations Management, 10, 2, 142-155 (2001)
[23] Guide, V. D.R.; Li, K., The potential for cannibalization of new product sales by remanufactured products, Decision Sciences, 41, 3, 547-572 (2010)
[24] Guide, V. D.R.; Souza, G. C.; Van Wassenhove, L. N.; Blackburn, J. D., Time value of commercial product returns, Management Science, 52, 8, 1200-1214 (2006) · Zbl 1232.90145
[25] Guide, V. D.R.; Van Wassenhove, L. N., The evolution of closed-loop supply chain research, Operations Research, 57, 1, 10-18 (2009) · Zbl 1181.90038
[26] Heiman, A.; Just, D.; McWilliams, B.; Zilberman, D., Money-back guarantees and the value of decision time: An empirical analysis (2005), Agricultural Issues Center, University of California
[27] Huang, X.; Choi, S. M.; Ching, W. K.; Siu, T. K.; Huang, M., On supply chain coordination for false failure returns: A quantity discount contract approach, International Journal of Production Economics, 133, 2, 634-644 (2011)
[28] Inderfurth, K.; de Kok, A.; Flapper, S., Product recovery in stochastic remanufacturing systems with multiple reuse options, European Journal of Operational Research, 133, 1, 130-152 (2001) · Zbl 0989.90046
[29] Ketzenberg, M.; Zuidwijk, R., Optimal pricing, ordering, and return policies for consumer goods, Production and Operations Management, 18, 3, 344-360 (2009)
[30] Kleber, R.; Reimann, M.; Souza, G. C.; Zhang, W., On the Robustness of the consumer homogeneity assumption with respect to the discount factor for remanufactured products, European Journal of Operational Research, 269, 3, 1027-1040 (2018) · Zbl 1388.90057
[31] Li, X.; Li, Y.; Cai, X., Quantity decisions in a supply chain with early returns remanufacturing, International Journal of Production Research, 50, 8, 2161-2173 (2011)
[32] Liu, J.; Mantin, B.; Wang, H., Supply chain coordination with customer returns and refund-dependent demand, International Journal of Production Economics, 148, 81-89 (2014)
[33] Ofek, E.; Katona, Z.; Sarvary, M., “Bricks and Clicks”: The impact of product returns on the strategies of multichannel retailers, Marketing Science, 30, 1, 42-60 (2011)
[34] Oraiopoulos, N.; Ferguson, M.; Toktay, L. B., Relicensing as a secondary market strategy, Management Science, 58, 5, 1022-1037 (2012)
[35] Orsdemir, A.; Kemahlioglu-Ziya, E.; Parlakturk, A., Competitive quality choice and remanufacturing, Production and Operations Management, 23, 1, 48-64 (2014)
[36] Ovchinnikov, A., Revenue and cost management for remanufactured products, Production and Operations Management, 20, 6, 824-840 (2011)
[37] Philips Austria GmbH. (2018). Personal communication with Q&R Excellence Manager.
[38] Pinçe, Ç.; Ferguson, M.; Toktay, B., Extracting maximum value from consumer returns: allocating between remarketing and refurbishing for warranty claims, Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 18, 4, 475-492 (2016)
[39] Pur, S., Stahl, E., Wittmann, M., Wittmann, G., & Weinfurtner, S. (2013). Retourenmanagement im Online-Handel – das Beste daraus machen: Daten, Fakten und Status quo.ibi research 2013. http://www.ibi.de.
[40] Ray, S.; Boyaci, T.; Aras, N., Optimal prices and trade-in rebates for durable, remanufacturable products, Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 7, 3, 208-228 (2005)
[41] Reimann, M., Accurate response with refurbished consumer returns, Decision Sciences, 47, 1, 31-59 (2016)
[42] Reimann, M.; Zhang, W., Joint optimization of new production, warranty servicing strategy and secondary market supply under consumer returns, Pesquisa Operacional, 33, 3, 325-342 (2013)
[43] Ruiz-Benitez, R.; Muriel, A., Consumer returns in a decentralized supply chain, International Journal of Production Economics, 147, Part C, 573-592 (2014)
[44] Savaskan, R. C.; Bhattacharya, S.; Van Wassenhove, L. N., Closed-loop supply chain models with product remanufacturing, Management Science, 50, 2, 239-252 (2004) · Zbl 1232.90119
[45] Scheriau, S. (2016). Philips - Consumer returned products. Master’s thesis. School of Business, Economics and Social Sciences, University of Graz.
[46] Shulman, J.; Coughlan, A.; Savaskan, R., Optimal restocking fees and information provision in an integrated demand-supply model of product returns, Manufacturing and Service Operations Management, 11, 4, 577-594 (2009)
[47] Shulman, J.; Coughlan, A.; Savaskan, R., Optimal reverse channel structure for consumer products returns, Marketing Science, 29, 6, 1071-1085 (2010)
[48] Shulman, J.; Coughlan, A.; Savaskan, R., Managing consumer returns in a competitive environment, Management Science, 57, 2, 347-362 (2011) · Zbl 1214.90074
[49] Souza, G. C., Closed-loop supply chains: A critical review, and future research, Decision Sciences, 44, 1, 7-38 (2013)
[50] Subramanian, R.; Ferguson, M.; Toktay, L. B., Remanufacturing and the component commonality decision, Production and Operations Management, 22, 1, 36-53 (2013)
[51] Subramanian, R.; Subramanyam, R., Key factors in the market for remanufactured products, Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 14, 2, 315-326 (2012)
[52] Taylor, T., Supply chain coordination under channel rebates with sales effort effects, Management Science, 48, 8, 992-1007 (2002) · Zbl 1232.90198
[53] Xiao, T.; Shi, K.; Yang, D., Coordination of a supply chain with consumer return under demand uncertainty, International Journal of Production Economics, 124, 1, 171-180 (2010)
[54] Yalabik, B.; Petruzzi, N. C.; Chhajed, D., An integrated product returns model with logistics and marketing coordination, European Journal of Operational Research, 161, 1, 162-182 (2005) · Zbl 1067.90107
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.