How do judgmental overconfidence and overoptimism shape innovative activity? (English) Zbl 1284.91296

Summary: Recent field evidence suggests a positive link between overconfidence and innovative activities. In this paper we argue that the connection between overconfidence and innovation is more complex than the previous literature suggests. In particular, we show theoretically and experimentally that different forms of overconfidence may have opposing effects on innovative activity. While overoptimism is positively associated with innovation, judgmental overconfidence is negatively linked to innovation. Our results indicate that future research is well advised to take into account that the relationship between innovation and overconfidence may crucially depend on what type of overconfidence is most prevalent in a particular context.


91B38 Production theory, theory of the firm
91B06 Decision theory


Full Text: DOI Link


[1] Alicke, Mark D.; Klotz, M. L.; Breitenbacher, David L.; Yurak, Tricia J.; Vredenburg, Debbie S., Personal contact, individuation, and the better-than-average effect, J. Pers. Soc. Psychol., 68, 5, 804-825, (1995)
[2] Arora, Ashish; Gambardella, Alfonso, The market for technology, (Hall, Bronwyn H.; Rosenberg, Nathan, Handbook of the Economics of Innovation, vol. 1, (2010), North-Holland), 641-678
[3] Bateman, Thomas S.; Crant, J. Michael, The proactive component of organizational behavior: A measure and correlates, J. Organ. Behav., 14, 2, 103-118, (1993)
[4] Benos, Alexandros V., Aggressiveness and survival of overconfident traders, J. Finan. Markets, 1, 3-4, 353-383, (September 1998)
[5] Bernardo, Antonio E.; Welch, Ivo, On the evolution of overconfidence and entrepreneurs, J. Econ. Manage. Strategy, 10, 3, 301-330, (2001)
[6] Biais, Bruno; Hilton, Denis; Mazurier, Karine; Pouget, Sebastien, Judgemental overconfidence, self-monitoring, and trading performance in an experimental financial market, Rev. Econ. Stud., 72, 2, 287-312, (2005) · Zbl 1121.91358
[7] Blanchflower, David G.; Oswald, Andrew J., What makes an entrepreneur?, J. Lab. Econ., 16, 1, 26-60, (1998)
[8] Bolton, Patrick; Brunnermeier, Markus K.; Veldkamp, Laura, Leadership, coordination, and corporate culture, Rev. Econ. Stud., 80, 2, 512-537, (2013) · Zbl 1264.91030
[9] Camerer, Colin; Lovallo, Dan, Overconfidence and excess entry: an experimental approach, Amer. Econ. Rev., 89, 1, 306-318, (1999)
[10] Daniel, Kent; Hirshleifer, David; Subrahmanyam, Avanidhar, Investor psychology and security market under- and overreactions, J. Finance, 53, 6, 1839-1885, (December 1998)
[11] Diamond, Peter A.; Stiglitz, Joseph E., Increases in risk and in risk aversion, J. Econ. Theory, 8, 3, 337-360, (July 1974)
[12] Dubra, Juan, Optimism and overconfidence in search, Rev. Econ. Dynam., 7, 1, 198-218, (January 2004)
[13] Dunning, David; Meyerowitz, Judith A.; Holzberg, Amy D., Ambiguity and self-evaluation: the role of idiosyncratic trait definitions in self-serving assessments of ability, J. Pers. Soc. Psychol., 57, 6, 1082-1090, (1989)
[14] Eberlein, Marion; Ludwig, Sandra; Nafziger, Julia, The effects of feedback on self-assessment, Bull. Econ. Res., 63, 2, 177-199, (2011)
[15] Ederer, Florian; Manso, Gustavo, Is pay for performance detrimental to innovation, Manage. Sci., 59, 7, 1496-1513, (July 2013)
[16] Evans, David S.; Leighton, Linda S., Some empirical aspects of entrepreneurship, Amer. Econ. Rev., 79, 3, 519-535, (1989)
[17] Fagerberg, Jan; Srholec, Martin; Verspagen, Bart, Innovation and economic development, (Hall, Bronwyn H.; Rosenberg, Nathan, Handbook of the Economics of Innovation, vol. 2, (2010), North-Holland), 833-872
[18] Fischbacher, Urs, Z-tree: zurich toolbox for ready-made economic experiments, Exper. Econ., 10, 2, 171-178, (2007)
[19] Frese, Michael; Kring, Wolfgang; Soose, Andrea; Zempel, Jeannette, Personal initiative at work: differences between east and west Germany, Acad. Manage. J., 39, 1, 37-63, (1996)
[20] Galasso, Alberto; Simcoe, Timothy S., CEO overconfidence and innovation, Manage. Sci., 57, 8, 1469-1484, (August 2011)
[21] Greiner, Ben, The online recruitment system ORSEE - A guide for the organization of experiments in economics, (June 2004), Max Planck Institute of Economics, Strategic Interaction Group, Discussion Papers on Strategic Interaction 2003-10
[22] Grubb, Michael D., Selling to overconfident consumers, Amer. Econ. Rev., 99, 38, 1770-1807, (December 2009)
[23] Hall, Bronwyn H.; Lerner, Josh, The financing of R&D and innovation, (Hall, Bronwyn H.; Rosenberg, Nathan, Handbook of the Economics of Innovation, vol. 1, (2010), North-Holland), 609-639
[24] Heger, Stephanie A.; Papageorge, Nicholas W., We should totally open a restaurant: performance uncertainty and optimistic beliefs, (2013), Technical Report
[25] Hilton, Denis; Regner, Isabelle; Cabantous, Laure; Charalambides, Laetitia; Vautier, Stephane, Do positive illusions predict overconfidence in judgment? A test using interval production and probability evaluation measures of miscalibration, J. Behav. Decis. Mak., 24, 2, 117-139, (2011)
[26] Hirshleifer, David; Low, Angie; Hong Teoh, Siew, Are overconfident CEOs better innovators?, J. Finance, 67, 4, 1457-1498, (August 2012)
[27] Hossiep, R.; Paschen, M., Bochumer inventar zur berufsbezogenen persönlichkeitsbeschreibung (BIP), (2003), Hogrefe
[28] Hulten, Charles R., Growth accounting^{*}, (Hall, Bronwyn H.; Rosenberg, Nathan, Handbook of the Economics of Innovation, vol. 2, (2010), North-Holland), 987-1031
[29] Hurst, Erik; Lusardi, Annamaria, Liquidity constraints, household wealth, and entrepreneurship, J. Polit. Economy, 112, 2, 319-347, (2004)
[30] Jonsson, A.-C.; Allwood, C. M., Stability and variability in the realism of confidence judgments over time, content domain, and gender, Pers. Individ. Differ., 34, 559-574, (March 2003)
[31] Kihlstrom, R. E.; Laffont, J. J., A general equilibrium entrepreneurial theory of firm formation based on risk aversion, J. Polit. Economy, 87, 4, 719-748, (1979)
[32] Klayman, Joshua; Soll, Jack B.; Gonzalez-Vallejo, Claudia; Barlas, Sema, Overconfidence: it depends on how, what, and whom you ask, Organ. Behav. Human Decis. Process., 79, 3, 216-247, (September 1999)
[33] Larkin, Ian; Leider, Stephen, Incentive schemes, sorting, and behavioral biases of employees: experimental evidence, Amer. Econ. J.: Microecon., 4, 2, 184-214, (2012)
[34] Lichtenstein, Sarah; Fischhoff, Baruch; Phillips, Lawrence D., Calibration of probabilities: the state of the art to 1980, (Jungermann, H.; deZeew, G., Decision Making and the Change in Human Affairs, (1982), D. Rede), 602-642
[35] Lowe, Robert A.; Ziedonis, Arvids A., Overoptimism and the performance of entrepreneurial firms, Manage. Sci., 52, 2, 173-186, (February 2006)
[36] March, James G., Exploration and exploitation in organizational learning, Organ. Sci., 2, 1, 71-87, (1991)
[37] Moore, Don A.; Healy, Paul J., The trouble with overconfidence, Psychol. Rev., 115, (2008)
[38] Morrison, Elizabeth Wolfe; Phelps, Corey C., Taking charge at work: extrarole efforts to initiate workplace change, Acad. Manage. J., 42, 4, 403-419, (1999)
[39] Odean, Terrance, Volume, volatility, price, and profit when all traders are above average, J. Finance, 53, 6, 1887-1934, (1998)
[40] Parker, A.; Fischhoff, B., Decision-making competence: an individual differences approach, J. Behav. Decis. Mak., 18, 1-27, (January 2005)
[41] Parker, Sharon K., Enhancing role breadth self-efficacy: the roles of job enrichment and other organizational interventions, J. Appl. Psychol., 83, 6, 835-852, (1998)
[42] Raven, J.; Raven, J. C.; Court, J. H., Manual for ravenʼs progressive matrices and vocabulary scales, (2003), Harcourt Assessment
[43] Russo, J.; Schoemaker, P. J.H., Managing over-confidence, Sloan Manage. Rev., 33, 7-17, (1992)
[44] Spinnewijn, Johannes, Unemployed but optimistic: optimal insurance design with biased beliefs, (2010), Technical Report
[45] Svenson, Ola, Are we all less risky and more skillful than our fellow drivers?, Acta Psychol., 47, 2, 143-148, (1981)
[46] Unsworth, Kerrie, Unpacking creativity, Acad. Manage. Rev., 26, 2, 289-297, (2001)
[47] Unsworth, Kerrie L.; Parker, Sharon, Proactivity and innovation: promoting a new workforce for the new workplace, (Holman, David; Wall, Toby D.; Clegg, Chris W.; Sparrow, Paul; Howard, Ann, The New Workplace: A Guide to Human Impact of Modern Working Practices, (2003), John Wiley & Sons), 175-196
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.