Assessing the numerical integration of dynamic prediction formulas using the exact expressions under the joint frailty-copula model. (English) Zbl 1478.62111

Summary: Joint models allow survival outcomes of a patient to be dynamically predictable based on intermediate events observed after treatment. The existing dynamic prediction methods need some numerical integration over frailty or random-effects distributions since the integral is implicit and improper. For a joint frailty-copula model, the Clayton copula and the gamma frailty model have been used to derive a dynamic prediction formula based on meta-analytic data. However, the prediction formulas under the Clayton copula involve an improper integral and need to be approximated numerically, as in all the joint models. In this paper, we consider the Gumbel copula and the FGM copula to obtain the exact (true) prediction formula without any numerical integration. The proposed formula also provides a tool for assessing approximation errors occurring to the approximation by numerical integration. Our numerical assessments show some approximation errors of the true prediction formula especially when the frailty distribution is heavy-tailed. A real data example illustrates how the proposed formulas can be used for assessing the approximation error. Our study may suggest some assessments for approximation errors in other types of joint models using more complex random-effects and frailty distributions.


62H05 Characterization and structure theory for multivariate probability distributions; copulas
62P10 Applications of statistics to biology and medical sciences; meta analysis
62N05 Reliability and life testing
Full Text: DOI


[1] Amrhein, L., Harsha, K., Fuchs, C. (2019). A mechanistic model for the negative binomial distribution of single-cell mRNA counts. bioRxiv, p. 657619. doi:10.1101/657619
[2] Amrhein, L., Harsha, K., Fuchs, C., Holoborodko, P. (2021). scModels: fitting discrete distribution models to count data, CRAN, https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=scModels
[3] Ancarani, LU; Gasaneo, G., Derivatives of any order of the confluent hypergeometric function F 1 1 (a, b, z) with respect to the parameter a or b, Journal of Mathematical Physics, 49, 6, 063508 (2008) · Zbl 1152.81314
[4] Burzykowski, T.; Molenberghs, G.; Buyse, M.; Geys, H.; Renard, D., Validation of surrogate end points in multiple randomized clinical trials with failure time end points, Applied Statistics, 50, 4, 405-422 (2001) · Zbl 1112.62336
[5] Choi, YH; Jacqmin-Gadda, H.; Król, A.; Parfrey, P.; Briollais, L.; Rondeau, V., Joint nested frailty models for clustered recurrent and terminal events: An application to colonoscopy screening visits and colorectal cancer risks in Lynch Syndrome families, Statistical Methods in Medical Research, 29, 5, 1466-1479 (2020)
[6] Commenges, D.; Jacqmin-Gadda, H., Dynamical biostatistical models (2015), CRC Press · Zbl 1333.92001
[7] Emura T. (2021). joint.Cox: joint frailty-copula models for tumour progression and death in meta-analysis, CRAN, Ver 3.12, https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=joint.Cox.
[8] Emura, T.; Hsu, JH, Estimation of the Mann-Whitney effect in the two-sample problem under dependent censoring, Computational Statistics & Data Analysis, 150, 106990 (2020) · Zbl 07212330
[9] Emura, T.; Matsui, S.; Rondeau, V., Survival analysis with correlated endpoints: Joint frailty-copula models (2019), Springer · Zbl 1429.62003
[10] Emura, T.; Nakatochi, M.; Matsui, S.; Michimae, H.; Rondeau, V., Personalized dynamic prediction of death according to tumour progression and high-dimensional genetic factors: Meta-analysis with a joint model, Statistical Methods in Medical Research, 27, 9, 2842-2858 (2018)
[11] Emura, T.; Nakatochi, M.; Murotani, K.; Rondeau, V., A joint frailty-copula model between tumour progression and death for meta-analysis, Statistical Methods in Medical Research, 26, 6, 2649-2666 (2017)
[12] Emura, T.; Shih, JH; Ha, ID; Wilke, RA, Comparison of the marginal hazard model and the sub-distribution hazard model for competing risks under an assumed copula, Statistical Methods in Medical Research, 29, 8, 2307-2327 (2020)
[13] Emura, T., Sofeu, C., & Rondeau, V. (2021). Conditional copula models for correlated survival endpoints: Individual patient data meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials (in review).
[14] Feddag, ML; Bacci, S., Pairwise likelihood for the longitudinal mixed Rasch model, Computational Statistics & Data Analysis, 53, 4, 1027-1037 (2009) · Zbl 1452.62869
[15] Ganzfried, B. F., Riester, M., Haibe-Kains, B., Risch, T., et al. (2013). curatedOvarianData: Clinically annotated data for the ovarian cancer transcriptome. Database (Vol. 2013), bat013. doi:10.1093/database/bat013
[16] Gumbel, EJ, Distributions de valeurs extrêmes en plusieurs dimensions, Publications De L’institut De Statistique De L’université De Paris, 9, 171-173 (1960) · Zbl 0093.15303
[17] Hofner, B.; Hothorn, T.; Kneib, T., Variable selection and model choice in structured survival models, Computational Statistics, 28, 3, 1079-1101 (2013) · Zbl 1305.65043
[18] Khuri, AI, Advanced calculus with applications in statistics (2003), Wiley · Zbl 1136.26300
[19] Li, Z.; Chinchilli, VM; Wang, M., A Bayesian joint model of recurrent events and a terminal event, Biometrical Journal, 61, 1, 187-202 (2019) · Zbl 1412.62166
[20] Moreira, C.; de Uña-Álvarez, J.; Braekers, R., Nonparametric estimation of a distribution function from doubly truncated data under dependence, Computational Statistics (2021) · Zbl 07432210
[21] Morgenstern, D., Einfache Beispiele zweidimensionaler Verteilungen, Mitteilungsblatt fürMathematische Statistik., 8, 234-235 (1956) · Zbl 0070.36202
[22] Nelsen, RB, An introduction to copulas (2006), Springer · Zbl 1152.62030
[23] Ota, S.; Kimura, M., Effective estimation algorithm for parameters of multivariate Farlie-Gumbel-Morgenstern copula, Japanese Journal of Statistics and Data Science (2021)
[24] Peng, M.; Xiang, L.; Wang, S., Semiparametric regression analysis of clustered survival data with semi-competing risks, Computational Statistics & Data Analysis, 124, 53-70 (2018) · Zbl 1469.62128
[25] Philipson, P.; Hickey, GL; Crowther, MJ; Kolamunnage-Dona, R., Faster Monte Carlo estimation of joint models for time-to-event and multivariate longitudinal data, Computational Statistics & Data Analysis, 151, 107010 (2020) · Zbl 07345929
[26] Rizopoulos, D., Fast fitting of joint models for longitudinal and event time data using a pseudo-adaptive Gaussian quadrature rule, Computational Statistics & Data Analysis, 56, 3, 491-501 (2012) · Zbl 1239.62122
[27] Rizopoulos, D.; Molenberghs, G.; Lesaffre, EM, Dynamic predictions with time-dependent covariates in survival analysis using joint modeling and landmarking, Biometrical Journal, 59, 6, 1261-1276 (2017) · Zbl 1379.62083
[28] Rondeau, V.; Mauguen, A.; Laurent, A.; Berr, C.; Helmer, C., Dynamic prediction models for clustered and interval-censored outcomes: Investigating the intra-couple correlation in the risk of dementia, Statistical Methods in Medical Research, 26, 5, 2168-2183 (2017)
[29] Rondeau, V.; Pignon, JP; Michiels, S., A joint model for dependence between clustered times to tumour progression and deaths: A meta-analysis of chemotherapy in head and neck cancer, Statistical Methods in Medical Research, 24, 711-729 (2015)
[30] Shih, JH; Chang, YT; Konno, Y.; Emura, T., Estimation of a common mean vector in bivariate meta-analysis under the FGM copula, Statistics, A Journal of Theoretical and Applied Statistics, 53, 3, 673-695 (2019) · Zbl 1418.62236
[31] Shih, JH; Emura, T., Likelihood-based inference for bivariate latent failure time models with competing risks under the generalized FGM copula, Computational Statistics, 33, 3, 1293-1323 (2018) · Zbl 1417.62294
[32] Shih, JH; Emura, T., Bivariate dependence measures and bivariate competing risks models under the generalized FGM copula, Statistical Papers, 60, 4, 1101-1118 (2019) · Zbl 1432.62153
[33] Shih, JH; Emura, T., Penalized Cox regression with a five-parameter spline model, Communication in Statistics- Theory and Methods (2020)
[34] Shih, JH; Emura, T., On the copula correlation ratio and its generalization, Journal of Multivariate Analysis, 182, 104708 (2021) · Zbl 1461.62059
[35] Shinohara, S.; Lin, YH; Michimae, H.; Emura, T., Dynamic lifetime prediction using a Weibull-based bivariate failure time model: A meta-analysis of individual-patient data, Communications in Statistics-Simulation and Computation (2020)
[36] Sofeu, C.; Emura, T.; Rondeau, V., A joint frailty-copula model for meta-analytic validation of failure time surrogate endpoints in clinical trials, Biometrical J, 63, 2, 423-446 (2021)
[37] van Houwelingen, HC; Putter, H., Dynamic prediction in clinical survival analysis (2011), CRC Press
[38] Wang, YC; Emura, T., Multivariate failure time distributions derived from shared frailty and copulas, Japanese Journal of Statistics and Data Science (2021)
[39] Wang, YC; Emura, T.; Fan, TH; Lo, SM; Wilk, RA, Likelihood-based inference for a frailty-copula model based on competing risks failure time data, Quality and Reliability Engineering International., 36, 5, 1622-1638 (2020)
[40] Wu, BH; Michimae, H.; Emura, T., Meta-analysis of individual patient data with semi-competing risks under the Weibull joint frailty-copula model, Computational Statistics, 35, 4, 1525-1552 (2020) · Zbl 07311686
[41] Zhou, X.; Kang, K.; Kwok, T.; Song, X., Joint hidden Markov model for longitudinal and time-to-event data with latent variables, Multivariate Behavioral Research (2020)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.