×

Incentive schemes for resolving Parkinson’s law in project management. (English) Zbl 1487.90278

Summary: Project management is a business process that supports about 30% of the world’s economic activity. Yet projects routinely suffer from the influence of Parkinson’s Law. This behavioural phenomenon routinely results in failure to deliver work that is completed early before its assigned deadline. As a consequence, the late completion of other work is not offset, and overall project performance suffers. Hence, project success rates below 40% are widely reported.
Our work uses mechanism design within non-cooperative game theory. A particular issue in the design process is to eliminate the possibility that a project worker with multiple dependent tasks can improve their incentive payment by falsely reporting some of their task completion times. From our review of the academic and business literature of project management, no incentive scheme used in practice accomplishes this.
Our results include the design of incentive schemes that eliminate or mitigate Parkinson’s Law. These schemes apply to projects designed under either traditional Critical Path Method (CPM) planning or modern Critical Chain Project Management (CCPM) planning, and are also invulnerable to group strategy. A large-scale computational study validates the resulting benefit to project performance as substantial and also robust across different project characteristics. We also provide what is apparently the first analytical comparison between traditional CPM and modern CCPM planning systems.
The incentive schemes we propose are simple and easily implementable. We recognize that performance incentives are structured differently by each organization, but our work provides a flexible basis from which various practical schemes can be designed.

MSC:

90B35 Deterministic scheduling theory in operations research

Software:

RanGen
PDFBibTeX XMLCite
Full Text: DOI

References:

[1] Abu-Hiljeh, S. F.; Ibbs, C. W., Schedule-based construction incentives, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 115, 430-443 (1989)
[2] Alberini, A.; Longo, A.; Tonin, S.; Trombetta, F.; Turvani, M., The role of liability, regulation and economic incentives in brownfield remediation and redevelopment: Evidence from surveys of developers, Regional Science & Urban Economics, 35, 327-351 (2005)
[3] Arditi, D.; Yasamis, F., Incentive/disincentive contracts: Perceptions of owners and contractors, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 124, 361-373 (1998)
[4] Bayiz, M.; Corbett, C. J., Coordination and incentive contracts in project management under asymmetric information, Anderson Graduate School of Management (2005), Working paper
[5] Bower, D.; Ashby, G.; Gerald, K.; Smyk, W., Incentive mechanisms for project success, Journal of Management in Engineering, 37-43 (2002)
[6] Bubshait, A. A., Incentive/disincentive contracts and its effects on industrial projects, International Journal of Project Management, 21, 63-70 (2003)
[7] Bukhari, S.; Malik, A. A., Determining the factors affecting the accuracy of effort estimates for different application and task types, 10th International Conference on Frontiers of Information Technology, 41-45 (2012)
[8] Chen, T.; Klastorin, T.; Wagner, M. R., Incentive contracts in serial stochastic projects, Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 17, 3, 290-301 (2015)
[9] Demeulemeester, E.; Vanhoucke, M.; Herroelen, W., Rangen: A random network generator for activity-on-the-node networks, Journal of Scheduling, 6, 1, 17-38 (2003) · Zbl 1154.90440
[10] Enlume (2018). Discover product trends and delight customers. http://www.enlume.com/industries/retail/ 2019.
[11] Goldratt, E. M., The critical chain (1997), North River Press: North River Press Great Barrington, MA
[12] Golenko-Ginzburg, D., On the distribution of activity time in PERT, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 39, 767-771 (1988) · Zbl 0644.90051
[13] Growwire.com (2019). When the market called for shorter product life cycles, these companies hatched an answer. https://www.growwire.com/product-life-cycle2019.
[14] Gutierrez, G. J.; Kouvelis, P., Parkinson’s law and its implications for project management, Management Science, 37, 990-1001 (1991) · Zbl 0729.90858
[15] Hall, N. G., Project management: Recent developments and research opportunities, Journal of Systems Science and Systems Engineering, 21, 129-143 (2012)
[16] Hall, N. G., Project management: Further research opportunities, (Schwindt, C.; Zimmernann, J., Handbook of project management and scheduling,2, 945-970 (2013))
[17] INFORMS, Catonsville, MD.
[18] Herroelen, W.; Leus, R., On the merits and pitfalls of critical chain scheduling, Journal of Operations Management, 19, 559-577 (2001)
[19] Herten, H. J.; Peeters, W. A.R., Incentive contracting as a project management tool, Project Management, 4, 34-39 (1986)
[20] Hill, J.; Thomas, L. C.; Allen, D. E., Experts’ estimates of task durations in software development projects, International Journal of Project Management, 18, 13-21 (2000)
[21] Hu, X.; Cui, N.; Demeulemeester, E., Effective expediting to improve project due date and cost performance through buffer management, International Journal of Production Research, 53, 5, 1460-1471 (2015)
[22] Hurwicz, L., Optimality and informational efficiency in resource allocation processes, Mathematical methods in the social sciences, ed. Arrow, Karlin and Suppes (1960), Stanford University Press · Zbl 0133.12805
[23] Ibbs, C. W., Innovative contract features for construction, Construction Management and Economics, 9, 157-169 (1991)
[24] Kerzner, H., Project management: A systems approach to planning, Scheduling and controlling (2009), 10th ed. Wiley: 10th ed. Wiley Hoboken, NJ
[25] Klastorin, T., Project management: Tools and tradeoffs (2012), Pearson, Upper Saddle River: Pearson, Upper Saddle River NJ, USA.
[26] Kog, Y. C.; Chua, D. K.H.; Loh, P. K.; Jaselskis, E. J., Key determinants for construction schedule performance, International Journal of Project Management, 17, 351-359 (1999)
[27] Krakowski, M., PERT and Parkinson’s law, Interfaces, 5, 35-40 (1974)
[28] Kwon, H. D.; Lippman, S. A.; McCardle, K. F.; Tang, C. S., Project management contracts with delayed payments, Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 12, 4, 692-707 (2012)
[29] Kwon, H. D.; Lippman, S. A.; Tang, C. S., Optimal time-based and cost-based coordinated project contracts with unobservable work rates, International Journal of Production Economics, 126, 247-254 (2010)
[30] Leach, L. P., Critical chain project management improves project performance, Project Management Journal, 30, 39-51 (1999)
[31] Linberg, K. R., Software developer perceptions about software project failure: A case study, Journal of Systems and Software, 49, 177-192 (1999)
[32] Manifesto for Agile Software Development (2001). http://agilemanifesto.org 2019.
[33] Margraf, B. (2018). Six methods for the estimation of activity duration in project management. https://smallbusiness.chron.com/six-methods-estimation-activity-duration-project-management-41782.html, 2019.
[34] Myerson, R., Incentive compatibility and the bargaining problem, Econometrica, 47, 61-73 (1979) · Zbl 0399.90008
[35] Myerson, R., Optimal coordination mechanisms in generalized principal-agent problems, Journal of Mathematical Economics, 11, 67-81 (1982) · Zbl 0481.90001
[36] Myerson, R., Multistage games with communications, Econometrica, 54, 323-358 (1986) · Zbl 0599.90134
[37] Parkinson, C. N., Parkinson’s law, Economist (1955)
[38] Parkinson, C. N., Parkinson’s law: The pursuit of progress (1958), John Murray: John Murray London
[39] Quigley, J. (2011). Personal communication.
[40] Raduescu, C.; Heales, J., Incentives and their effects on information systems projects, Proceedings of the 13th European Conference on Information Systems, Regensburg, Germany (2005)
[41] Raz, T.; Barnes, R.; Dvir, D., A critical look at critical chain project management, Project Management Journal, 36, 24-32 (2003)
[42] Schonberger, R. J., Why projects are “always” late: A rationale based on manual simulation of a PERT/CPM network, Interfaces, 11, 66-70 (1981)
[43] Sommer, S. C.; Loch, C. H., Incentive contracts in projects with unforeseeable uncertainty, Production and Operations Management, 18, 185-196 (2009)
[44] Steyn, H., An investigation into the fundamentals of critical chain project scheduling, International Journal of Project Management, 19, 6, 363-369 (2001)
[45] The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, Mechanism design theory, Scientific Background on the Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel 2007 (2007)
[46] Vanhoucke, M.; Coelho, J.; Batselier, J., An overview of project data for integrated project management and control, Journal of Modern Project Management, 3, 2, 6-21 (2016)
[47] Williams, T. M., What are PERT estimates?, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 46, 1498-1504 (1995) · Zbl 0841.90064
[48] Wu, Y.; Krishnan, V.; Ramachandran, K., Managing cost salience and procrastination in projects: Compensation and team composition, Production and Operations Management, 23, 8, 1299-1311 (2014)
[49] Wysocki, R. K., Effective project management (2009), 5/e. Wiley, Indianapolis: 5/e. Wiley, Indianapolis IN, USA
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.