Bankruptcy prediction in banks and firms via statistical and intelligent techniques – a review. (English) Zbl 1114.91305

Summary: A comprehensive review of the work done, during the 1968–2005, in the application of statistical and intelligent techniques to solve the bankruptcy prediction problem faced by banks and firms. The review is categorized by taking the type of technique applied to solve this problem as an important dimension. Accordingly, the papers are grouped in the following families of techniques: (i) statistical techniques, (ii) neural networks, (iii) case-based reasoning, (iv) decision trees, (iv) operational research, (v) evolutionary approaches, (vi) rough set based techniques, (vii) other techniques subsuming fuzzy logic, support vector machine and isotonic separation and (viii) soft computing subsuming seamless hybridization of all the above-mentioned techniques. Of particular significance is that in each paper, the review highlights the source of data sets, financial ratios used, country of origin, time line of study and the comparative performance of techniques in terms of prediction accuracy wherever available. The review also lists some important directions for future research.


91B06 Decision theory
62P20 Applications of statistics to economics
90C59 Approximation methods and heuristics in mathematical programming
90C70 Fuzzy and other nonstochastic uncertainty mathematical programming
Full Text: DOI


[1] Ahn, B.A.; Cho, S.S.; Kim, C.Y., The integrated methodology of rough set theory and artificial neural network for business failure prediction, Expert systems with applications, 18, 65-74, (2000)
[2] Alam, P.; Booth, D.; Lee, K.; Thordarson, T., The use of fuzzy clustering algorithm and self-organizing neural network for identifying potentially failing banks: an experiment study, Expert systems with applications, 18, 185-199, (2000)
[3] Altman, E.I., Financial ratios, discriminant analysis and the prediction of corporate bankruptcy, Journal of finance, 23, 589-609, (1968)
[4] Altman, E.I.; Marco, G.; Varetto, F., Corporate distress diagnosis: comparisons using linear discriminant analysis and neural networks (the Italian experience), Journal of banking and finance, 18, 505-529, (1994)
[5] Altman, E.I.; Haldeman, R.G.; Narayanan, P., ZETA ANALYSIS, a new model to identify bankruptcy risk of corporations, Journal of banking and finance, 1, 29-54, (1977)
[6] Andres, J.D.; Landajo, M.; Lorca, P., Forecasting business profitability by using classification techniques: A comparative analysis based on a Spanish case, European journal of operational research, 167, 518-542, (2005) · Zbl 1074.90544
[7] Atiya, A.F., Bankruptcy prediction for credit risk using neural networks: A survey and new results, IEEE transactions on neural networks, 12, 4, 929-935, (2001)
[8] Back, B.; Laitinen, T.; Sere, K., Neural network and genetic algorithm for bankruptcy prediction, Expert systems with applications, 11, 4, 407-413, (1996)
[9] J. Baek and S. Cho, Bankruptcy Prediction for credit risk using an auto associative neural networks in Korean firms, in: IEEE International Conference on Computational Intelligence for Financial Engineering, Hong-Kong, 2003.
[10] Banks, W.J.; Prakash, L.A., On the performance of linear programming heuristics applied on a quadratic transformation in the classification problem, European journal of operational research, 74, 23, 23-28, (1994) · Zbl 0798.90132
[11] Barniv, R.; Anurag, A.; Leach, R., Predicting the out come following bankruptcy filing: A three state classification using NN, International journal of intelligent systems in accounting, finance and management, 6, 177-194, (1997)
[12] Bell, T.B., Neural nets or the logit model? A comparison of each model’s ability to predict commercial bank failures, International journal of intelligent systems in accounting, finance and management, 6, 249-264, (1997)
[13] H. Bian, L. Mazlack, Fuzzy-rough nearest neighbour classification approach, in: 22nd International Conference of the North American Fuzzy Information Processing Society (NAFIPS 2003) Proceedings Chicago, 2003, pp. 500-505.
[14] J.C. Bioch, V. Popova, Bankruptcy prediction with rough sets, ERIM Report Series Research in Management (ERS-2001-11-LIS), 2001.
[15] Brewer, E.; Jackson, W.; Moser, J., Alligators in the swamp: the impact of derivatives on the financial performance of depository institutions, Journal of money, credit and banking, 28, 478-496, (1996)
[16] Bryant, S.M., A case-based reasoning approach to bankruptcy prediction modeling, Intelligent systems in accounting, finance and management, 6, 195-214, (1997)
[17] Calderon, T.G.; Cheh, J.J., A roadmap for future neural networks research in auditing and risk assessment, International journal of accounting information systems, 3, 203-236, (2002)
[18] Canbas, S.; Cabuk, A.; Kilic, S.B., Prediction of commercial bank failure via multivariate statistical analysis of financial structure: the turkish case, European journal of operational research, 166, 528-546, (2005) · Zbl 1064.91511
[19] Cielen, A.; Peeters, L.; Vanhoof, K., Bankruptcy prediction using a data envelopment analysis, European journal of operational research, 154, 526-532, (2004) · Zbl 1146.90441
[20] Cole, R.; Gunther, J., A CAMEL rating’s shelf life, Federal reserve bank of Dallas review, 13-20, (1995)
[21] Cooper, C.A.; Rhodes, E.W.W., Measuring the efficiency of decision making units, European journal of operational research, 2, 429-444, (1978) · Zbl 0416.90080
[22] Cristiamini, N.; Shawe-Taylor, J., An introduction to support vector machines, (2000), Cambridge university press Cambridge, England
[23] M. Daubie, N. Meskens, Business failure prediction: A review and analysis of the literature. Working Paper, Department of Productions and Operations Management, Catholic University of Mons, Belgium, 2002, pp. 1-15.
[24] Dietrich, J.R.; Kaplan, R.S., Empirical analysis of the loan classification decision, The accounting review, 57, 18-38, (1982)
[25] Dimitras, A.I.; Zanakis, S.H.; Zopounidis, C., A survey of business failure with an emphasis on prediction method and industrial applications, European journal of operational research, 90, 487-513, (1996) · Zbl 0907.90038
[26] Dimitras, A.I.; Slowinski, R.; Susmaga, R.; Zopounidis, C., Business failure prediction using rough sets, European journal of operational research, 114, 263-280, (1999) · Zbl 0963.91023
[27] Elhadi, M.T., Bankruptcy support system: taking advantage of information retrieval and case-based reasoning, Export systems with applications, 18, 215-219, (2000)
[28] Fahlman, S.E.; Lebiere, C., The cascade-correlation learning architecture, (), 524-532
[29] Fletcher, D.; Goss, E., Application forecasting with neural networks an application using bankruptcy data, Information and management, 24, 159-167, (1993)
[30] Fraser, D., The determinants of bank profits: an analysis of extremes, Financial review, 11, 69-87, (1976)
[31] Frydman, H.; Altman, E.I.; Kao, D., Introducing recursive partitioning for financial classification: the case of financial distress, Journal of finance, 40, 1, 269-291, (1985)
[32] R. Gady, Anatomy of profitable medium-size banks in the fourth district, 1966-1970, Economic Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, 1972, pp. 20-32.
[33] J. Gehrke, R. Ramakrishnan, W.Y. Loh, BOAT-optimistic decision tree construction, in: Proceedings ACM SIGMOD International Conference Management of Data, Philadelphia, PA, 1999, pp. 169-180.
[34] Gentry, J.; Newbold, A.; Whitford, D., Classifying bankrupt firms with funds flow components, Journal of accounting research, 23, 11(1), 146-160, (1985)
[35] Gersho, A.; Gray, R.M., Vector quantization and signal compression, (1992), Kluwer Norwell, MA · Zbl 0782.94001
[36] Gorzalczany, M.B.; Pista, Z., Neuro-fuzzy approach versus rough-set inspired methodology for intelligent decision support, Information science, 120, 45-68, (1999)
[37] Greco, S.; Matarazzo, B.; Slowinski, R., A new rough set approach to evaluation of bankruptcy risk, (), 121-136
[38] Greco, S.; Matarazzo, B.; Slowinski, R., A new rough set approach to multicriteria and multiattribute classification, Rough sets and current trends in computing, Berlin, 60-67, (1998)
[39] Greco, S.; Matarazzo, B.; Slowinski, R., Decision rule approach, (), 507-562, (Chapter 13) · Zbl 1072.90534
[40] Greco, S.; Matarazzo, B.; Slowinski, R., Rough sets methodology for sorting problems in presence of multiple attributes and criteria, European journal of operational research, 138, 2, 247-259, (2002) · Zbl 1008.90509
[41] Greco, S.; Matarazzo, B.; Slowinski, R., Rough approximation by dominance relations, International journal of intelligent systems, 17, 2, 153-171, (2002) · Zbl 0997.68135
[42] Greco, S.; Matarazzo, B.; Slowinski, R., Multicriteria classification, (), 318-328, (Chapter 16.1.9)
[43] Greco, S.; Matarazzo, B.; Slowinski, R., Rough sets theory for multicriteria decision analysis, European journal of operational research, 129, 1, 1-47, (2001) · Zbl 1008.91016
[44] J. Haslem, A. Scheraga, C.A. Bedingfield, P. James, An Analysis of the Foreign and Domestic Balance Sheet Strategies of the U.S. Banks and Their Association to Profitability Performance, Management International Review. First Quarter, Wiesbaden, 1992.
[45] Ignizio, J.P.; Soltyas, J.R., Simultaneous design and training of ontogenic neural network classifier, Computers operations research, 23, 6, 535-546, (1996) · Zbl 0854.68087
[46] Jeng, B.; Jeng, Y.-M.; Liang, T.-P., FILM: A fuzzy learning method for automated knowledge acquisition, Decision support systems, 21, 61-73, (1997)
[47] Jo, H.; Han, I.; lee, H., Bankruptcy prediction using case-based reasoning, neural network and discriminant analysis for bankruptcy prediction, Expert systems with applications, 13, 2, 97-108, (1997)
[48] Jo, H.; Han, I., Integration of case-based forecasting, neural network and discriminant analysis for bankruptcy prediction, Expert systems with applications, 11, 4, 415-422, (1996)
[49] Joachimsthaler, E.A.; Stam, A., Four approaches to the classification problem in discriminant analysis: an experimental study, Decision sciences, 19, 322-333, (1988)
[50] Johnson, R.A.; Wichern, D.W., Applied multivariate statistical analysis, (1988), Prentice-Hall Englewood Cliffs, NJ · Zbl 0663.62061
[51] Jones, S.; Hensher, D.A., Predicting firm financial distress: A mixed logit model, Accounting review, 79, 4, 1011-1038, (2004)
[52] Kao, C.; Liu, S.-T., Prediction bank performance with financial forecasts: A case of Taiwan commercial banks, Journal of banking & finance, 28, 2353-2368, (2004)
[53] Karels, G.V.; Prakash, A.J., Multivariate normality and forecasting of business bankruptcy, Journal of business finance and accounting, 14, 4, (1987)
[54] Kaski, S.; Sinkkonen, J.; Peltonen, J., Bankruptcy analysis with self-organizing maps in learning metrics, IEEE transactions on neural networks, 12, 4, (2001) · Zbl 0997.68711
[55] Kiviluoto, K., Predicting bankruptcies with self organizing map, Neurocomputing, 21, 191-201, (1998) · Zbl 0928.68138
[56] Kohonen, T., Self-organizing maps, (1997), Springer-Verlag Berlin · Zbl 0866.68085
[57] Kolari, J.; Glennon, D.; Shin, H.; Caputo, M., Predicting large US commercial bank failures, Journal of economics and business, 54, 32 1, 361-387, (2002)
[58] Kolodner, J.L., Case based reasoning, (1993), Morgan Kaufman CA
[59] Koza, J.R., Genetic programming: on the programming of computers by means of natural selection, (1992), Massachusetts Institute of Technology Cambridge, MA · Zbl 0850.68161
[60] Kwast, M.; Rose, J., Pricing, operating efficiency and profitability among large commercial banks, Journal of banking and finance, 6, 233-254, (1982)
[61] Lachenbruch, P.A., An almost unbiased method of obtaining confidence intervals for the probability of misclassification in discriminant analysis, Biometrics, December, 639-645, (1967)
[62] Lacher, R.C.; Coats, P.K.; Sharma, S.C.; Fantc, L.F., A neural network for classifying the financial health of a firm, European journal of operational research, 85, 53-65, (1995) · Zbl 0910.90016
[63] Lam, K.F.; Moy, J.W., Combining discriminant methods in solving classification problems in two-group discriminant analysis, European journal of operational research, 138, 294-301, (2002) · Zbl 1007.62057
[64] Lam, M., Neural networks techniques for financial performance prediction: integrating fundamental and technical analysis, Decision support systems, 37, 567-581, (2004)
[65] Lee, K.C.; Han, I.; Kwon, Y., Hybrid neural network models for bankruptcy predictions, Decision support systems, 18, 63-72, (1996)
[66] Lee, K.; Booth, D.; Alam, P., A comparison of supervised and unsupervised neural networks in predicting bankruptcy of Korean firms, Expert systems with applications, 29, 1-16, (2005)
[67] Leshno, M.; Spector, Y., Neural network prediction analysis: the bankruptcy case, Neurocomputing, 10, 125-147, (1996)
[68] Liang, T.P., A composite approach to inducing knowledge for expert systems design, Management science, 38, 1, 145-154, (1992)
[69] Lin, F.Y.; McClean, S., A datamining approach to the prediction of corporate failure, Knowledge based systems, 14, 189-195, (2001)
[70] Marais, M.L.; Patel, J.; Wolfson, M., The experimental design of classification models: an application of recursive partitioning and bootstrapping to commercial bank loan classifications, Journal of accounting research, 22, 87-113, (1984)
[71] Martin, D., Early warning of bank failure: A logit regression approach, Journal of banking and finance, 1, 249-276, (1977)
[72] McCulloch, W.S.; Pitts, W.A., Logical calculus of ideas immanent in nervous activity, Bulletin of mathematical biophysics, 5, 115-133, (1943) · Zbl 0063.03860
[73] McKee, T.E., Developing a bankruptcy prediction model via rough sets theory, International journal of intelligent systems in accounting, finance and management, 9, 59-173, (2000)
[74] McKee, T.E.; Lensberg, T., Genetic programming and rough sets: A hybrid approach to bankruptcy classification, European journal of operational research, 138, 436-451, (2002) · Zbl 1131.90465
[75] McKee, T.E., Rough sets bankruptcy prediction models versus auditor signaling rates, Journal of forecasting, 22, 569-589, (2003)
[76] Merton, R., On the pricing of corporate debt: the risk structure of interest rates, Journal of finance, 29, 449-470, (1974)
[77] Messier, W.F.; Hansen, J., Inducing rules for expert system development: an example using default and bankruptcy data, Management science, 12, 1403-1415, (1988)
[78] S. Michael, D. Georgios, M. Nikolaos, Z. Constantin, A fuzzy knowledge-based decision aiding method for the assessment of financial risk: The case of corporate bankruptcy prediction, in: European Symposium on Intelligent Techniques, Crete, Greece, 1999.
[79] Min, J.H.; Lee, Y.-C., Bankruptcy prediction using support vector machine (SVM) with optimal choice of kernel function parameters, Expert systems with applications, 28, 603-614, (2005)
[80] Nanda, S.; Pendharkar, P., Linear models for minimizing misclassification costs in bankruptcy prediction, International journal of intelligent systems in accounting, finance and management, 10, 155-168, (2001)
[81] Moody, J.; Darken, C.J., Fast learning in networks of locally-tuned processing units, Neural computing, 1, 281-294, (1989)
[82] M. Odom, R. Sharda, A neural network for bankruptcy prediction, in: IJCNN International Conference on Neural Networks, San Diego, CA, 1990.
[83] Ohlson, J.A., Financial rations and the probabilistic prediction of bankruptcy, Journal of accounting research, 18, 109-131, (1980)
[84] O’Leary, D.E., Using neural network to predict corporate failure, International journal of intelligent systems in accounting finance and management, 7, 187-197, (1998)
[85] Olmeda, I.; Fernandez, E., Hybrid classifiers for financial multicriteria decision making: the case of bankruptcy prediction, Computational economics, 10, 317-335, (1997) · Zbl 0883.90046
[86] Park, C.-S.; Han, I., A case-based reasoning with the feature weights derived by analytic hierarchy process for bankruptcy prediction, Expert systems with applications, 23, 3, 255-264, (2002)
[87] Pawlak, Z., Rough sets, International journal of computer and information science, 11, 341-356, (1982) · Zbl 0501.68053
[88] Pendharkar, P.C.; Rodger, J.A., An empirical study of impact of crossover operators on the performance of non-binary genetic algorithm based neural approaches for classification, Computers and operations research, 31, 481-498, (2004) · Zbl 1197.62069
[89] Piramuthu, S.; Ragavan, H.; Shaw, M.J., Using feature construction to improve the performance of the neural networks, Management science, 44, 3, (1998) · Zbl 0988.90522
[90] Platt, H.D.; Platt, M.B.; Pedersen, J., Bankruptcy discrimination with real variables, Journal of business finance and accounting, 21, 491-509, (1994)
[91] J.R. Quinlan, Decision trees as probabilistic classifiers, in: Proceedings of 4th International Workshop Machine Learning, Irvine, CA, 1987, pp. 31-37.
[92] Rahimian, E.; Singh, S.; Thammachote, T.; Virmani, R., Bankruptcy prediction by neural network, ()
[93] Rashad, A.-K.; El-Sheshai, K.M., Information choice and utilization in an experiment on default prediction, Journal of accounting research, 18, 2, (1980)
[94] Rud, O.P., Data mining cook book, (2000), John Wiely and Sons New York
[95] Rumelhart, D.E.; Hinton, G.E.; Williams, R.J., Learning internal representations by error propagation, (), 318-362
[96] Russell, S.; Norvig, P., Artificial intelligence. A modern approach, (2003), Prentice-Hall New Jersey, USA
[97] Ryu, Y.U.; Yue, W.T., Firm bankruptcy prediction: experimental comparison of isotonic separation and other classification approaches, IEEE transactions on systems, management and cybernetics-part A: systems and humans, 35, 5, 727-737, (2005)
[98] Salchenberger, L.; Mine, C.; Lash, N., Neural networks: A tool for predicting thrift failures, Decision sciences, 23, 899-916, (1992)
[99] Scott, J., The probability of bankruptcy, Journal of banking and finance, 5, 317-344, (1981)
[100] Serrano-Cinca, C., Self organizing neural networks for financial diagnosis, Decision support systems, 17, 227-238, (1996)
[101] R. Sharda, R.L. Wilson, Performance comparison issues in neural network experiments for classification problems, in: Proceedings of the 26th Hawai International Conference on System Scientists, 1993.
[102] Shin, K.-S.; Lee, Y.-J., A genetic algorithm application in bankruptcy prediction modeling, Expert systems with applications, 23, 3, 321-328, (2002)
[103] Slowinski, R.; Greco, S.; Matarazzo, B., Rough set based decision support, (), 475-527, (Chapter 16)
[104] Specht, D.F., Probabilistic neural networks, Neural networks, 3, 110-118, (1990)
[105] Sung, T.K.; Chank, N.; Lee, G., Dynamics of modelling in data mining: interpretive approach to bankruptcy prediction, Journal of management information systems, 16, 63-85, (1999)
[106] Swicegood, P.; Clark, J.A., Off-site monitoring for predicting bank under performance: A comparison of neural networks, discriminant analysis and professional human judgment, International journal of intelligent systems in accounting, finance and management, 10, 169-186, (2001)
[107] Tam, K.Y., Neural network models and the prediction of bank bankruptcy, Omega, 19, 5, 429-445, (1991)
[108] Tam, K.Y.; Kiang, M., Predicting bank failures: A neural network approach, Decision sciences, 23, 926-947, (1992) · Zbl 0763.90062
[109] Tanaka, H.; Lee, H., Interval regression analysis by quadratic programming approach, IEEE transactions on fuzzy systems, 6, 4, 473-481, (1998)
[110] Tay, F.E.H.; Shen, L., Economic and financial prediction using rough set model, European journal of operational research, 141, 641-659, (2002) · Zbl 1081.91597
[111] (), (Chapters 8-13)
[112] Tseng, F.-M.; Lin, L., A quadratic interval logit model for forecasting bankruptcy, Omega, 33, 85-91, (2005)
[113] Tsukuda, J.; Baba, S.-I., Predicting Japanese corporate bankruptcy in terms of finance data using neural network, Computers and industrial engineering, 27, 1-4, 445-448, (1994)
[114] Tung, W.L.; Quek, C.; Cheng, P., Genso-EWS: A novel neural-fuzzy based early warning system for predicting bank failures, Neural networks, 17, 567-587, (2004)
[115] Vapnik, V., ()
[116] Varetto, F., Genetic algorithm applications in the analysis of insolvency risk, Journal of banking and finance, 22, 1421-1439, (1998)
[117] Wall, L., Why are some banks more profitable than others?, Journal of bank research, 15, 240-256, (1985)
[118] J. Wallrafen, P. Protzel, H. Popp, Genetically optimized neural network classifiers for bankruptcy prediction, in: Proceedings of the 29 the Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, 1996.
[119] West, R.C., A factor analytic approach to bank condition, Journal of banking and finance, 9, 253-266, (1985)
[120] Wilcox, J.W., A prediction of business failure using accounting data, empirical research in accounting: selected studies, Journal of accounting research, Suppl., 163-179, (1973)
[121] Wilson, R.L.; Sharda, R., Bankruptcy prediction using neural networks, Decision support systems, 11, 545-557, (1994)
[122] Yang, Z.R.; Platt, M.B.; Platt, H.D., Probability neural network in bankruptcy prediction, Journal of business research, 44, 67-74, (1999)
[123] A.Y.N. Yip, Predicting business failure with a case-based reasoning approach, lecture notes in computer science, in: M.G. Negoita, R.J. Howlett, L.C. Jain (Eds.), Knowledge-Based Intelligent Information and Engineering Systems: 8th International Conference, KES 2004, Wellington, New Zealand, September 3215/2004, Proceedings, Part III, 2004, pp. 20-25.
[124] Zadeh, L.A., Fuzzy sets, Information and control, 8, 338-353, (1965) · Zbl 0139.24606
[125] Zadeh, L.A., Soft computing and fuzzy logic, IEEE software, 11, 6, 48-56, (1994)
[126] Zhang, G.; Hu, M.Y.; Patuwo, B.E.; Indro, D.C., Artificial neural networks and bankruptcy prediction general framework and cross-validated analysis, European journal of operational research, 116, 16-32, (1999) · Zbl 0995.62506
[127] Zimmermann, H.J., Fuzzy set theory and its applications, (1996), Kluwer Academic Publishers London · Zbl 0845.04006
[128] Zmijewski, M., Methodological issues related to the estimation of financial distress prediction models, Journal of accounting research, 22, 59-82, (1984)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.