×

Optimal harvesting of fish stocks under a time-varying discount rate. (English) Zbl 1307.91143

Summary: Optimal control theory has been extensively used to determine the optimal harvesting policy for renewable resources such as fish stocks. In such optimisations, it is common to maximise the discounted utility of harvesting over time, employing a constant time discount rate. However, evidence from human and animal behaviour suggests that we have evolved to employ discount rates which fall over time, often referred to as “hyperbolic discounting”. This increases the weight on benefits in the distant future, which may appear to provide greater protection of resources for future generations, but also creates challenges of time-inconsistent plans. This paper examines harvesting plans when the discount rate declines over time. With a declining discount rate, the planner reduces stock levels in the early stages (when the discount rate is high) and intends to compensate by allowing the stock level to recover later (when the discount rate will be lower). Such a plan may be feasible and optimal, provided that the planner remains committed throughout. However, in practice there is a danger that such plans will be re-optimized and adjusted in the future. It is shown that repeatedly restarting the optimization can drive the stock level down to the point where the optimal policy is to harvest the stock to extinction. In short, a key contribution of this paper is to identify the surprising severity of the consequences flowing from incorporating a rather trivial, and widely prevalent, “non-rational” aspect of human behaviour into renewable resource management models. These ideas are related to the collapse of the Peruvian anchovy fishery in the 1970’s.

MSC:

91B76 Environmental economics (natural resource models, harvesting, pollution, etc.)
49J15 Existence theories for optimal control problems involving ordinary differential equations
49N90 Applications of optimal control and differential games
PDFBibTeX XMLCite
Full Text: DOI HAL

References:

[1] Aguero, M., A bioeonomic model of the Peruvian pelagic fishery, (Pauly, D.; Tsukuyama, I., The Peruvian Anchoveta and Its Upwelling Ecosystem: Three Decades of Change (1987), Instituto del Mar del Peru)
[2] Ainslie, G., Picoeconomics (1992), Cambridge University Press: Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK
[3] Akerlof, G. A., Procrastination and obedience, American Economic Review, 81, 1-19 (1991)
[4] Ariely, D.; Wertenbroch, K., Procrastination, deadlines, and performance: self-control by precommitment, Psychological Science, 13, 3, 219-224 (2002)
[5] Arrow, K., Aspects of the Theory of Risk Bearing (1965), Yrjö Hahnsson Foundation: Yrjö Hahnsson Foundation Helsinki, Finland
[6] Ashraf, N.; Karlan, D.; Yin, W., Tying Odysseus to the Mast: evidence from a commitment savings product in the philippines, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 121, 2, 635-672 (2006)
[7] Barrett, R.; Caulkins, J.; Yates, A.; Elliott, D., Population dynamics of the Peruvian anchovy, Mathematical Modelling, 6, 525-548 (1985)
[8] Beckerman, W.; Hepburn, C., Ethics of the discount rate in the Stern review on the economics of climate change, World Economics, 8, 187-208 (2007)
[9] Benabou, R.; Tirole, J., Willpower and personal rules, Journal of Political Economy, 112, 848-886 (2004)
[10] Chabris, C. F.; Laibson, D. I.; Schuldt, J. P., Intertemporal choice, (Durlauf, S.; Blume, L., The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, second ed (2008), Palgrave Macmillan: Palgrave Macmillan London)
[11] Clark, C., Mathematical Bioeconomics: Optimal Management of Renewable Resources (1990), John Wiley & Sons: John Wiley & Sons Hoboken, NJ · Zbl 0712.90018
[12] Conrad, J.; Clark, C., Natural Resource Economics (1987), Cambridge University Press: Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK
[13] Cropper, M.; Laibson, D., The implications of hyperbolic discounting for project evaluation, (Portney, P. R.; Weyant, J. P., Discounting and Intergenerational Equity (1999), Resources for the Future), 164-172
[14] Dasgupta, P., Discounting climate change, Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 37, 141-169 (2008) · Zbl 1165.91448
[15] Dasgupta, P.; Maskin, E., Uncertainty and hyperbolic discounting, The American Economic Review, 95, 4, 1290-1299 (2005)
[16] DellaVigna, S., Psychology and economics: evidence from the field, Journal of Economic Literature, 47, 315-372 (2009)
[17] DellaVigna, S.; Malmendier, U., Contract design and self-control: theory and evidence, Quarterly Journal of Economics., 119, 353-402 (2004) · Zbl 1090.91059
[18] DellaVigna, S.; Malmendier, U., Paying not to go to the gym, American Economic Review, 96, 3, 694-719 (2006)
[19] Frederick, S.; Loewenstein, G.; O’Donoghue, T., Time discounting and time preference: a critical review, Journal of Economic Literature, XL, 351-401 (2002)
[20] Fujii, T.; Karp, L., Numerical analysis of non-constant pure rate of time preference: a model of climate policy, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 56, 83-101 (2008) · Zbl 1210.91093
[21] Gine, X.; Karlan, D.; Zinman, J., Put your money where your butt is: a commitment contract for smoking cessation. Policy Research Working Paper Series, Vol. 4985 (2009), The World Bank
[22] Glantz, M., Science, politics and economics of the Peruvian anchoveta fishery, Marine Policy, 3, 3, 201-210 (1979)
[23] Green, L.; Myerson, J., Exponential versus hyperbolic discounting of delayed outcomes: risk and waiting times, American Zoologist, 36, 496-505 (1996)
[24] Groom, B.; Hepburn, C.; Koundouri, P.; Pearce, D., Discounting the future: the long and the short of it, Environmental and Resource Economics, 31, 1, 445-493 (2005)
[25] Gruber, J.; Koszegi, B., Is addiction rational? Theory and evidence, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 116, 1261-1305 (2001) · Zbl 1004.91508
[26] The Green Book: Appraisal and Evaluation in Central Government (2003), HM Treasury: HM Treasury London, UK
[27] Hanley, N.; Shogren, J.; White, B., Environmental Economics in Theory and Practice (2007), Palgrove Macmillan: Palgrove Macmillan Basingstoke, Hampshire, UK
[28] Harris, C.; Laibson, D., Dynamic choices of hyperbolic consumers, Econometrica, 69, 4, 935-957 (2001) · Zbl 1020.91042
[29] Heal, G., Climate economics: a meta-review and some suggestions for future research, Review of Environmental Economics and Policy, 3, 4-21 (2009)
[30] Hepburn, C., 2006. Use of discount rates in the estimation of the costs of inaction with respect to selected environmental concerns. Technical report, OECD Working Party on National Environmental Policy. ENV/EPOC/WPNEP(2006)13/FINAL.; Hepburn, C., 2006. Use of discount rates in the estimation of the costs of inaction with respect to selected environmental concerns. Technical report, OECD Working Party on National Environmental Policy. ENV/EPOC/WPNEP(2006)13/FINAL.
[31] Hepburn, C.; Duncan, S.; Papachristodoulou, A., Behavioural economics, hyperbolic discounting and environmental policy, Environmental and Resource Economics, 46, 189-206 (2010)
[32] Idyll, C., The anchovy crisis, Scientific American, 228, 22-29 (1973)
[33] Karp, L., Global warming and hyperbolic discounting, Journal of Public Economics, 89, 261-282 (2005)
[34] Karp, L., Tsur, Y., 2008. Time perspective and climate change policy. Technical report, University of California, Berkeley: Department of Agricultural and Resource Economics. CUDARE Working Papers No. 1062.; Karp, L., Tsur, Y., 2008. Time perspective and climate change policy. Technical report, University of California, Berkeley: Department of Agricultural and Resource Economics. CUDARE Working Papers No. 1062. · Zbl 1217.91136
[35] Kirby, K. N., Bidding on the future: evidence against normative discounting of delayed rewards, Journal of Experimental Psychology, 126, 54-70 (1997)
[36] Laibson, D., Golden eggs and hyperbolic discounting, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 112, 443-477 (1997) · Zbl 0882.90024
[37] Laibson, D. I.; Repetto, A.; Tobacman, J., Self-control and saving for retirement, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 1, 91-196 (1998)
[38] Laibson, D., Repetto, A., Tobacman, J., (forthcoming). Estimating discount functions with consumption choices over the lifecycle. American Economic Review.; Laibson, D., Repetto, A., Tobacman, J., (forthcoming). Estimating discount functions with consumption choices over the lifecycle. American Economic Review.
[39] Li, C.-Z.; Löfgren, K.-G., Renewable resources and economic sustainability: a dynamic analysis with heterogeneous time preferences, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 40, 236-250 (2000) · Zbl 0964.91026
[40] Mazur, J., 1987. An Adjusting Procedure for Studying Delayed Reinforcement. In: The Effect of Delay and of Intervening Events on Reinforcement Value of Quantitative Analyses of Behavior, Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ, pp. 55-73.; Mazur, J., 1987. An Adjusting Procedure for Studying Delayed Reinforcement. In: The Effect of Delay and of Intervening Events on Reinforcement Value of Quantitative Analyses of Behavior, Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ, pp. 55-73.
[41] McClure, S. M.; Ericson, K. M.; Laibson, D. I.; Loewenstein, G.; Cohen, J. D., Time discounting for primary rewards, Journal of Neuroscience, 27, 5796-5804 (2007)
[42] Nordhaus, W. D., A review of the stern review on the economics of climate change, Journal of Economic Literature, 45, 686-702 (2007)
[43] O’Donoghue, T.; Rabin, M., Doing it now or later, American Economic Review, 89, 103-124 (1999)
[44] O’Donoghue, T.; Rabin, M., Incentives for procrastinators, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 114, 769-816 (1999) · Zbl 0946.91044
[45] Pearce, D.; Groom, B.; Hepburn, C.; Koundouri, P., Valuing the future: recent advances in social discounting, World Economics, 4, 2, 121-141 (2003)
[46] Pratt, J. W., Risk aversion in the large and the small, Econometrica, 32, 132-136 (1964) · Zbl 0132.13906
[47] Ramsey, F., A mathematical theory of saving, Economic Journal, 138, 543559 (1928)
[48] Read, D., Is time-discounting hyperbolic or subadditive?, Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 23, 1, 5-32 (2001) · Zbl 0986.91013
[49] Rubinstein, A., Is it ‘economics and psychology’?: the case of hyperbolic discounting, International Economic Review, 44, 4, 1207-1216 (2003)
[50] Sethi, S.; Thompson, G., Optimal Control Theory: Applications to Management Science and Economics (2000), Springer: Springer New York, NY · Zbl 0998.49002
[51] Shogren, J.; Settle, C., Hyperbolic discounting and time inconsistency in a native-exotic conflict, Resources and Energy Economics, 26, 255-274 (2004)
[52] Sozou, P., On hyperbolic discounting and uncertain hazard rates, Proceedings of Royal Society London, Part B, 265, 2015-2020 (1998)
[53] Stern, N., The Economics of Climate Change: The Stern Review (2007), Cambridge University Press: Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK
[54] Strotz, R. H., Myopia and inconsistency in dynamic utility maximization, Review of Economic Studies, 23, 165-180 (1956)
[55] Thaler, R. H., Some empirical evidence on dynamic inconsistency, Economic Letters, 8, 201-207 (1981)
[56] Voinov, A.; Farley, J., Reconciling sustainability, systems theory and discounting, Ecological Economics, 63, 104-113 (2007)
[57] Walters, C.; Maguire, J.-J., Lessons for stock assessment from the northern cod collapse, Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries, 6, 125-137 (1996)
[58] Weitzman, M., Why the far-distant future should be discounted at its lowest possible rate, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 36, 201-208 (1998) · Zbl 0924.90049
[59] Weitzman, M. L., A review of the stern review of the economics of climate change, Journal of Economic Literature, 45, 703-724 (2007)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.