zbMATH — the first resource for mathematics

A systematic approach for diagnosing service failure: service-specific FMEA and grey relational analysis approach. (English) Zbl 1235.90054
Summary: In any organization, the importance of failure management cannot be mentioned by a single word. However, most failure analysis is dominated by the manufacturing sector, despite the increasing importance of the service sector. In response, this paper proposes a systematic approach for identifying and evaluating potential failures using a service-specific failure mode and effect analysis (service-specific FMEA) and grey relational analysis. The proposed approach consists of two stages: construction of service-specific FMEA and application of grey relational analysis. The first stage, construction of service-specific FMEA, aims at incorporating the service specific characteristics to the traditional FMEA, providing 3 dimensions and 19 sub-dimensions, encompassing the service characteristics. At the second stage, grey relational analysis is applied to calculate the risk priority of each failure mode to deal with the necessities of a flexible evaluation framework under these interrelated multi-dimensions. The proposed approach is expected to help the service managers to manage the service failure within the systematic framework. This paper contributes to the field in that it incorporates the service-specific characteristics to the traditional FMEA, as well as providing the appropriate evaluation framework using grey relational analysis.

90B25 Reliability, availability, maintenance, inspection in operations research
62N05 Reliability and life testing
Full Text: DOI
[1] Stamatis, D.H., Failure mode and effect analysis: FMEA from theory to execution, (2003), ASQC Quality Press Milwaukee, WI
[2] Agbonifoh, B.A.; Edoreh, P.E., Consumer awareness and complaining behaviour, Eur. J. market., 20, 43-49, (1986)
[3] Tax, S.S.; Brown, S.W., Recovering and learning from service failure, Sloan manag. rev., 40, 75-88, (1998)
[4] Lewis, B.R.; Spyrankopoulos, S., Service failures and recovery in retail banking: the customers’ perspective, Int. J. bank market., 19, 37-47, (2001)
[5] Miller, J.L.; Craighead, C.W.; Karwan, K.R., Service recovery: A framework and empirical investigation, J. oper. manag., 18, 387-400, (2000)
[6] Michel, S., Analyzing service failures and recoveries: A process approach, Int. J. serv. ind. manag., 12, 20-33, (2001)
[7] Berry, L.L.; Parasuraman, A., Prescriptions for a service quality revolution in America, Organ. dyn., 20, 5-15, (1992)
[8] Boshoff, C., An experimental study of service recovery options, Int. J. serv. ind. manag., 8, 110-130, (1997)
[9] Reichheld, F.F., Learning from customer defections, Harvard bus. rev., 74, 56-69, (1996)
[10] Roos, I., Switching process in customer relationships, J. serv. res., 1, 68-85, (1999)
[11] S. Narayanagounder, K. Gurusami, A new approach for prioritization of failure modes in design FMEA using ANOVA, in: Proceedings of world academy of Sci. Eng. Techn., 2009.
[12] Rhee, S.J.; Ishii, K., Using cost based FMEA to enhance reliability and serviceability, J. adv. eng. inf., 17, 179-188, (2003)
[13] Dale, B.G.; Shaw, P., Failure mode and effects analysis in the motor industry: A state-of-the-art study, Qual. reliab. eng. int., 6, 179-188, (1990)
[14] Vandenbrande, W.W., How to use FMEA to reduce the size of your quality toolbox, Qual. prog., 31, 97-100, (1998)
[15] Chuang, P.T., Combining service blueprint and FMEA for service design, Serv. ind. J., 27, 91-104, (2007)
[16] Chase, R.B., The customer contact approach to services: theoretical bases and practical extensions, Oper. res., 29, 698-706, (1981)
[17] Fitzsimmons, J.A.; Fitzsimmons, M.J., Service management for competitive advantage, (1994), McGraw-Hill NY
[18] Edvardsson, B.; Olsson, J., Key concepts for new service developments, Serv. ind. J., 16, 140-164, (1996)
[19] Kellogg, D.L.; Nie, W., A framework for strategic service management, J. oper. manag., 13, 323-337, (1995)
[20] Johne, A.; Storey, C., New service development: A review of the literature and annotated bibliography, Eur. J. market., 32, 184-251, (1998)
[21] Shostack, G.L., Service positioning through structural change, J. market., 51, 34-43, (1987)
[22] Jones, P., Management in service industries, (1989), Pitman London
[23] Gronro¨os, C., Service management and marketing: managing the moments of truth in service competition, (1990), Lexington Books Lexington, MA
[24] Van Looy, B.; Van Dierdonck, R.; Gemmel, P., Services management: an integrated approach, (1998), Financial Times Pitman Publishing London
[25] Syson, F.; Perks, H., New service development: A network perspective, J. serv. market., 18, 255-266, (2004)
[26] Chang, C.L.; Wei, C.C.; Lee, Y.H., Failure mode and effects analysis using fuzzy method and grey theory, Kybernetes, 28, 1072-1080, (1999)
[27] Bowles, J.B.; Peláez, C.E., Fuzzy logic prioritization of failures in a system failure mode, effects and criticality analysis, J. reliab. eng. syst. safe., 50, 203-213, (1995)
[28] Pillay, A.; Wang, J., Modified failure mode and effects analysis using approximate reasoning, Reliab. eng. syst. safe., 79, 69-85, (2003)
[29] Tay, K.M.; Lim, C.P., Fuzzy FMEA with a guided rules reduction system for prioritization of failures, Int. J. qual. reliab. manag., 23, 1047-1066, (2006)
[30] Dong, C., Failure mode and effects analysis based on fuzzy utility cost estimation, Int. J. qual. reliab. manag., 24, 958-971, (2007)
[31] Chang, C.C.; Liu, P.H.; Wei, C.C., Failure mode and effects analysis using grey theory, Integrated manuf. syst., 12, 211-216, (2001)
[32] Chen, J.K., Utility priority number evaluation for FMEA, J. fail. an. prev., 7, 321-328, (2007)
[33] Deng, J.L., Introduction to grey system, J. grey syst., 1, 1-24, (1989) · Zbl 0701.90057
[34] Kuo, Y.; Yang, T.; Huang, G.W., The use of grey relational analysis in solving multiple attribute decision-making problems, Comp. ind. eng., 55, 80-93, (2008)
[35] Wu, H.H., A comparative study of using grey relational analysis in multiple attribute decision making problems, Qual. eng., 15, 209-217, (2002)
[36] Mueller, R.D.; Palmer, A.; Mack, R.; McMullan, R., Service in the restaurant industry: an American and irish comparison of service failures and recovery strategies, Hospit. manag., 22, 395-418, (2003)
[37] Hoffman, K.D.; Bateson, J.E.G., Essentials of service marketing, (1997), Dryden Texas
[38] Hess, R.L.; Ganesan, S.; Klein, N.M., Service failure and recovery: the impact of relationship factors on customer satisfaction, J. acad. market. sci., 31, 127-145, (2003)
[39] Goldstein, S.M.; Johnston, R.; Duffy, J.; Rao, J., The service concept: the missing link in service design research, J. oper. manag., 20, 121-134, (2002)
[40] Berry, L.; Parasuraman, A., Marketing services, (1991), The Free Press New York, NY
[41] Smith, A.; Bolton, R.; Wagner, J., A model of customer satisfaction with service encounters involving failure and recovery, J. market. res., 34, 356-372, (1999)
[42] Parasuraman, A.; Zeithaml, V.A.; Berry, L.L., A conceptual model of service quality and its implication for future research, J. market., 49, 41-50, (1985)
[43] Stewart, D.M.; Chase, R.B., The impact of human error on delivering service quality, Prod. oper. manag., 8, 240-263, (1999)
[44] Hoffman, K.D.; Kelley, S.W.; Rotalsky, H.M., Tracking service failures and employee recovery efforts, J. serv. market., 9, 49-61, (1995)
[45] Armistead, C.G.; Clarke, G.; Stanley, P., Managing service recovery, cranfield school of management, (1995), Cranfield
[46] McDougall, G.; Levesque, T., The effectiveness of recovery strategies after service failure: an experiment in the hospitality industry, J. hospit. leisure. market., 5, 27-49, (1998)
[47] Taylor, S., Waiting for service: the relationship between delays and evaluations of service, J. market., 58, 56-69, (1994)
[48] Kelley, S.W.; Davis, M.A., Antecedents to customer expectations for service recovery, J. acad. market. sci., 22, 52-61, (1994)
[49] Boulding, W.; Kalra, A.; Staelin, R.; Zeithaml, V.A., A dynamic process model of service quality: from expectations to behavioral intentions, J. market. res., 30, 7-27, (1993)
[50] Lewis, B.R.; McCann, P., Service failure and recovery: evidence from the hotel industry, Int. J. contemp. hospit. manag., 16, 6-17, (2004)
[51] Boshoff, C.; Leong, J., Empowerment, attribution and apologising as dimensions of service recovery: an experimental study, Int. J. serv. ind. manag., 9, 24-47, (1998)
[52] Bailey, D., Recovery from customer service shortfalls, Manag. serv. qual., 4, 25-28, (1994)
[53] Mattila, A.S., The effectiveness of service recovery in a multi-industry setting, J. serv. market., 15, 583-596, (2001)
[54] Colgate, M.; Norris, M., Developing a comprehensive picture of service failure, Int. J. serv. ind. manag., 12, 215-233, (2001)
[55] Puente, J.; Pino, R.; Priore, P.; de la Fuente, D., A decision support system for applying failure mode and effects analysis, Int. J. qual. reliab. manag., 19, 137-150, (2002)
[56] Li, G.D.; Yamaguchi, D.; Nagai, M., A grey-based decision-making approach to the supplier selection problem, Math. comput. model., 46, 573-581, (2007)
[57] Yang, C.C.; Chen, B.S., Supplier selection using combined analytical hierarchy process and grey relational analysis, J. manuf. technol. manage., 17, 926-941, (2006)
[58] Chen, M.F.; Tzeng, G.H., Combining grey relation and TOPSIS concepts for selecting an expatriate host country, Math. comput. model., 40, 1473-1490, (2004) · Zbl 1099.90549
[59] QSA, Quality system assessment, Second ed., Daimler Chrysler Corporation, Ford Motor Company, and General Motors Corporation, March, 1998.
[60] Teng, S.G.; Ho, S.M.; Shumar, D.; Liu, P.C., Implementing FMEA in a collaborative supply chain environment, Int. J. qual. reliab. manag., 23, 179-196, (2006)
[61] Y. Geum, J. Shin, Y. Park, FMEA-based portfolio approach to service productivity improvement, Serv. Indust. J. 2010, First published on: 28 September 2010 (iFirst) doi:10.1080/02642069.2010.503876.
[62] Bitner, M.J.; Booms, B.H.; Tetreault, M.S., The service encounter: diagnosing favorable and unfavorable incidents, J. market., 54, 71-84, (1990)
[63] Surprenant, C.F.; Soloman, M.R., Predictability and personalization in the service encounter, J. market., 51, 73-80, (1987)
[64] Shostack, G.L., Planning the service encounter, (), 243-254
[65] Ben-Daya, M.; Raouf, A., A revised failure mode and effects analysis model, Int. J. qual. reliab. manag., 13, 43-47, (1996)
[66] Shostack, G.L., Designing services that deliver, Harvard bus. rev., 62, 133-139, (1984)
[67] Fließa, S.; Kleinaltenkamp, M., Blueprinting the service company: managing service processes efficiently, J. bus. res., 57, 392-404, (2004)
[68] Kelley, S.W.; Hoffman, K.D.; Davis, M.A., A typology of retail failures and recoveries, J. retailing, 69, 429-452, (1993)
[69] Bell, C.R.; Zemke, R.E., Service breakdown: the road to recovery, Manag. rev., 76, 32-35, (1987)
[70] Zeithaml, V.A.; Berry, L.L.; Parasuraman, A., The nature and determinants of customer expectations of service, J. acad. market. sci., 21, 1-12, (1993)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.