×

Research and reality: a literature review on drawing down retirement financial savings. (English) Zbl 1412.91050

Summary: How do, could, and should retirees draw down their financial savings? This article reviews over 100 papers on this topic from the perspective of individuals, families, governments, and financial institutions. Three significant conceptual/methodological weaknesses in the existing literature are identified: (1) analysts have examined a limited range of self-managed drawdown strategies; (2) nearly all have ignored home ownership, pensions, debt, and government taxes and transfers when quantitatively evaluating alternative drawdown strategies; and (3) there is a well-acknowledged gap between the behavior implied by economic models and that of real-life individuals, particularly when it comes to voluntary annuitization. Expanding the set of drawdown strategies evaluated (e.g., including larger payouts when life expectancy is reduced after the onset of a significant health condition, or using savings as bridge income to delay the take-up of social security payments), refining the income concept used, and more exact modeling of the trade-offs underlying individual decision-making will likely increase the appeal of self-managed drawdown strategies and help resolve the “annuity puzzle” that has long dominated this line of research. It may also lead to advice and financial products that will better meet the needs of retirees.

MSC:

91B30 Risk theory, insurance (MSC2010)
91-02 Research exposition (monographs, survey articles) pertaining to game theory, economics, and finance
PDFBibTeX XMLCite
Full Text: DOI

References:

[1] Agnew, J. R.; Anderson, L. R.; Gerlach, J. R.; Szykman, L. R., Who Chooses Annuities? An Experimental Investigation of the Role of Gender, Framing, and Defaults, American Economic Review: Papers & Proceedings, 98, 418-422 (2008)
[2] Aguiar, M.; Hurst, E., Consumption versus Expenditure, Journal of Political Economy, 113, 919-948 (2005)
[3] Albrecht, P.; Maurer, R., Self Annuitization, Ruin Risk in Retirement and Asset Allocation: The Annuity Benchmark, Journal of Pension Economics and Finance, 1, 269-288 (2002)
[4] American Council of Life Insurers, Positioning and Promoting Annuities in a New Retirement Environment (1999)
[5] Ameriks, J.; Caplin, A.; Laufer, S.; Van Nieuwerburgh, S., The Joy of Giving or Assisted Living? Using Strategic Surveys to Separate Public Care Aversion from Bequest Motives, Journal of Finance, 66, 519-561 (2011)
[6] Ameriks, J.; Veres, R.; Warshawsky, M. J., Making Retirement Income Last a Lifetime, Journal of Financial Planning, 14, 82-97 (2001)
[7] Ameriks, J.; Yakoboski, P., Reducing Retirement Income Risks: The Role of Annuitization, Benefits Quarterly, 19, 4, 13-24 (2003)
[8] Avery, M.; Morrison, R. J., Spending Down One’s Retirement Assets in an Uncertain World (2009)
[9] Avery, M.; Morrison, R. J., Retirement Savings and Retirement Consumption: Incentives Based Analyses of Supposed Anomalies (2011)
[10] Babbel, D. F., Lifetime Income for Women: A Financial Economist’s Perspective. Wharton Financial Institutions Center Policy Brief: Personal Finance, August. (2008)
[11] Babbel, D. F.; Merrill, C. B., Rational Decumulation, 06-14 (2006)
[12] Bayraktar, E.; Young, V. R., Minimizing the Probability of Lifetime Ruin with Deferred Life Annuities, North American Actuarial Journal, 13, 141-154 (2009) · Zbl 1483.91178
[13] Benartzi, S.; Previtero, A.; Thaler, R. H., Annuity Puzzles, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 25, 4, 143-164 (2011)
[14] Blake, D.; Cairns, A.; Dowd, K., Pensionmetrics 2: Stochastic Pension Design during the Distribution Phase, Insurance Mathematics & Economics, 33, 29-47 (2003) · Zbl 1043.62086
[15] Broadbent, J.; Palumbo, M.; Woodman, E., The Shift from Defined Benefit to Defined Contribution Pension Plans—Implications for Asset Allocation and Risk Management, 1-59 (2006)
[16] Brown, J. R., Private Pensions, Mortality Risk, and the Decision to Annuitize, Journal of Public Economics, 82, 29-62 (2001)
[17] Brown, J. R., Rational and Behavioral Perspectives on the Role of Annuities in Retirement Planning (2007)
[18] Brown, J. R., Financial Education and Annuities, OECD Journal: General Papers, 20, 3, 173-215 (2008)
[19] Brown, J. R.; Lusardi, A., Understanding the Role of Annuities in Retirement Planning, Overcoming the Saving Slump (2009), Chicago: University of Chicago Press, Chicago
[20] Brown, J. R., Automatic Lifetime Income as a Path to Retirement Income Security, Prepared for the American Council of Life Insurers. (2009)
[21] Brown, J. R.; Kling, J. R.; Mullainathan, S.; Wrobel, M., Why Don’t People Insure Late Life Consumption? A Framing Explanation of the Under-Annuitization Puzzle, American Economic Review: Papers & Proceedings, 98, 304-309 (2008)
[22] Brown, J. R.; Warshawsky, M. J., Longevity-Insured Retirement Distributions from Pension Plans: Market and Regulatory Issues (2001)
[23] Brown, R. L.; Scahill, P., Issues in the Issuance of Enhanced Annuities, Social and Economic Dimensions of an Aging Population Research Papers 265 (2010), Hamilton, Ontario, , Canada: SEDAP, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, , Canada
[24] Brown, S. L.; Lin, I.-F., The Gray Divorce Revolution: Rising Divorce among Middle-Aged and Older Adults, 1990-2010, Journals of Gerontology Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences, 67, 731-741 (2012)
[25] Brunner, J. K.; Pech, S., Adverse Selection in the Annuity Market When Payoffs Vary over the Time of Retirement, Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics, 161, 155-183 (2005)
[26] Bryck, M.; Meredith, B.; Rappaport, A.; Siegel, S., What a Difference a Year Makes: A Supplemental Report on the Impact of the 2008-2009 Financial Crisis (2009)
[27] Bryck, M.; Meredith, B.; Rappaport, A.; Siegel, S., The Financial Recovery for Retirees Continues: The Impact of the 2008-2011 Financial Crisis. LIMRA (2011), InFRE and Society of Actuaries
[28] Bryck, M.; Meredith, B.; Siegel, S.; LIMRA, InFRE, and Society of Actuaries, Will Retirement Assets Last a Lifetime? (2009)
[29] Brzozowski, M.; Lu, Y., Home Cooking, Food Consumption, and Food Production among Retired Canadian Households, Canadian Public Policy, 36, 107-128 (2010)
[30] Butler, M.; Peijnenburg, K.; Staubli, S., How Much Do Means-Tested Benefits Reduce the Demand for Annuities? (2011)
[31] Chevreau, J., Don’t Be a Slave to Retirement Savings: Advice from a Debt-Despiser, Wealthy Boomer, National Poste (2008)
[32] Clements, J., It Pays to Delay: The Longer You Wait To Buy an Annuity, the More You Get, Wall Street Journal (2003)
[33] Cooper, S., The New Retirement: How It Will Change Our Future. (2008), Toronto: Viking Canada, Toronto
[34] Côté, J.-D., Is Canada Ready for the DC Spend-Down Phase?, Benefits Canada (2010)
[35] Curry, B., Majority Backs Expanding Canada Pension Plan, Poll Finds, Globe and Mail (2011)
[36] Davidoff, T., Housing, Health, and Annuities, Journal of Risk and Insurance, 76, 31-52 (2009)
[37] Davidoff, T.; Brown, J. R.; Diamond, P. A., Annuities and Individual Welfare, American Economic Review, 95, 1573-1590 (2005)
[38] Daykin, C., Annuities and Alternative Ways of Providing Retirement Income (2004)
[39] Denardi, M.; French, E.; Jones, J. B., Differential Mortality, Uncertain Medical Expenses, and the Saving of Elderly Singles (2006)
[40] Denton, F. T.; Mountain, D. C.; Spencer, B. G., Age, Retirement and Expenditure Patterns: An Econometric Study of Older Canadian Households. Quantitative Studies in Economics and Population Research Reports 375 (2002), Hamilton, Ontario, , Canada: McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, , Canada
[41] Doyle, S.; Piggott, J.; Mitchell, O. S.; Smetters, K., Integrating Payouts: Annuity Design and Public Pension Benefits in Mandatory Defined Contribution Plans, The Pension Challenge Risk Transfers and Retirement Income Security, 89-101 (2003), Oxford: Oxford University Press, Oxford
[42] Dus, I.; Maurer, R.; Mitchell, O. S., Betting on Death and Capital Markets in Retirement: A Shortfall Risk Analysis of Life Annuities versus Phased Withdrawal Plans, Pension Research Council Working Paper. (2004)
[43] Dushi, I.; Webb, A., Household Annuitization Decisions: Simulations and Empirical Analyses, Journal of Pension Economics and Finance, 3, 109-143 (2004)
[44] European Union Memo, Sex Discrimination in Insurance Contracts: Statement by European Commission Vice-President Viviane Reding, the EU’s Justice Commissioner, on the European Court of Justice’s Ruling in the Test-Achats Case (2011)
[45] Finkelstein, A.; Poterba, J., Selection Effects in the Market for Individual Annuities: New Evidence from the United Kingdom, Economic Journal, 112, 28-50 (2005)
[46] Fishman, T., Shock of Gray (2010), New York: Scribner’s, New York
[47] Gardner, J.; Wadsworth, M., Who Would Buy an Annuity? (2004)
[48] Gerrard, R.; Haberman, S.; Vigna, E., The Management of Decumulation Risks in a Defined Contribution Pension Plan, North American Actuarial Journal, 10, 84-109 (2006) · Zbl 1479.91325
[49] Government of Canada, Canadians and Their Money: Building a Brighter Financial Future (2010)
[50] Greenwald, M.; Bryck, S. A.; Sondergeld, E. T., Spending and Investing in Retirement: Is There a Strategy (2006), Schaumburg, IL: Society of Actuaries and LIMRA International, Schaumburg, IL
[51] Hamilton, M.; Grady, P.; Sharpe, A., The Financial Circumstances of Elderly Canadians and the Implications for the Design of Canada’s Retirement Income System, The State of Economics in Canada: Festschrift in Honour of David Slater, 225-253 (2001), Montreal, Quebec, , Canada: McGill-Queen’s University Press, Montreal, Quebec, , Canada
[52] Health Canada, Canada’s Aging Population. Division of Aging and Seniors (2002), Ottawa: Minister of Public Works and Government Services Canada, Ottawa
[53] Horneff, W. J.; Maurer, R.; Mitchell, O. S.; Dus, I., Following the Rules: Integrating Asset Allocation and Annuitization in Retirement Portfolios, Journal of Public Economics, 42, 396-408 (2008) · Zbl 1141.91448
[54] Horneff, W. J.; Maurer, R. H.; Mitchell, O. S.; Stamos, M. Z. (2010)
[55] Hurd, M. D.; Rohwedder, S., Changes in Consumption and Activities in Retirement (2005), Ann Arbor: University of Michigan, Michigan Retirement Research Center, Ann Arbor
[56] Iannicola, D.; Parker, R., Barriers to Financial Advice For Non-Affluent Consumers (2010)
[57] Ibbotson Associates, Inc, Retirement Portfolio and Variable Annuity with Guaranteed Minimum Withdrawal Benefit (VA+GMWB) (2007), Chicago: Ibbotson Associates
[58] James, E.; Song, X., Annuity Markets around the World: Money’s Worth and Risk Intermediation (2001)
[59] Koijen, R. S. J.; Nijman, T. E.; Werker, B. J. M., Optimal Annuity Risk Management (August 30, 2009) (2009)
[60] Kotlikoff, L., Is Conventional Financial Planning Good for Your Financial Health (2006)
[61] Lafrenière, S. A.; Carrière, Y.; Martel, L.; Bélanger, A., Dependent Seniors at Home—Formal and Informal Help (2003), Health Reports, Statistics Canada
[62] Love, D. A.; Palumbo, M. G.; Smith, P. A., The Trajectory of Wealth in Retirement, Journal of Public Economics, 93, 191-208 (2009)
[63] Milevsky, M. A., Optimal Asset Allocation Towards the End of the Life Cycle: To Annuitize or Not to Annuitize?, The Journal of Risk and Insurance, 65, September, 401-26 (1998)
[64] Milevsky, M. A., How to Completely Avoid Outliving Your Money: An Introduction to Variable Payout Annuities for Retiring Canadians (2002), Toronto, , Canada: Working Paper, IFID Centre, Schulich School of Business, York University, Toronto, , Canada
[65] Milevsky, M. A.; Moore, K. S.; Young, V. R., Optimal Asset Allocation and Ruin-Minimization Annuitization Strategies, Mathematical Finance, 16, 647-671 (2006) · Zbl 1130.91031
[66] Milevsky, M. A.; Robinson, C., Self-Annuitization and Ruin in Retirement, with Discussion, North American Actuarial Journal, 4, 112-129 (2000) · Zbl 1083.60515
[67] Milevsky, M. A.; Young, V. R., Optimal Asset Allocation and the Real Option to Delay Annuitization: It’s Not Now-or-Never (2002), Toronto, , Canada: IFID Centre, Schulich School of Business, York University, Toronto, , Canada
[68] Milevsky, M. A.; Young, V. R., Annuitization and Asset Allocation, Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 31, 3138-3177 (2007) · Zbl 1163.91440
[69] Mills, M.; Young, M., Facing the New Facts of Retirement Income Adequacy, Benefits Quarterly, 40-47 (2004)
[70] Mitchell, O. S.; Poterba, J. M.; Warshawsky, M. J.; Brown, J. R., New Evidence on the Money’s Worth of Individual Annuities, American Economic Review, 89, 1299-1318 (1999)
[71] Modigliani, F., Life Cycle, Individual Thrift and the Wealth of Nations, American Economic Review, 76, 3, 297-313 (1986)
[72] Morrison, R. J., Assessing the Quality of DYNACAN’s Synthetically-Generated Earnings Histories (2000)
[73] Murtaugh, C. M.; Spillman, B. C.; Warshawsky, M. J., In Sickness and in Health: An Annuity Approach to Financing Long-Term Care and Retirement Income, Journal of Risk and Insurance, 68, 225-254 (2001)
[74] National Academy of Social Insurance, Uncharted Waters: Paying Benefits from Individual Accounts in Federal Retirement Policy (2005)
[75] Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), Private Pensions and the Financial Crisis: How to Ensure Adequate Retirement Income from Defined Contribution Pension Plans? Working Party on Private Pensions, OECD (2009)
[76] Orszag, M. J., Annuities: The Problems (2000)
[77] Orth, B., Approaches for Promoting Voluntary Annuitization (2008), Schaumburg, IL
[78] Pang, G.; Warshawsky, M., Optimizing the Equity-Bond-Annuity Portfolio in Retirement: The Impact of Uncertain Health Expenses, Insurance: Mathematics and Economics, 46, 198-209 (2010) · Zbl 1231.91223
[79] Pashchenko, S., Accounting for Non-Annuitization, Journal of Public Economics, 98, 53-67 (2013)
[80] Peijnenburg, K.; Nijman, T.; Werker, B., Health Cost Risk: A Potential Solution to the Annuity Puzzle (2011)
[81] Peijnenburg, K.; Nijman, T.; Werker, B., The Annuity Puzzle Remains a Puzzle (2011) · Zbl 1401.91181
[82] Perun, P., Putting Annuities Back into Savings Plans, Society of Actuaries Symposium on Managing Retirement Assets (2004)
[83] Polyak, I., New Advice to Retirees: Spend More at First, Cut Back Later, New York Times (2005)
[84] Poterba, J.; Venti, S. F.; Wise, D. A., The Drawdown of Personal Retirement Assets (2011)
[85] Poterba, J.; Venti, S. F.; Wise, D. A., The Composition and Drawdown of Wealth in Retirement, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 25, 95-118 (2011)
[86] Purcell, P., Pension Issues: Lump-Sum Distributions and Retirement Income Security (2005)
[87] Rappaport, A. M., The Role of Information and Expectations in Retirement Planning: Communicating Income vs. Lump Sums; Retirement Options (2008)
[88] Rappaport, A. M., Defaults for the Distribution of Retirement Assets: What Are the Issues? (2008)
[89] Rashbrooke, G. D., Asset Decumulation: Optimising Income Needs for Retirement (2007)
[90] Retire Early, What’s the “Safe” Withdrawal Rate in Retirement? 1998 (1998)
[91] Shapiro, A. F., Post-Retirement Financial Strategies from the Perspective of an Individual Who Is Approaching Retirement Age, Society of Actuaries, Schaumburg, IL (2010)
[92] Siegel, J. J., Perspectives on the Equity Premium, Financial Analysts Journal, 61, 61-73 (2005)
[93] Siegel, S., Housing Wealth and Retirement, The Actuary, 8, 18-23 (2011)
[94] Sinclair, S. H.; Smetters, K. A., Health Shocks and the Demand for Annuities (2004)
[95] Skinner, J., Are You Sure You’re Saving Enough for Retirement?, Journal of Economic Perspectives, American Economic Association, 21, 59-80 (2007)
[96] Smith, K. E.; Soto, M.; Penner, R. G., How Seniors Change Their Asset Holdings during Retirement (2009)
[97] Society of Actuaries Committee on Post-Retirement Needs and Risks, Managing Post-Retirement Risks—A Guide to Retirement Planning, Society of Actuaries, Schaumburg, 2008 (2008)
[98] Sondergeld, E. T.; Greenwald, M., Public Misperceptions about Retirement Security—Closing the Gaps (2007), Schaumburg, IL: Society of Actuaries and LIMRA International, Schaumburg, IL
[99] Stabile, G., Optimal Timing of the Annuity Purchases: A Combined Stochastic Control and Optimal Stopping Problem (2003)
[100] Steiner, K., Self-Insuring Your Retirement?Manage the Risks Involved like an Actuary (2010)
[101] Steiner, K., Sorry, but There’s Nothing Particularly Magical about the 4
[102] Sun, W.; Triest, R. K.; Webb, A., Optimal Retirement Asset Decumulation Strategies: The Impact of Housing Wealth (2007), Boston: Federal Reserve Bank of Boston, Boston
[103] Tomlinson, J., Sorting Out the Annuity Puzzle, Advisor Perspectives (2011)
[104] Tomlinson, J., An Innovative Solution to Retirement Income, Advisor Perspectives (2012)
[105] U. S. Department of Labor, Report on the Spend Down of Defined Contribution Assets at Retirement (2008), Washington, DC: ERISA Advisory Council, U.S. Department of Labor, Washington, DC
[106] U. S. Department of Labor, Taking the Mystery Out of Retirement Planning (2010), Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Labor, Washington, DC
[107] Venti, S. F.; Wise, D. A.; David, A. Wise, Aging and Housing Equity: Another Look, Perspectives on the Economics of Aging, 127-75 (2004), Chicago: University of Chicago Press for NBER, Chicago
[108] Wang, T.; Young, V. R., Optimal Reversible Annuities to Minimize the Probability of Lifetime Ruin (2010)
[109] Warner, J.; Pletter, S., The Personal Discount Rate: Evidence from Military Downsizing Programs, American Economic Review, 91, 33-53 (2001)
[110] Warshawsky, M.; Hill, T., Who Prefers Annuities? Observations about Retirement Decisions, Watson Wyatt Insider, 18, 12-21 (2008)
[111] Webb, A., Providing Income for a Lifetime: Bridging the Gap between Academic Research and Practical Advice (2009), Boston College.: Center for Retirement Research, Boston College.
[112] Whitaker, B., Managing Retirement, After You Really Retire, New York Times (2005)
[113] WISER, Making Your Money Last for a Lifetime: Why You Need to Know about Annuities (2001)
[114] WISER, Getting Ready to Retire: What You Need to Know about Annuities (2002)
[115] Yaari, M. E., Uncertain Lifetime, Life Insurance, and the Theory of the Consumer, Review of Economic Studies, 32, 137-150 (1965)
[116] Young, V. R., Optimal Investment Strategy to Minimize the Probability of Lifetime Ruin, North American Actuarial Journal, 8, 105-126 (2004) · Zbl 1085.60514
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.