×

Measuring the effects of price controls using mixed complementarity models. (English) Zbl 1430.90532

Summary: Government involvement in managing domestic prices of energy and other commodities is a major issue in emerging economies. We examine one aspect of the problem, price controls, when governments set or cap prices. We show how a mixed complementarity problem (MCP) formulation can be used to model and assess the impacts of price controls in multi-sector economic-equilibrium models. Both the gains from deregulation and the consequences of imposing new or altering existing regulations can thus be measured. We present three distinct models that capture different price-control situations: firms have to meet demand and receive an implicit subsidy, demand rationing occurs due to an associated price control constraint, and subsidies limit demand rationing. We present an approach to measuring the effects on the equilibrium in the first case and the levels of disequilibrium induced by price controls in the other cases. We also show how to determine the most efficient allocation program when a government engages in rationing. We illustrate the cases described by these models using markets that have or had price controls.

MSC:

90C33 Complementarity and equilibrium problems and variational inequalities (finite dimensions) (aspects of mathematical programming)
91B76 Environmental economics (natural resource models, harvesting, pollution, etc.)
91B24 Microeconomic theory (price theory and economic markets)
90C90 Applications of mathematical programming

Software:

RECS
PDFBibTeX XMLCite
Full Text: DOI

References:

[1] Abrell, J.; Rausch, S., Combining price and quantity controls under partitioned environmental regulation, Journal of Public Economics, 145, 1, 226-242 (2017)
[2] Alston, R.; Kearl, J. R.; Vaughan, M. B., Is there a consensus among economists in the 1990s, American Economic review, 82, 2, 203-209 (1992)
[3] Böhringer, C.; Rutherford, T. F., Combining bottom-up and top-down, Energy Economics, 30, 574-596 (2008)
[4] Capital, Aljazira, Research Department Saudi cement sector (2013), September
[5] Capital, Al Rajhi, Research Department December 11. Report on agriculture and food sector (2012), Available at
[6] Commander, S., A guide to the political economy of reforming energy subsidies (2012), Institute for the Study of Labor: Institute for the Study of Labor Bonn, Germany, IZA Policy Paper No. 5P.O. Box 7240, 53072
[7] Clements, B.; Jung, H. S.; Gupta, S., Real and distributive effects of petroleum price liberalization: the case study of Indonesia, Developing Economies, 45, 2, 220-237 (2007)
[8] Cowan, E. (1973). Rationing of “gas” appears likely, planners assert: Congress believed unwilling to approve tax increase to discourage driving, New York Times, (Nov), 29, 89.; Cowan, E. (1973). Rationing of “gas” appears likely, planners assert: Congress believed unwilling to approve tax increase to discourage driving, New York Times, (Nov), 29, 89.
[9] Darbouche, H., MENA’s growing natural gas deficit and the issue of domestic prices, Energy Strategy Reviews, 2, 1, 116-121 (2013)
[10] De la Grandville, O., Economic growth: a unified approach (2009), Cambridge University Press: Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK · Zbl 1167.91303
[11] Gouel, C., Modeling Commodity Markets in a Stochastic Context; a practical guide to the RECS toolbox version .5, AGRODEP Technical Note 06 (2013), working paper
[12] Greenberg, H. G.; Murphy, F. H., Computing regulated market equilibria with mathematical programming, Operations Research, 33, 5, 935-955 (1985) · Zbl 0579.90007
[13] Frum, D., How we got here: the 70’s: the decade that brought you modern life (for better or worse), 312-322 (2000), Basic Books
[14] Gabriel, S. A.; Conejo, A. J.; Fuller, J. D.; Hobbs, B. F., Complementarity modeling in energy markets (2012), (International Series in Operations Research & Management Science), Springer
[15] Gabriel, S.; Kiet, S.; Zhuang, J., A mixed complementarity-based equilibrium model of natural gas markets, Operations Research, 53, 5, 799-818 (2005) · Zbl 1165.91449
[16] Gabriel, S.; Shim, Y.; Conejo, A. J.; de la Torre, S.; García-Bertrand, R., A Benders decomposition method for discretely-constrained mathematical programs with equilibrium constraints, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 61, 9, 1404-1419 (2010) · Zbl 1206.90175
[17] Granado, F.; Coady, D., The unequal benefits of fuel subsidies: a review of evidence for developing countries, World Development, 40, 11, 2234-2248 (2012)
[18] Hobbs, B.; Pang, J., Nash-Cournot equilibria in electric power markets with piecewise linear demand functions and joint constraints, Operations Research, 55, 1, 113-127 (2007) · Zbl 1167.91356
[19] Hogan, W., Energy policy models for project independence, Computers & Operations Research, 2, 3-4, 251-271 (1975)
[20] Huppmann, D., Endogenous production capacity investment in natural gas market equilibrium models, European Journal of Operational Research, 231, 2, 503-506 (2013) · Zbl 1317.91058
[21] Kalt, J. P., The economics and politics of oil price regulation: federal policy in the post-embargo era (1981), MIT press: MIT press Cambridge
[22] Lifset, R., The energy crises of the 1970’s: Anticipations and reactions in the industrialized world, Historical Social Research, 39, 4, 22-42 (2014)
[23] Loulou, R., ETSAP-TIAM: The TIMES integrated assessment model Part 2: Model structure, Computational Management Science, 5, 1-2, 41-66 (2008) · Zbl 1175.90178
[24] Loulou, R.; Labriet, M., ETSAP-TIAM: The TIMES integrated assessment model Part I: Model structure, Computational Management Science, 5, 1-2, 7-40 (2008) · Zbl 1175.90179
[25] Masoumi, A.; Yu, M.; Nagurney, A., A supply chain generalized network oligopoly model for pharmaceuticals under brand differentiation and perishability, Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review, 48, 4, 762-780 (2012)
[26] Matar, W.; Murphy, F. H.; Pierru, A.; Rioux, B., Modeling the Saudi energy economy and its administered components: The KAPSARC energy model (2013), USAEE Working Paper No. 13-150. Available at
[27] Matar, W.; Murphy, F. H.; Pierru, A.; Rioux, B., Lowering Saudi Arabia’s fuel consumption and energy system costs without increasing end consumer prices, Energy Economics, 49, 558-569 (2015)
[28] Miranda, M.; Helmberger, P. G., The effects of commodity price stabilization programs, The American Economic Review, 78, 1, 46-58 (1988)
[29] Mujeri, M., Chowdhury, T., & Shahana, S. (2014). Energy sector in Bangladesh: An agenda for reforms. GSI Report. Ontario, Canada: International Institute for Sustainable Development.; Mujeri, M., Chowdhury, T., & Shahana, S. (2014). Energy sector in Bangladesh: An agenda for reforms. GSI Report. Ontario, Canada: International Institute for Sustainable Development.
[30] Mulet, L. (2009). Venezuela, poultry products annual, GAIN Report Number: VE9080, US Department of Agriculture, http://gain.fas.usda.gov/Recent
[31] Murphy, F. H.; Pierru, A.; Smeers, Y., A tutorial on building policy models as mixed-complementarity problems, Interfaces, 46, 6, 465-481 (2016)
[32] Murphy, F. H.; Sanders, R.; Shaw, S.; Thrasher, R., Modeling natural gas regulatory proposals using the project independence evaluation system, Operations Research, 29, 5, 876-902 (1981), September - October
[33] Rioux, B., Galkin, P., Murphy, F. H., Pierru, A., Malov, A., Feijoo Palacios, F., Li, Y., & Wu, K. (2018). The economic impact of price controls on China’s natural gas supply chain. KAPSARC Discussion Paper No. 31, KAPSARC, doi:10.30573/KS-2018-DP31; Rioux, B., Galkin, P., Murphy, F. H., Pierru, A., Malov, A., Feijoo Palacios, F., Li, Y., & Wu, K. (2018). The economic impact of price controls on China’s natural gas supply chain. KAPSARC Discussion Paper No. 31, KAPSARC, doi:10.30573/KS-2018-DP31
[34] Rioux, B.; Galkin, P.; Murphy, F. H.; Pierru, A., How do price caps in China’s electricity sector impact the economics of coal, power and wind? Potential gains from reforms, Energy Journal, 38, 63-75 (2017)
[35] Sequera, V. (2018). Venezuelans report big weight losses in 2017 as hunger hits. Reuters, (February), 21.; Sequera, V. (2018). Venezuelans report big weight losses in 2017 as hunger hits. Reuters, (February), 21.
[36] Trivedi, A., In Trump’s China industrial subsidies loom large, Wall Street Journal, 270, November, 16 (2016)
[37] Wogrin, S.; Hobbs, B.; Ralph, D.; Centeno, E.; Barquín, J., Open versus closed loop capacity equilibria in electricity markets under perfect and oligopolistic competition, Mathematical Programming, 140, 2, 295-322 (2013) · Zbl 1273.90113
[38] Yu, M.; Nagurney, A., Competitive food supply chain networks with application to fresh produce, European Journal of Operational Research, 224, 2, 273-282 (2013) · Zbl 1292.90034
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.