Data envelopment analysis (DEA) – thirty years on.

*(English)*Zbl 1180.90151Summary: This paper provides a sketch of some of the major research thrusts in data envelopment analysis (DEA) over the three decades since the appearance of the seminal work of Charnes et al. [A.Charnes, W.W. Cooper, E. L. Rhodes, Measuring the efficiency of decision making units. Eur. J. Oper. Res. 2, 429–444 (1978; Zbl 0416.90080)]. The focus herein is primarily on methodological developments, and in no manner does the paper address the many excellent applications that have appeared during that period. Specifically, attention is primarily paid to (1) the various models for measuring efficiency, (2) approaches to incorporating restrictions on multipliers, (3) considerations regarding the status of variables, and (4) modeling of data variation.

##### MSC:

90B50 | Management decision making, including multiple objectives |

90-02 | Research exposition (monographs, survey articles) pertaining to operations research and mathematical programming |

##### Software:

DEAFrontier
PDF
BibTeX
XML
Cite

\textit{W. D. Cook} and \textit{L. M. Seiford}, Eur. J. Oper. Res. 192, No. 1, 1--17 (2009; Zbl 1180.90151)

Full Text:
DOI

##### References:

[1] | Aigner, D.J.; Chu, S.F., On estimating the industry production frontiers, American economic review, 56, 826-839, (1968) |

[2] | Aigner, D.J.; Lovell, C.A.K.; Schmidt, P., Formulation and estimation of stochastic frontier production models, Journal of econometrics, 6, 21-37, (1977) · Zbl 0366.90026 |

[3] | Ali, A.I.; Seiford, L.M., Translation invariance in data envelopment analysis, Operations research letters, 9, 403-405, (1990) · Zbl 0711.90006 |

[4] | Allen, R.; Athanasopoulos, A.; Dyson, R.G.; Thanassoulis, E., Weights restrictions and value judgments in data envelopment analysis: evolution, development and future directions, Annals of operations research, 73, 13-34, (1997) · Zbl 0890.90002 |

[5] | Andersen, P.; Petersen, N.C., A procedure for ranking efficient units in DEA, Management science, 39, 1261-1264, (1993) · Zbl 0800.90096 |

[6] | Anderson, T.R.; Hollingsworth, K.B.; Inman, L.B., The fixed weighting nature of a cross-evaluation model, Journal of productivity analysis, 18, 1, 249-255, (2002) |

[7] | Aparicio, J.; Ruiz, J.; Sirvent, I., Closest targets and minimum distance to the Pareto-efficient frontier in DEA, Journal of productivity analysis, 28, 209-218, (2007) |

[8] | Banker, R.D., Estimating most productive scale size using data envelopment analysis, European journal of operational research, 17, 35-44, (1984) · Zbl 0538.90030 |

[9] | Banker, R.D., Maximum likelihood, consistency and data envelopment analysis: A statistical foundation, Management science, 39, 1265-1273, (1993) · Zbl 0798.90009 |

[10] | Banker, R.D.; Maindiratta, A., Maximum likelihood estimation of monotone and concave production frontiers, Journal of productivity analysis, 3, 401-415, (1992) |

[11] | Banker, R.D.; Morey, R., Efficiency analysis for exogenously fixed inputs and outputs, Operations research, 34, 4, 513-521, (1986) · Zbl 0609.90074 |

[12] | Banker, R.D.; Morey, E.C., The use of categorical variables in data envelopment analysis, Management science, 32, 12, 1613-1627, (1986) |

[13] | Banker, R.D.; Natarasan, R., Statistical tests based on DEA efficiency scores, (), (Chapter 11) · Zbl 1085.90507 |

[14] | Banker, R.D.; Charnes, A.; Cooper, W.W., Some models for estimating technical and scale inefficiencies in data envelopment analysis, Management science, 30, 1078-1092, (1984) · Zbl 0552.90055 |

[15] | Banker, R.; Das, S.; Datar, S., Analysis of cost variances for management control in hospitals, Research in governmental and nonprofit accounting, 5, 268-291, (1989) |

[16] | Banker, R.D.; Chang, H.; Cooper, W.W., Simulation studies of efficiency, returns to scale and misspecification with nonlinear functions in DEA, Annals of operations research, 66, 233-253, (1996) · Zbl 0864.90013 |

[17] | Beasley, J., Determining teaching and research efficiencies, Journal of the operational research society, 46, 441-452, (1995) · Zbl 0830.90091 |

[18] | Bessent, A.; Bessent, W.; Elam, J.; Clark, T., Efficiency frontier determination by constrained facet analysis, Journal of operational research society, 36, 785-796, (1988) · Zbl 0655.90045 |

[19] | Briec, W., Holder distance function and measurement of technical efficiency, Journal of productivity analysis, 11, 2, 111-131, (1999) |

[20] | Chang, Y.; Sueyoshi, T., An interactive application of DEA in microcomputers, Computer science in economics and management, 4, 1, 51-64, (1991) · Zbl 0729.90693 |

[21] | Charnes, A.; Cooper, W.W., Programming with linear fractional functionals, Naval research logistics quarterly, 9, 67-88, (1962) · Zbl 0127.36901 |

[22] | Charnes, A.; Neralic, L., Sensitivity analysis in data envelopment analysis, Glasnik matematicki, 27, 191-201, (1992) · Zbl 0776.90004 |

[23] | Charnes, A.; Cooper, W.W.; Rhodes, E.L., Measuring the efficiency of decision making units, European journal of operational research, 2, 429-444, (1978) · Zbl 0416.90080 |

[24] | Charnes, A.; Cooper, W.W.; Rhodes, E.L., Evaluating program and managerial efficiency: an application of data envelopment analysis to program follow through, Management science, 27, 668-697, (1981) |

[25] | Charnes, A.; Clarke, C.; Cooper, W.W.; Golany, B., A development study of DEA in measuring the effect of maintenance units in the U.S. air force, Annals of operations research, 2, 95-112, (1985) |

[26] | Charnes, A.; Cooper, W.W.; Golany, B.; Seiford, L.M.; Stutz, J., Foundations of data envelopment analysis and pareto – koopmans empirical production functions, Journal of econometrics, 30, 91-107, (1985) · Zbl 0582.90007 |

[27] | Charnes, A.; Cooper, W.W.; Thrall, R.M., Classifying and characterizing inefficiencies in data envelopment analysis, Operations research letters, 5/3, 105-110, (1986) · Zbl 0605.90082 |

[28] | Charnes, A.; Cooper, W.W.; Huang, Z.M.; Sun, D.B., Polyhedral cone-ratio DEA models with an illustrative application to large commercial banks, Journal of econometrics, 46, 73-91, (1990) · Zbl 0712.90015 |

[29] | Charnes, A.; Cooper, W.W.; Thrall, R.M., A structure for classifying and characterizing efficiencies and inefficiencies in DEA, Journal of productivity analysis, 2, 197-237, (1991) |

[30] | Charnes, A.; Haag, S.; Jaska, P.; Semple, J., Sensitivity of efficiency calculations in the additive model of data envelopment analysis, International journal of system sciences, 23, 789-798, (1992) · Zbl 0749.90002 |

[31] | Charnes, A.; Rousseau, J.; Semple, J., Sensitivity and stability of efficiency classifications in data envelopment analysis, Journal of productivity analysis, 7, 5-18, (1996) |

[32] | Chen, Y., Ranking efficient units in DEA, Omega, 32, 213-219, (2004) |

[33] | Chen, Y., Measuring super-efficiency in DEA in the presence of infeasibility, European journal of operational research, 161, 545-551, (2005) · Zbl 1067.90064 |

[34] | Chen, Y.; Zhu, J., Measuring information technology’s indirect impact on firm performance, Information technology & management journal, 5, 1-2, 9-22, (2004) |

[35] | Cherchye, L.; Van Puyenbroeck, T., A comment on multistage DEA methodology, Operational research letters, 28, 2, 143-149, (2001) |

[36] | Cherchye, L.; Kuosmanen, T.; Post, T., What is the economic meaning of FDH? A reply to thrall, Journal of productivity analysis, 13, 263-267, (2000) |

[37] | Coelli, T.; Rao, D.S.P.; Battese, G.E., An introduction to efficiency and productivity analysis, (1998), Kluwer Academic Publishers Boston, MA · Zbl 0935.62128 |

[38] | Cook, W.D.; Green, R.H., Evaluating power plant efficiency: A hierarchical model, Computers and operations research, 32, 813-823, (2005) · Zbl 1071.90544 |

[39] | Cook, W.D.; Zhu, J., Building performance standards into DEA structures, IIE transactions, 37, 267-275, (2005) |

[40] | Cook, W.D.; Zhu, J., Rank order data in DEA: A general framework, European journal of operational research, 174, 1021-1038, (2006) · Zbl 1103.90348 |

[41] | Cook, W.D.; Zhu, J., Classifying inputs and outputs in ’data envelopment analysis, European journal of operational research, 180, 2, 692-699, (2007) · Zbl 1123.90044 |

[42] | Cook, W.D., Zhu, J., 2008. CAR-DEA: Context dependent assurance regions in DEA. Operations Research, forthcoming. · Zbl 1167.90535 |

[43] | Cook, W.D.; Roll, Y.; Kazakov, A., A DEA model for measuring the relative efficiency of highway maintenance patrols, Infor, 28, 113-124, (1990) |

[44] | Cook, W.D.; Kress, M.; Seiford, L.M., On the use of ordinal data in data envelopment analysis, Journal of the operational research society, 44, 133-140, (1993) · Zbl 0776.90005 |

[45] | Cook, W.D.; Kress, M.; Seiford, L.M., Data envelopment analysis in the presence of both quantitative and qualitative factors, Journal of the operational research society, 47, 945-953, (1996) · Zbl 0863.90002 |

[46] | Cook, W.D.; Chai, D.; Doyle, J.; Green, R.H., Hierarchies and groups in DEA, Journal of productivity analysis, 10, 177-198, (1998) |

[47] | Cook, W.D.; Hababou, M.; Tuenter, H., Multi-component efficiency measurement and shared inputs in data envelopment analysis: an application to sales and service performance in bank branches, Journal of productivity analysis, 14, 209-224, (2000) |

[48] | Cook, W.D.; Green, R.; Zhu, J., Dual role factors in DEA, IIE transactions, 38, 1-11, (2006) |

[49] | Cook, W.D., Liang, L., Zha, Y., Zhu, J., 2008. A modified super-efficiency DEA model for infeasibility. Journal of the Operational Research Society, forthcoming. · Zbl 1168.90502 |

[50] | Cooper, W.W.; Huang, Z.; Li, S., Satisficing DEA models under chance constraints, Annals of operations research, 66, 279-295, (1996) · Zbl 0864.90003 |

[51] | Cooper, W.W.; Park, K.; Pastor, J.T., RAM: range adjusted measure of inefficiency for use with additive models and relations to other models and measures in DEA, Journal of productivity analysis, 11, 1, 5-42, (1999) |

[52] | Cooper, W.W.; Park, K.S.; Yu, G., IDEA and AR-IDEA: models for dealing with imprecise data in DEA, Management science, 45, 597-607, (1999) · Zbl 1231.90289 |

[53] | Cooper, W.W.; Li, S.; Seiford, L.M.; Tone, K.; Thrall, R.M.; Zhu, J., Sensitivity and stability analysis in DEA: some recent developments, Journal of productivity analysis, 15, 217-246, (2001) |

[54] | Cooper, W.W.; Huang, Z.; Li, S., Chance constraint DEA, () |

[55] | Cooper, W.W.; Seiford, L.M.; Tone, K., Introduction to data envelopment analysis and its uses, (2006), Springer Science, p. 351 |

[56] | Deprins, L.; Simar, L.; Tulkens, H., Measuring labor efficiency in post offices, (), 243-267 |

[57] | Doyle, J.; Green, R., Efficiency and cross efficiency in DEA: derivations, meanings and the uses, Journal of the operational research society, 45, 5, 567-578, (1994) · Zbl 0807.90016 |

[58] | Doyle, J.; Green, R.; Cook, W.D., Preference voting and project ranking using DEA and cross-evaluation, European journal of operational research, 90, 461-472, (1996) · Zbl 0911.90009 |

[59] | Dulá, J.H.; Hickman, B.L., Effects of excluding the column being scored from the DEA envelopment LP technology matrix, Journal of the operational research society, 48, 1001-1012, (1997) · Zbl 0901.90001 |

[60] | Dyson, R.G.; Thanassoulis, E., Reducing weight flexibility in DEA, Journal of operational research society, 39, 6, 563-576, (1988) |

[61] | Färe, R.S.; Grosskopf, S., Network DEA, Socio-economic journal, 5, 1-2, 9-22, (2000) |

[62] | Fare, R.; Grosskopf, S., Intertemporal production frontiers: with dynamic DEA, (1996), Kluwer Academic Boston, MA |

[63] | Fare, R.; Grosskopf, S., Modelling undesirable factors in efficiency evaluation: comment, European journal of operational research, 157, 242-245, (2004) · Zbl 1080.90527 |

[64] | Färe, R.S.; Lovell, C.A.K., Measuring the technical efficiency of production, Journal of economic theory, 19, 150-162, (1978) · Zbl 0398.90012 |

[65] | Färe, R.S.; Grosskopf, S.; Lovell, C.A.K., Production frontiers, (1994), Cambridge University Press |

[66] | Farrell, M.J., The measurement of productive efficiency, Journal of the royal statistical society, series A, general, 120, 3, 253-281, (1957) |

[67] | Frei, F.; Harker, P., Projections onto efficient frontiers: theoretical and computational extensions to DEA, Journal of productivity analysis, 11, 275-300, (1999) |

[68] | Gonzalez, E.; Alvarez, A., From efficiency measurement to efficiency improvement: the choice of relevant benchmarks, European journal of operational research, 133, 512-520, (2001) · Zbl 1002.90530 |

[69] | Golany, B.; Roll, Y., Incorporating standards via data envelopment analysis, (), 313-328 · Zbl 0862.90008 |

[70] | Green, R.H.; Cook, W.D.; Doyle, J., A note on the additive data envelopment analysis model, Journal of the operational research society, 48, 4, 446-448, (1997) · Zbl 0887.90002 |

[71] | Green, R.; Cook, W.D., A free disposal hull approach to efficiency measurement, Journal of the operational research society, 55, 1059-1063, (2004) · Zbl 1095.90083 |

[72] | Green, R.; Doyle, J.; Cook, W.D., Efficiency bounds in data envelopment analysis, European journal of operational research, 89, 482-490, (1996) · Zbl 0915.90037 |

[73] | Hua, Z., Bin, Y., 2007. DEA with undesirable factors. In: Zhu, J., Cook, W.D. (Eds.), Modeling Data Irregularities and Structural Complexities in Data Envelopment Analysis. Springer Science Series (Chapter 6). · Zbl 1170.90416 |

[74] | Kamakura, W.A., A note on the use of categorical variables in data envelopment analysis, Management science, 34, 10, 1273-1276, (1988) |

[75] | Korostolev, A.P.; Simar, L.; Tsybakov, A.B., Efficient estimation of monotone boundaries, Annals of statistics, 23, 476-489, (1995) · Zbl 0829.62043 |

[76] | Kumbhakar, S.C.; Lovell, C.A.K., Stochastic frontier analysis, (2000), Cambridge University Press · Zbl 0968.62080 |

[77] | Kuosmanen, T., 2006. Stochastic nonparametric envelopment of data: Combining virtues of SFA and DEA in a unified framework. MTT Discussion Paper. |

[78] | Land, K.C.; Lovell, C.A.K.; Thore, S., Productive efficiency under capitalism and state socialism: the chance constrained programming approach, Public finance in a world of transition, 47, 109-121, (1992) |

[79] | Land, K.C.; Lovell, C.A.K.; Thore, S., Production efficiency under capitalism and state socialism: an empirical inquiry using chance-constrained data envelopment analysis, Technological forecasting and social change, 46, 139-152, (1994) |

[80] | Lang, P.; Yolalan, O.R.; Kettani, O., Controlled envelopment by face extension in DEA, Journal of operational research society, 46, 4, 473-491, (1995) · Zbl 0830.90085 |

[81] | Liang, L.F.; Yang, F.; Cook, W.D.; Zhu, J., DEA models for supply chain efficiency evaluation, Annals of operations research, 145, 1, 35-49, (2006) · Zbl 1106.90045 |

[82] | Liang, L.F., Wu, J., Cook, W.D., Zhu, J., 2008. The DEA cross efficiency model and its Nash equilibrium. Operations Research, forthcoming. · Zbl 1167.91330 |

[83] | Lovell, C.A.K.; Rouse, A.P.B., Equivalent standard DEA models to provide super-efficiency scores, Journal of the operational research society, 54, 1, 101-108, (2003) · Zbl 1088.90519 |

[84] | Malmquist, S., Index numbers and indifference surfaces, Trabajos de estatistica, 4, 209-242, (1953) · Zbl 0052.15903 |

[85] | Muñiz, M.; Paradi, J.; Ruggiero, J.; Yang, Z.J., Evaluating alternative DEA models used to control for non-discretionary inputs, Computers & operations research, 33, 1173-1183, (2006) · Zbl 1126.90356 |

[86] | Neralic, L., Sensitivity in data envelopment analysis for arbitrary perturbations of data, Glasnik matematicki, 32, 315-335, (1997) · Zbl 0894.90003 |

[87] | Neralic, L., Preservation of efficiency and inefficiency classification in data envelopment analysis, Mathematical communications, 9, 51-62, (2004) · Zbl 1081.90034 |

[88] | Olesen, O.B.; Petersen, N.C., Indicators of ill-conditioned data sets and model misspecification in data envelopment analysis: an extended facet approach, Management science, 42, 2, 205-219, (1996) · Zbl 0881.90003 |

[89] | Oral, M.; Kettani, O.; Lang, P., A methodology for collective evaluation and selection of industrial R&D projects, Management science, 37, 7, 871-883, (1991) · Zbl 0729.90671 |

[90] | Pastor, J.T., Translation invariance in DEA: A generalization, Annals of operations research, 66, 93-102, (1996) · Zbl 0863.90005 |

[91] | Pastor, J.T.; Ruiz, J.L.; Sirvent, I., An enhanced DEA russell graph efficiency measure, European journal of operational research, 115, 596-607, (1999) · Zbl 0946.91030 |

[92] | Portela, M.; Castro, P.; Thanassoulis, E., Finding closest targets in non-oriented DEA models: the case of convex and non-convex technologies, Journal of productivity analysis, 19, 251-269, (2003) |

[93] | Portela, M.; Thanassoulis, E., Developing a decomposable measure of profit efficiency using DEA, Journal of the operational research society, 58, 4, 481-490, (2007) · Zbl 1213.91098 |

[94] | Roll, Y.; Cook, W.D.; Golany, B., Controlling factor weights in data envelopment analysis, IIE transactions, 23, 2-9, (1991) |

[95] | Rousseau, J.J.; Semple, J.H., Categorical outputs in data envelopment analysis, Management science, 39, 3, 384-386, (1993) · Zbl 0825.90680 |

[96] | Rousseau, J.J.; Semple, J.H., Two-person ratio efficiency games, Management science, 41, 435-441, (1995) · Zbl 0832.90125 |

[97] | Ruggiero, J., On the measurement of technical efficiency in the public sector, European journal of operational research, 90, 553-565, (1996) · Zbl 0907.90039 |

[98] | Ruggiero, J., Non-discretionary inputs in data envelopment analysis, European journal of operational research, 111, 461-469, (1998) · Zbl 0941.91047 |

[99] | Ruggiero, J., 2007. Non-discretionary inputs. In: Zhu, J., Cook, W.D. (Eds.), Modeling Data Irregularities and Structural Complexities in Data Envelopment Analysis. Springer Science Series (Chapter 5). |

[100] | Russell, R.R., Measures of technical efficiency, Journal of economic theory, 35, 109-126, (1988) · Zbl 0555.90014 |

[101] | Scheel, H., Undesirable outputs in efficiency valuations, European journal of operational research, 132, 400-410, (2001) · Zbl 0985.90053 |

[102] | Seiford, L.M.; Zhu, J., An investigation of returns to scale in data envelopment analysis, Omega, 27, 1-11, (1997) |

[103] | Seiford, L.M.; Zhu, J., Sensitivity analysis of DEA models for simultaneous changes in all of the data, Journal of the operational research society, 49, 1060-1071, (1998) · Zbl 1140.90433 |

[104] | Seiford, L.M.; Zhu, J., An acceptance system decision rule with data envelopment analysis, Computers and operations research, 25, 329-332, (1998) · Zbl 1042.90587 |

[105] | Seiford, L.M.; Zhu, J., Infeasibility of super-efficiency data envelopment analysis models, Infor, 37, 174-187, (1999) |

[106] | Seiford, L.M.; Zhu, J., An investigation of returns to scale in data envelopment analysis, Omega, 27, 1-11, (1999) |

[107] | Seiford, L.M.; Zhu, J., Profitability and marketability of the top 55 US commercial banks, Management science, 45, 9, 1270-1288, (1999) |

[108] | Seiford, L.; Zhu, J., Modelling undesirable factors in efficiency evaluation, European journal of operational research, 142, 16-20, (2002) · Zbl 1079.90565 |

[109] | Sexton, T.R.; Silkman, R.H.; Hogan, A.J., Data envelopment analysis: critique and extensions, (), 73-105 |

[110] | Simar, L.; Wilson, P.W., Sensitivity analysis of efficiency scores: how to bootstrap in nonparametric frontier models, Management science, 44, 49-61, (1998) · Zbl 1012.62501 |

[111] | Sueyoshi, T., A special algorithm for the additive model in DEA, Journal of the operational research society, 41, 3, 249-257, (1990) · Zbl 0703.90059 |

[112] | Sueyoshi, T., Comparisons and analyses of managerial efficiency and returns to scale of telecommunication enterprises by using DEA/WINDOW, Communications of the operations research society of Japan, 37, 210-219, (1992) |

[113] | Syrjanen, M.J., Non-discretionary and discretionary factors and scale in data envelopment analysis, European journal of operational research, 158, 20-33, (2004) · Zbl 1061.90066 |

[114] | Thanassoulis, E.; Allen, R., Simulating weights restrictions in data envelopment analysis by means of unobserved dmus, Management science, 44, 4, 586-594, (1998) · Zbl 1003.90511 |

[115] | Thompson, R.G.; Singleton, F.D.; Thrall, R.M.; Smith, B.A., Comparative site evaluations for locating a high-energy physics lab in Texas, Interfaces, 16, 35-49, (1986) |

[116] | Thompson, R.G.; Langemeir, L.N.; Lee, C.; Lee, E.; Thrall, R.M., The role of multiplier bounds in efficiency analysis with application to kansas farming, Journal of econometrics, 46, 93-108, (1990) |

[117] | Thompson, R.G.; Dharmapala, S.; Thrall, R.M., Linked-cone DEA profit ratios and technical inefficiencies with applications to illinois coal mines, International journal of production economics, 39, 99-115, (1995) |

[118] | Thore, S., Chance-constrained activity analysis, European journal of operational research, 30, 267-269, (1987) |

[119] | Thrall, R.M., The lack of invariance of optimal dual solutions under translation, Annals of operations research, 66, 103-108, (1996) · Zbl 0868.90002 |

[120] | Thrall, R.M., What is the economic meaning of FDH?, Journal of productivity analysis, 11, 243-250, (1999) |

[121] | Tone, K., A slacks-based measure of efficiency in data envelopment analysis, European journal of operational research, 130, 498-509, (2001) · Zbl 0990.90523 |

[122] | Tulkens, H., On FDH efficiency analysis: some methodological issues and applications to retail banking, courts and urban transit, Journal of productivity analysis, 4, 183-210, (1993) |

[123] | Wilson, P.W., Detecting influential observations in data envelopment analysis, Journal of productivity analysis, 6, 27-46, (1995) |

[124] | Zhu, J., Robustness of the efficient DMUs in data envelopment analysis, European journal of operational research, 90, 451-460, (1996) · Zbl 0907.90007 |

[125] | Zhu, J., Imprecise data envelopment analysis (IDEA): A review and improvement with an application, European journal of operational research, 144, 513-529, (2003) · Zbl 1012.90013 |

[126] | Zhu, J., Quantitative models for performance evaluation and benchmarking: data envelopment analysis with spreadsheets, (2003), Kluwer Academic Publishers |

[127] | Zhu, J.; Shen, H.Z., A discussion of testing DMUs’ returns to scale, European journal of operational research, 81, 590-596, (1995) · Zbl 0906.90004 |

This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.