A DEMATEL-based completion method for incomplete pairwise comparison matrix in AHP. (English) Zbl 1434.90075

Summary: Pairwise comparison matrix (PCM) as a crucial component of Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) presents the preference relations among alternatives. However, in many cases, the PCM is difficult to be completed, which obstructs the subsequent operations of the classical AHP. In this paper, based on decision-making and trial evaluation laboratory (DEMATEL) method which has ability to derive the total relation matrix from direct relation matrix, a new completion method for incomplete pairwise comparison matrix (iPCM) is proposed. The proposed method provides a new perspective to estimate the missing values in iPCMs with explicit physical meaning, which is straightforward and flexible. Several experiments are implemented as well to present the completion ability of the proposed method and some insights into the proposed method and matrix consistency.


90B50 Management decision making, including multiple objectives
90C08 Special problems of linear programming (transportation, multi-index, data envelopment analysis, etc.)
Full Text: DOI arXiv


[1] Alonso, S.; Chiclana, F.; Herrera, F.; Herrera-Viedma, E.; Alcalá-Fdez, J.; Porcel, C., A consistency-based procedure to estimate missing pairwise preference values, International Journal of Intelligent Systems, 23, 155-175, (2008) · Zbl 1148.68470
[2] Benítez, J.; Delgado-Galván, X.; Izquierdo, J.; Pérez-García, R., Consistent completion of incomplete judgments in decision making using AHP, Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics, 290, 412-422, (2015) · Zbl 1321.90068
[3] Bozóki, S.; Fülöp, J.; Rónyai, L., On optimal completion of incomplete pairwise comparison matrices, Mathematical and Computer Modelling, 52, 318-333, (2010) · Zbl 1201.15012
[4] Brunelli, M.; Canal, L.; Fedrizzi, M., Inconsistency indices for pairwise comparison matrices: A numerical study, Annals of Operations Research, 211, 493-509, (2013) · Zbl 1286.90076
[5] Brunelli, M.; Fedrizzi, M., Boundary properties of the inconsistency of pairwise comparisons in group decisions, European Journal of Operational Research, 240, 765-773, (2015) · Zbl 1338.91051
[6] Büyüközkan, G.; Çifçi, G., A new incomplete preference relations based approach to quality function deployment, Information Sciences, 206, 30-41, (2012)
[7] Büyüközkan, G.; Görener, A., Evaluation of product development partners using an integrated AHP-VIKOR model, Kybernetes, 44, 220-237, (2015)
[8] Chan, FT; Jha, A.; Tiwari, MK, Bi-objective optimization of three echelon supply chain involving truck selection and loading using NSGA-II with heuristics algorithm, Applied Soft Computing, 38, 978-987, (2016)
[9] Chan, FT; Kumar, N., Global supplier development considering risk factors using fuzzy extended AHP-based approach, Omega, 35, 417-431, (2007)
[10] Cheng, B., Hu, S., Wang, J.W., & Dong, Y. Y. (2016). A goal programming approach for group decision making with four incomplete preference relations. In 2016 International conference on intelligent networking and collaborative systems (INCoS) (pp. 435-438). IEEE
[11] Chen, K.; Kou, G.; Tarn, JM; Song, Y., Bridging the gap between missing and inconsistent values in eliciting preference from pairwise comparison matrices, Annals of Operations Research, 235, 155-175, (2015) · Zbl 1332.90124
[12] Corrente, S.; Greco, S.; Ishizaka, A., Combining analytical hierarchy process and choquet integral within non-additive robust ordinal regression, Omega, 61, 2-18, (2016)
[13] Csató, L.; Rónyai, L., Incomplete pairwise comparison matrices and weighting methods, Fundamenta Informaticae, 144, 309-320, (2016) · Zbl 1360.91086
[14] Dey, PK; Cheffi, W., Green supply chain performance measurement using the analytic hierarchy process: A comparative analysis of manufacturing organisations, Production Planning & Control, 24, 702-720, (2013)
[15] Dong, Yukun; Wang, Jinyu; Chen, Fenghua; Hu, Yong; Deng, Yong, Location of Facility Based on Simulated Annealing and “ZKW” Algorithms, Mathematical Problems in Engineering, 2017, 1-9, (2017)
[16] Emrouznejad, Ali; Marra, Marianna, The state of the art development of AHP (1979-2017): a literature review with a social network analysis, International Journal of Production Research, 55, 6653-6675, (2017)
[17] Erdogan, M.; Kaya, I., A combined fuzzy approach to determine the best region for a nuclear power plant in Turkey, Applied Soft Computing, 39, 84-93, (2016)
[18] Erdogan, M.; Kaya, I., Evaluating alternative-fuel busses for public transportation in Istanbul using interval type-2 fuzzy AHP and TOPSIS, Journal of Multiple-Valued Logic and Soft Computing, 26, 625-642, (2016)
[19] Ergu, Daji; Kou, Gang; Peng, Yi; Shi, Yong; Shi, Yu, The analytic hierarchy process: task scheduling and resource allocation in cloud computing environment, The Journal of Supercomputing, 64, 835-848, (2011)
[20] Ergu, D.; Kou, G.; Peng, Y.; Zhang, M., Estimating the missing values for the incomplete decision matrix and consistency optimization in emergency management, Applied Mathematical Modelling, 40, 254-267, (2016)
[21] Fedrizzi, M.; Giove, S., Incomplete pairwise comparison and consistency optimization, European Journal of Operational Research, 183, 303-313, (2007) · Zbl 1127.90362
[22] Fei, L., Wang, H., Chen, L., & Deng, Y. (2017). A new vector valued similarity measure for intuitionistic fuzzy sets based on OWA operators. Iranian Journal of Fuzzy Systems(accepted).
[23] Fontela, E., & Gabus, A. (1976). The DEMATEL observer. Geneva: Battelle Geneva Research Centre.
[24] Gabus, A., & Fontela, E. (1972). World problems, an invitation to further thought within the framework of DEMATEL. Geneva: Battelle Geneva Research Center.
[25] Gomez-Ruiz, JA; Karanik, M.; Peláez, JI, Estimation of missing judgments in AHP pairwise matrices using a neural network-based model, Applied Mathematics and Computation, 216, 2959-2975, (2010) · Zbl 1198.90232
[26] Govindan, K.; Kaliyan, M.; Kannan, D.; Haq, AN, Barriers analysis for green supply chain management implementation in Indian industries using analytic hierarchy process, International Journal of Production Economics, 147, 555-568, (2014)
[27] Harker, PT, Incomplete pairwise comparisons in the analytic hierarchy process, Mathematical Modelling, 9, 837-848, (1987)
[28] Ishizaka, A.; Labib, A., Review of the main developments in the analytic hierarchy process, Expert Systems with Applications, 38, 14,336-14,345, (2011)
[29] Ishizaka, A.; Pereira, VE, Portraying an employee performance management system based on multi-criteria decision analysis and visual techniques, International Journal of Manpower, 37, 628-659, (2016)
[30] Ishizaka, A.; Siraj, S.; Nemery, P., Which energy mix for the UK (United Kingdom)? An evolutive descriptive mapping with the integrated GAIA (graphical analysis for interactive aid)-AHP (analytic hierarchy process) visualization tool, Energy, 95, 602-611, (2016)
[31] Jandova, V.; Krejci, J.; Stoklasa, J.; Fedrizzi, M., Computing interval weights for incomplete pairwise-comparison matrices of large dimension—A weak consistency based approach, IEEE Transactions on Fuzzy Systems, PP, 1, (2016)
[32] Jiang, W.; Wei, B.; Tang, Y.; Zhou, D., Ordered visibility graph average aggregation operator: An application in produced water management, Chaos: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science, 27, 023117, (2017)
[33] Jiang, W.; Wei, B.; Zhan, J.; Xie, C.; Zhou, D., A visibility graph power averaging aggregation operator: A methodology based on network analysis, Computers & Industrial Engineering, 101, 260-268, (2016)
[34] Jiang, W.; Zhan, J., A modified combination rule in generalized evidence theory, Applied Intelligence, 46, 630-640, (2017)
[35] Kahraman, C.; Suder, A.; Bekar, ET, Fuzzy multiattribute consumer choice among health insurance options, Technological and Economic Development of Economy, 22, 1-20, (2016)
[36] Lee, AH; Kang, HY; Lin, CY; Shen, KC, An integrated decision-making model for the location of a PV solar plant, Sustainability, 7, 13,522-13,541, (2015)
[37] Liang, Q.; Liao, X.; Liu, J., A social ties-based approach for group decision-making problems with incomplete additive preference relations, Knowledge-Based Systems, 119, 68-86, (2017)
[38] Liou, JJH, Building an effective system for carbon reduction management, Journal of Cleaner Production, 103, 353-361, (2015)
[39] Liou, JJH; Tamosaitiene, J.; Zavadskas, EK; Tzeng, GH, New hybrid COPRAS-G MADM model for improving and selecting suppliers in green supply chain management, International Journal of Production Research, 54, 114-134, (2016)
[40] Liu, S.; Chan, FT; Ran, W., Decision making for the selection of cloud vendor: An improved approach under group decision-making with integrated weights and objective/subjective attributes, Expert Systems with Applications, 55, 37-47, (2016)
[41] Liu, T.; Deng, Y.; Chan, F., Evidential supplier selection based on DEMATEL and game theory, International Journal of Fuzzy Systems, (2017)
[42] Mentes, A.; Akyildiz, H.; Yetkin, M.; Turkoglu, N., A FSA based fuzzy DEMATEL approach for risk assessment of cargo ships at coasts and open seas of Turkey, Safety Science, 79, 1-10, (2015)
[43] Miccoli, F.; Ishizaka, A., Sorting municipalities in Umbria according to the risk of wolf attacks with AHPSort II, Ecological Indicators, 73, 741-755, (2017)
[44] Mieza, IZ; Yepes, V.; Moreno-Jiménez, JM, A systematic review of application of multi-criteria decision analysis for aging-dam management, Journal of Cleaner Production, 147, 217-230, (2017)
[45] Moreno-Jiménez, JM; Salvador, M.; Gargallo, P.; Altuzarra, A., Systemic decision making in AHP: A Bayesian approach, Annals of Operations Research, 245, 261-284, (2016) · Zbl 1349.91097
[46] Pinto, D.; Shrestha, S.; Babel, MS; Ninsawat, S., Delineation of groundwater potential zones in the Comoro watershed, Timor Leste using GIS, remote sensing and analytic hierarchy process (AHP) technique, Applied Water Science, 7, 503-519, (2017)
[47] Pourahmad, A.; Hosseini, A.; Banaitis, A.; Nasiri, H.; Banaitiene, N.; Tzeng, GH, Combination of fuzzy-AHP and DEMATEL-ANP with GIS in a new hybrid MCDM model used for the selection of the best space for leisure in a blighted urban site, Technological and Economic Development of Economy, 21, 773-796, (2015)
[48] Rodríguez, RM; Bedregal, B.; Bustince, H.; Dong, Y.; Farhadinia, B.; Kahraman, C.; Martínez, L.; Torra, V.; Xu, Y.; Xu, Z.; etal., A position and perspective analysis of hesitant fuzzy sets on information fusion in decision making. Towards high quality progress, Information Fusion, 29, 89-97, (2016)
[49] Rouyendegh, B. D., Oztekin, A., Ekong, J., & Dag, A. (2016). Measuring the efficiency of hospitals: A fully-ranking DEA-FAHP approach. Annals of Operations Research. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10479-016-2330-1.
[50] Saaty, T. L. (1980). The analytic hierarchy process: Planning, priority setting, resources allocation. New York: McGraw.
[51] Saaty, TL, Decision makingthe analytic hierarchy and network processes (AHP/ANP), Journal of Systems Science and Systems Engineering, 13, 1-35, (2004)
[52] Santos, LFOM; Osiro, L.; Lima, RHP, A model based on 2-tuple fuzzy linguistic representation and analytic hierarchy process for supplier segmentation using qualitative and quantitative criteria, Expert Systems with Applications, 79, 53-64, (2017)
[53] Shen, KY; Tzeng, GH, Combined soft computing model for value stock selection based on fundamental analysis, Applied Soft Computing, 37, 142-155, (2015)
[54] Strassen, V., Gaussian elimination is not optimal, Numerische mathematik, 13, 354-356, (1969) · Zbl 0185.40101
[55] Su, CM; Horng, DJ; Tseng, ML; Chiu, AS; Wu, KJ; Chen, HP, Improving sustainable supply chain management using a novel hierarchical grey-DEMATEL approach, Journal of Cleaner Production, 134, 469-481, (2016)
[56] Tomashevskii, I., Eigenvector ranking method as a measuring tool: Formulas for errors, European Journal of Operational Research, 240, 774-780, (2015) · Zbl 1338.91062
[57] Tsai, SB; Chien, MF; Xue, Y.; Li, L.; Jiang, X.; Chen, Q.; Zhou, J.; Wang, L., Using the fuzzy DEMATEL to determine environmental performance: A case of printed circuit board industry in Taiwan, PloS One, 10, e0129,153, (2015)
[58] Tsai, WH; Chou, WC, Selecting management systems for sustainable development in SMEs: A novel hybrid model based on DEMATEL, ANP, and ZOGP, Expert Systems with Applications, 36, 1444-1458, (2009)
[59] Tzeng, GH; Chiang, CH; Li, CW, Evaluating intertwined effects in e-learning programs: A novel hybrid MCDM model based on factor analysis and DEMATEL, Expert Systems with Applications, 32, 1028-1044, (2007)
[60] Tzeng, GH; Huang, CY, Combined DEMATEL technique with hybrid MCDM methods for creating the aspired intelligent global manufacturing & logistics systems, Annals of Operations Research, 197, 159-190, (2012) · Zbl 1251.90112
[61] Vetschera, R., Deriving rankings from incomplete preference information: A comparison of different approaches, European Journal of Operational Research, 258, 244-253, (2017) · Zbl 1380.91067
[62] Wang, H.; Xu, Z., Interactive algorithms for improving incomplete linguistic preference relations based on consistency measures, Applied Soft Computing, 42, 66-79, (2016)
[63] Wang, YM; Luo, Y.; Hua, Z., On the extent analysis method for fuzzy AHP and its applications, European Journal of Operational Research, 186, 735-747, (2008) · Zbl 1144.90011
[64] Wang, ZJ; Li, KW, Group decision making with incomplete intuitionistic preference relations based on quadratic programming models, Computers & Industrial Engineering, 93, 162-170, (2016)
[65] Wu, CR; Lin, CT; Tsai, PH, Evaluating business performance of wealth management banks, European Journal of Operational Research, 207, 971-979, (2010)
[66] Wu, HH; Chang, SY, A case study of using DEMATEL method to identify critical factors in green supply chain management, Applied Mathematics and Computation, 256, 394-403, (2015) · Zbl 1338.90242
[67] Wu, KJ; Liao, CJ; Tseng, ML; Lim, MK; Hu, J.; Tan, K., Toward sustainability: Using big data to explore the decisive attributes of supply chain risks and uncertainties, Journal of Cleaner Production, 142, 663-676, (2017)
[68] Wu, WW; Lee, YT, Developing global managers competencies using the fuzzy DEMATEL method, Expert Systems with Applications, 32, 499-507, (2007)
[69] Xu, Z., Deviation square priority method for distinct preference structures based on generalized multiplicative consistency, IEEE Transactions on Fuzzy Systems, 23, 1164-1180, (2015)
[70] Zavadskas, EK; Turskis, Z.; Antucheviciene, J., Selecting a contractor by using a novel method for multiple attribute analysis: Weighted aggregated sum product assessment with grey values (WASPAS-G), Studies in Informatics and Control, 24, 141-150, (2015)
[71] Zhang, Qi; Li, Meizhu; Deng, Yong, Measure the structure similarity of nodes in complex networks based on relative entropy, Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 491, 749-763, (2018)
[72] Zhang, X.; Deng, Y.; Chan, FTS; Adamatzky, A.; Mahadevan, S., Supplier selection based on evidence theory and analytic network process, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part B: Journal of Engineering Manufacture, 230, 562-573, (2016)
[73] Zhang, Z., Logarithmic least squares approaches to deriving interval weights, rectifying inconsistency and estimating missing values for interval multiplicative preference relations, Soft Computing, (2016) · Zbl 1382.91037
[74] Zhou, X.; Deng, X.; Deng, Y.; Mahadevan, S., Dependence assessment in human reliability analysis based on D numbers and AHP, Nuclear Engineering and Design, 313, 243-252, (2017)
[75] Zhou, X.; Shi, Y.; Deng, X.; Deng, Y., D-DEMATEL: A new method to identify critical success factors in emergency management, Safety Science, 91, 93-104, (2017)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.