×

zbMATH — the first resource for mathematics

The synchronization of chaotic systems. (English) Zbl 0995.37022
Summary: Synchronization of chaos refers to a process wherein two (or many) chaotic systems (either equivalent or nonequivalent) adjust a given property of their motion to a common behavior due to a coupling or to a forcing (periodical or noisy). We review major ideas involved in the field of synchronization of chaotic systems, and present in detail several types of synchronization features: complete synchronization, lag synchronization, generalized synchronization, phase and imperfect phase synchronization. We also discuss problems connected with characterizing synchronized states in extended pattern forming systems. Finally, we point out the relevance of chaos synchronization, especially in physiology, nonlinear optics and fluid dynamics, and give a review of relevant experimental applications of these ideas and techniques.

MSC:
37D45 Strange attractors, chaotic dynamics of systems with hyperbolic behavior
PDF BibTeX XML Cite
Full Text: DOI
References:
[1] Hornby, A.S., Oxford advanced dictionary, (1974), Oxford University Press Oxford
[2] Hugenii, C., Horoloquium oscilatorium, (1673), Apud F. Muguet Parisiis, **
[3] I.I. Blekman, Synchronization in Science and Technology, Nauka, Moscow, 1981 (in Russian); ASME Press, New York, 1988 (in English). ∗∗
[4] Fujisaka, H.; Yamada, T., Prog. theor. phys., 69, 32, (1983), *
[5] Afraimovich, V.S.; Verichev, N.N.; Rabinovich, M.I., Izvestiya vysshikh uchebnykh zavedenii radiofizika, 29, 9, 1050, (1986), *
[6] Pecora, L.M.; Carroll, T.L., Phys. rev. lett., 64, 821, (1990), **
[7] Rosenblum, M.G.; Pikovsky, A.S.; Kurths, J., Phys. rev. lett., 76, 1804, (1996), **
[8] Rosa, E.R.; Ott, E.; Hess, M.H., Phys. rev. lett., 80, 1642, (1998)
[9] Rosenblum, M.G.; Pikovsky, A.S.; Kurths, J., Phys. rev. lett., 78, 4193, (1997), *
[10] Rulkov, N.F.; Sushchik, M.M.; Tsimring, L.S.; Abarbanel, H.D.I., Phys. rev. E, 51, 980, (1995), **
[11] Kocarev, L.; Parlitz, U., Phys. rev. lett., 76, 1816, (1996), *
[12] Boccaletti, S.; Valladares, D.L., Phys. rev. E, 62, 7497, (2000)
[13] Zaks, M.A.; Park, E.-H.; Rosenblum, M.G.; Kurths, J., Phys. rev. lett., 82, 4228, (1999)
[14] Femat, R.; Solis-Perales, G., Phys. lett. A, 262, 50, (1999)
[15] Zanette, D.H., Phys. rev. E, 55, 5315, (1997)
[16] Parmananda, P., Phys. rev. E, 56, 1595, (1997)
[17] Amengual, A.; Hernández-García, E.; Montagne, R.; San Miguel, M., Phys. rev. lett., 78, 4379, (1997)
[18] Boccaletti, S.; Bragard, J.; Arecchi, F.T.; Mancini, H.L., Phys. rev. lett., 83, 536, (1999)
[19] Chaté, H.; Pikovsky, A.; Rudzick, O., Physica D, 131, 17, (1999)
[20] Boccaletti, S.; Valladares, D.L.; Kurths, J.; Maza, D.; Mancini, H., Phys. rev. E, 61, 3712, (2000)
[21] Schafer, C.; Rosenblum, M.G.; Kurths, J.; Abel, H.H., Nature, 392, 239, (1998), *
[22] Tass, P.; Rosenblum, M.G.; Weule, M.G.; Kurths, J.; Pikovsky, A.; Volkmann, J.; Schnitzler, A.; Freund, H.J., Phys. rev. lett., 81, 3291, (1998)
[23] Van Wiggeren, G.D.; Roy, R., Science, 279, 1198, (1998), *
[24] Neiman, A.; Pei, X.; Russell, D.; Wojtenek, W.; Wilkens, L.; Moss, F.; Braun, H.A.; Huber, M.T.; Voigt, K., Phys. rev. lett., 82, 660, (1999)
[25] Maza, D.; Vallone, A.; Mancini, H.; Boccaletti, S., Phys. rev. lett., 85, 5567, (2000)
[26] Hall, G.M.; Bahar, S.; Gauthier, D.J., Phys. rev. lett., 82, 2995, (1999)
[27] Yehia, A.R.; Jeandupreux, D.; Alonso, F.; Guevara, M.R., Chaos, 9, 916, (1999)
[28] Shuai, J.-W.; Durand, D.M., Phys. lett. A, 264, 289, (1999)
[29] Ticos, C.M.; Rosa, E.; Pardo, W.B.; Walkenstein, J.A.; Monti, M., Phys. rev. lett., 85, 2929, (2000)
[30] Allaria, E.; Arecchi, F.T.; Di Garbo, A.; Meucci, R., Phys. rev. lett., 86, 791, (2001)
[31] Blasius, B.; Huppert, A.; Stone, L., Nature, 399, 354, (1999)
[32] DeShazer, D.J.; Breban, R.; Ott, E.; Roy, R., Phys. rev. lett., 87, 044101, (2001)
[33] Barreto, E.; So, P.; Gluckmann, B.J.; Schiff, S.J., Phys. rev. lett., 84, 1689, (2000)
[34] Barreto, E.; So, P., Phys. rev. lett., 85, 2490, (2000)
[35] Pikovsky, A.S., Z. phys. B, 55, 149, (1984), *
[36] Pecora, L.M.; Carroll, T.L., Phys. rev. A, 44, 2374, (1991)
[37] Pyragas, K., Phys. rev. E, 54, R4508, (1996)
[38] He, R.; Vaidya, P.V., Phys. rev. A, 46, 7387, (1992)
[39] Kapitaniak, T., Phys. rev. E, 50, 1642, (1994)
[40] Amritkar, R.E.; Gupte, N., Phys. rev. E, 47, 3889, (1993)
[41] Kocarev, L.; Parlitz, U., Phys. rev. lett., 74, 5028, (1995)
[42] Parlitz, U.; Kocarev, L.; Stojanovski, T.; Preckel, H., Phys. rev. E, 53, 4351, (1996)
[43] Güemez, J.; Matı́as, M.A., Phys. rev. E, 52, R2145, (1995)
[44] Wu, C.W.; Chua, L.O., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 4, 979, (1994)
[45] Sparrow, C., The Lorenz equations, bifurcations, chaos, and strange attractors, (1982), Springer New York · Zbl 0504.58001
[46] Balmforth, N.; Tresser, Ch.; Worfolk, P.; Wu, C.W., Chaos, 7, 392, (1997)
[47] Kowalski, J.M.; Albert, G.L.; Gross, G.W., Phys. rev. A, 42, 6260, (1990)
[48] Cuomo, K.M.; Oppenheim, A.V., Phys. rev. lett., 71, 65, (1993), *
[49] Carroll, T.L.; Pecora, L.M., Physica D, 67, 126, (1993)
[50] Carroll, T.L., Phys. rev. E, 50, 2580, (1994)
[51] Verhulst, F., Nonlinear differential equations and dynamical systems, (1990), Springer Berlin, Heidelberg · Zbl 0685.34002
[52] Yu, L.; Ott, E.; Chen, Q., Phys. rev. lett., 65, 2935, (1990)
[53] Gauthier, D.J.; Bienfang, J.C., Phys. rev. lett., 77, 1751, (1996)
[54] Benettin, G.; Froeschlé, C.; Scheidecker, H.P., Phys. rev. A, 19, 454, (1976)
[55] Shimada, I.; Nagashima, T., Prog. theor. phys., 61, 1605, (1979)
[56] Wolf, A.; Swift, J.B.; Swinney, H.L.; Vastano, J.A., Physica D, 16, 285, (1985)
[57] Willems, J.L., Stability theory of dynamical systems, (1970), Wiley New York · Zbl 0222.93010
[58] Murali, K.; Lakshmanan, M., Phys. rev. E, 49, 4882, (1994)
[59] Brown, R.; Rulkov, N.F., Phys. rev. lett., 78, 4189, (1997)
[60] Brown, R.; Rulkov, N.F., Chaos, 7, 395, (1997)
[61] Ashwin, P.; Buescu, J.; Stewart, I., Phys. lett. A, 193, 126, (1994), *
[62] Ashwin, P.; Buescu, J.; Stewart, I.N., Nonlinearity, 9, 703, (1996)
[63] Ott, E.; Sommerer, J.C.; Alexander, J.C.; Kan, I.; Yorke, J.A., Phys. rev. lett., 71, 4143, (1993), *
[64] C. Sommerer, J.; Ott, E., Nature (London), 365, 136, (1993)
[65] Lai, Y.C.; Grebogi, C.; Yorke, J.A.; Venkataramani, S.C., Phys. rev. lett., 77, 55, (1996)
[66] Ott, E.; Sommerer, J.C., Phys. lett. A, 188, 39, (1994)
[67] Astakhov, V.; Shabunin, A.; Kapitaniak, T.; Anishchenko, V., Phys. rev. lett., 79, 1014, (1997)
[68] Venkataramani, S.C.; Hunt, B.R.; Ott, E., Phys. rev. E, 54, 1346, (1996)
[69] Venkataramani, S.C.; Hunt, B.R.; Ott, E., Phys. rev. lett., 77, 5361, (1996)
[70] Voss, H.U., Phys. rev. E, 61, 5115, (2000)
[71] Voss, H.U., Phys. rev. lett., 87, 014102, (2001)
[72] Kuramoto, Y., Chemical oscillations, waves and turbulence, (1984), Springer Berlin, ** · Zbl 0558.76051
[73] Risken, H.Z., The fokker – planck equation, (1989), Springer Berlin · Zbl 0665.60084
[74] Pikovsky, A.S.; Rosenblum, M.; Osipov, G.V.; Zaks, M.; Kurths, J., Physica D, 104, 219, (1997)
[75] Roessler, O.E., Phys. lett. A, 57, 397, (1976)
[76] Gabor, D., J. IEE London, 93, 429, (1946)
[77] Pikovsky, A.; Rosenblum, M.; Kurths, J., Synchronization—A unified approach to nonlinear science, (2001), Cambridge University Press Cambridge, *
[78] Josić, K.; Mar, D.J., Phys. rev. E, 64, 066234, (2001)
[79] Stone, E.F., Phys. lett. A, 163, 367, (1992), *
[80] Pikovsky, A.; Osipov, G.; Rosenblum, M.; Zaks, M.; Kurths, J., Phys. rev. lett., 79, 47, (1997)
[81] Pikovsky, A.S.; Zaks, M.; Rosenblum, M.; Osipov, G.; Kurths, J., Chaos, 7, 680, (1997)
[82] Anishchenko, V.S.; Vadivasova, T.E.; Postnoy, D.E.; Safonova, M.A., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 2, 633, (1992) · Zbl 0876.34039
[83] Osipov, G.V.; Kurths, J., Phys. rev. E, 65, 016216, (2002)
[84] Katok, A.; Hasselblatt, B., Introduction to the modern theory of dynamical systems, (1995), Cambridge University Press Cambridge · Zbl 0878.58020
[85] Schuster, H.G., Deterministic chaos, an introduction, (1988), VCH-Verlag Weinheim, * · Zbl 0707.58003
[86] Goldztein, G.; Strogatz, S.H., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 5, 983, (1995)
[87] Lindsey, W.C., Synchronization systems in communication and control, (1972), Prentice-Hall Englewood Cliffs, NJ
[88] Keener, I.P., Trans. AMS, 26, 2, 589, (1980)
[89] Afraimovich, V.S.; Nekorkin, V.I.; Osipov, G.V.; Shalfeev, V.D., Stability, structures chaos in nonlinear synchronization networks, (1995), World Scientific Singapore · Zbl 0845.93003
[90] Strogatz, S.H.; Mirollo, R.E., Physica D, 31, 143, (1988), *
[91] Manneville, P.; Pomeau, Y., Physica D, 1, 219, (1980)
[92] Lee, K.J.; Kwsk, Y.; Lim, T.K., Phys. rev. lett., 81, 321, (1998)
[93] Kye, W.H.; Kim, C.M., Phys. rev. E, 62, 6304, (2000)
[94] Andrade, V.; Davidchack, R.L.; Lai, Y.C., Phys. rev. E, 61, 3230, (2000)
[95] Zhu, L.Q.; Raghu, A.; Lai, Y.C., Phys. rev. lett., 86, 4017, (2001)
[96] Pikovsky, A.S.; Grassberger, P., J. phys. A, 24, 4587, (1991)
[97] Yang, H.L., Phys. rev. E, 63, 026213, (2001)
[98] Kuznetsov, S.P.; Sataev, I.R., Phys. rev. E, 64, 046214, (2001)
[99] Kuznetsov, S.P.; Sataev, I.R., Phys. lett. A, 162, 236, (1992)
[100] Feigenbaum, M.J., J. stat. phys., 19, 25, (1978)
[101] Park, E.H.; Zaks, M.; Kurths, J., Phys. rev. E, 60, 6627, (1999)
[102] Zaks, M.A.; Park, E.-H.; Kurths, J., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 10, 2649, (2000)
[103] Schäfer, C.; Rosenblum, M.G.; Abel, H.H.; Kurths, J., Phys. rev. E, 60, 857, (1999)
[104] Taherion, S.; Lai, Y.C., Phys. rev. E, 59, R6247, (1999)
[105] Heagy, J.F.; Carroll, T.L.; Pecora, L.M., Phys. rev. E, 52, R1253, (1995)
[106] Zhou, C.S.; Lai, C.H., Phys. rev. E, 59, R6243, (1999)
[107] Osipov, G.; Pikovsky, A.; Rosenblum, M.; Kurths, J., Phys. rev. E, 55, 2353, (1997)
[108] Pikovsky, A.; Rosenblum, M.; Kurths, J., Europhys. lett., 34, 165, (1996)
[109] Abarbanel, H.D.I.; Rulkov, N.F.; Sushchik, M.M., Phys. rev. E, 53, 4528, (1996)
[110] Pecora, L.M.; Carroll, T.L.; Heagy, J.F., Phys. rev. E, 52, 3420, (1995)
[111] Hunt, B.R.; Ott, E.; Yorke, J.A., Phys. rev. E, 55, 4029, (1997)
[112] Brown, R., Phys. rev. lett., 81, 4835, (1998)
[113] Schiff, S.J.; So, P.; Chang, T.; Burke, R.E.; Sauer, T., Phys. rev. E, 54, 6708, (1996)
[114] Grassberger, P.; Procaccia, I., Phys. rev. lett., 50, 346, (1983)
[115] Kaplan, J.L.; Yorke, J.A., Functional differential equations and approximation of fixed points, (), 204, *
[116] Guckenheimer, J.; Holmes, P., Nonlinear oscillations, dynamical systems, and bifurcations of vector fields, (1983), Springer Berlin, New York, * · Zbl 0515.34001
[117] Blekhman, I.I.; Fradkov, A.L.; Nijmeijer, H.; Pogromsky, A.Yu., Systems control lett., 31, 299, (1997), *
[118] Brown, R.; Kocarev, L., Chaos, 10, 344, (2000)
[119] Boccaletti, S.; Pecora, L.M.; Pelaez, A., Phys. rev. E, 63, 066219, (2001), *
[120] S. Boccaletti, D.L. Valladares, L.M. Pecora, H.P. Geffert, T. Carroll, Reconstructing embedding spaces of coupled dynamical systems from multivariate data, Phys. Rev. E 65 (2002) 035204 (R).
[121] Wiesenfeldt, M.; Parlitz, U.; Lauterborn, W., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 11, 2217, (2001)
[122] Palus, M.; Komarek, V.; Hrncir, Z.; Sterbova, K., Phys. rev. E, 63, 046211, (2001)
[123] Cenys, A.; Lasiene, G.; Pyragas, K., Physica D, 52, 332, (1991), *
[124] Le Van Quyen, M.; Martinerie, J.; Adam, C.; Varela, F.J., Physica D, 127, 250, (1999)
[125] Arnhold, J.; Grassberger, P.; Lehnertz, K.; Elger, C.E., Physica D, 134, 419, (1999)
[126] Quiroga, R.Q.; Arnhold, J.; Grassberger, P., Phys. rev. E, 61, 5142, (2000)
[127] Merkwirth, C.; Parlitz, U.; Lauterborn, W., Phys. rev. E, 62, 2089, (2000)
[128] Tanaka, N.; Okamoto, H.; Saito, M., Physica D, 147, 1, (2000)
[129] Pompe, B., J. stat. phys., 73, 587, (1993)
[130] Johnson, G.A.; Mar, D.J.; Carroll, T.L.; Pecora, L.M., Phys. rev. lett., 80, 1998, (3956)
[131] Arecchi, F.T., Phys. rev. A, 45, R4225, (1992)
[132] Giacomelli, G., Phys. rev. lett., 73, 1099, (1994)
[133] Giacomelli, G.; Politi, A., Phys. rev. lett., 76, 2686, (1996)
[134] Boccaletti, S.; Maza, D.; Mancini, H.; Genesio, R.; Arecchi, F.T., Phys. rev. lett., 79, 5246, (1997)
[135] Pyragas, K., Phys. rev. E, 58, 3067, (1998)
[136] Bünner, M.J.; Just, W., Phys. rev. E, 58, R4072, (1998)
[137] Farmer, J.D., Physica D, 4, 366, (1982)
[138] Ikeda, K.; Matsumoto, M., J. stat. phys., 44, 955, (1986)
[139] Abarbanel, H.D.I., Analysis of observed chaotic data, (1996), Springer Berlin, New York, * · Zbl 0875.70114
[140] Ott, E.; Grebogi, C.; Yorke, J.A., Phys. rev. lett., 64, 1196, (1990), *
[141] For a review of control techniques and algorithms see S. Boccaletti, C. Grebogi, Y.-C. Lai, H. Mancini, D. Maza, Phys. Rep. 329 (2000) 103 ∗∗.
[142] Benzi, R.; Sutera, A.; Vulpiani, A., J. phys. A, 14, L453, (1981)
[143] Wiesenfeld, K.; Moss, F., Nature, 373, 33, (1995)
[144] Gammaitoni, L.; Hänggi, P.; Jung, P.; Marchesoni, F., Rev. mod. phys., 70, 223, (1998)
[145] Zaikin, A.A.; Kurths, J.; Schimansky-Geier, L., Phys. rev. lett., 85, 227, (2000)
[146] Zaikin, A.A.; Garcia-Ojalvo, J.; Schimansky-Geier, L.; Kurths, J., Phys. rev. lett., 88, 010601, (2002)
[147] Hu, G.; Ditzinger, T.; Ning, C.Z.; Haken, H., Phys. rev. lett., 71, 807, (1993)
[148] Pikovsky, A.S.; Kurths, J., Phys. rev. lett., 78, 775, (1997)
[149] Hu, B.; Zhou, C., Phys. rev. E, 61, R1001, (2000)
[150] Zhou, C.; Kurths, J.; Hu, B., Phys. rev. lett., 87, 98101, (2001)
[151] Mainen, Z.F.; Sejnowski, T.J., Science, 268, 1503, (1995)
[152] Bjornstad, O.N.; Ims, R.A.; Lambin, X., Trends ecol. evol., 14, 427, (1999)
[153] Hudson, P.J.; Cattadori, I.M., Trends ecol. evol., 14, 1, (1999)
[154] Jeltsch, F.; Wissel, C., Ecol. modelling, 75/76, 111, (1994)
[155] Pikovsky, A.S., (), 1601-1604
[156] Pikovsky, A.S., Radiophys. quantum electron., 27, 576, (1984)
[157] Jensen, R.V., Phys. rev. E, 58, R6907, (1998)
[158] Matsumoto, K.; Tsuda, I., J. stat. phys., 31, 87, (1983)
[159] Herzel, H.P.; Ebeling, W., Phys. lett. A, 111, 1, (1985)
[160] Herzel, H.P.; Pompe, B., Phys. lett. A, 122, 121, (1987)
[161] Pikovsky, A.S., Phys. lett. A, 165, 33, (1992)
[162] Heagy, J.F.; Platt, N.; Hammel, S.M., Phys. rev. E, 49, 1140, (1994)
[163] Zhou, C.S.; Lai, C.-H., Physica D, 135, 1, (2000)
[164] Platt, N.; Spiegel, E.A.; Tresser, C., Phys. rev. lett., 70, 279, (1993)
[165] Mritan, A.; Banavar, J.R.; Mritan, A.; Banavar, J.R., Phys. rev. lett., Phys. rev. lett., 73, 2932, (1994)
[166] Pikovsky, A.S., Phys. rev. lett., 73, 2931, (1994)
[167] Longa, L.; Curado, E.M.F.; Oliveira, A.A., Phys. rev. E, 54, R2201, (1996)
[168] Herzel, H.; Freund, J., Phys. rev. E, 52, 3238, (1995)
[169] Malescio, G., Phys. rev. E, 53, 6551, (1996)
[170] Gade, P.M.; Basu, C., Phys. lett. A, 217, 21, (1996)
[171] Sanchez, E.; Matias, M.A.; Perez-Munuzuri, V., Phys. rev. E, 56, 4068, (1997)
[172] Lai, C.-H.; Zhou, C.S., Europhys. lett., 43, 376, (1998)
[173] Zhou, C.S.; Chen, T.L., Neurocomputing, 30, 293, (2000)
[174] Toral, R.; Mirasso, C.R.; Hernandez-Garcia, E.; Piro, O., Chaos, 11, 665, (2001)
[175] C.S. Zhou, J. Kurths, Noise-induced phase synchronization and synchronization transitions in chaotic oscillators, Phys. Rev. Lett., submitted for publication. · Zbl 1073.37033
[176] Arnold, L., Random dynamical systems, (1998), Springer Berlin, Heidelberg
[177] Paladin, G.; Serva, M.; Vulpiani, A., Phys. rev. lett., 74, 66, (1995)
[178] Witt, A.; Neiman, A.; Kurths, J., Phys. rev. E, 55, 5050, (1997)
[179] Hodgkin, A.L.; Huxley, A.F., J. physiol., 117, 500, (1952)
[180] Braun, H.A.; Huber, M.T.; Dewald, M.; Schäfer, K.; Voigt, K., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 8, 881, (1998)
[181] See, for example, B. Hille, Ionic Channels of Excitable Membranes, 2nd Edition, Sinauer, Sunderland, MA, 1992.
[182] Braun, H.A.; Bade, H.; Hensel, H., Pflugers arch, ges. physiol. menschen tiere, 386, 1, (1980)
[183] Feudel, U.; Neiman, A.; Pei, X.; Wojtenek, W.; Braun, H.A.; Huber, M.; Moss, F., Chaos, 10, 231, (2000)
[184] Stratonovich, R.L., Topics in the theory of random noise, (1963), Gordon and Breach New York, ** · Zbl 0119.14502
[185] C.S. Zhou, J. Kurths, I.Z. Kiss, J.L. Hudson, Noise enhanced phase synchronization of chaotic oscillators, Phys. Rev. Lett., submitted for publication.
[186] Benzi, R.; Sutera, A.; Vulpiani, A., J. phys. A, 14, L453, (1981)
[187] Zhou, C.S.; Lai, C.H., Phys. rev. E, 60, 3928, (1999)
[188] Neiman, A.; Silchenko, A.; Anishchenko, V.; Schimansky-Geier, L., Phys. rev. E, 58, 7118, (1998)
[189] Neiman, A.; Schimansky-Geier, L.; Cornell-Bell, A.; Moss, F., Phys. rev. lett., 83, 4896, (1999)
[190] Hu, B.; Zhou, C.S., Phys. rev. E, 63, 026201, (2001)
[191] Strogatz, S.H.; Mirollo, S.E.; Matthews, P.C., Phys. rev. lett., 68, 2730, (1992)
[192] Heagy, J.F.; Pecora, L.M.; Carroll, T.L., Phys. rev. lett., 74, 4185, (1994)
[193] Zanette, D.H.; Mikhailov, A.S., Phys. rev., E58, 872, (1998)
[194] see also the Erratum, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82 (1998) 674.
[195] Maza, D.; Boccaletti, S.; Mancini, H., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 10, 829, (2000)
[196] Kuramoto, Y., Physica D, 50, 15, (1991)
[197] Sakaguchi, H.; Shinomoto, S.; Kuramoto, Y., Prog. theor. phys., 77, 1005, (1987)
[198] Ermentrout, G.B.; Kopell, N., SIAM (soc. ind. appl. math.) J. math. anal., 15, 215, (1984), *
[199] Ren, L.; Ermentrout, G.B., SIAM J. math. anal., 29, 208, (1998)
[200] Zhan, M.; Zheng, Z.G.; Hu, G.; Peng, X.H., Phys. rev. E, 62, 3552, (2000)
[201] Osipov, G.V.; Sushchik, M.M., Phys. rev. E, 58, 7198, (1998)
[202] Vadivasova, T.E.; Strelkova, G.I.; Anishchenko, V.S., Phys. rev. E, 63, 036225, (2001)
[203] Hadley, P.; Beasley, M.R.; Wiesenfeld, K., Phys. rev. B, 38, 8712, (1988)
[204] Wiesenfeld, K.; Colet, P.; Strogatz, S.H., Phys. rev. lett., 76, 404, (1996)
[205] Wiesenfeld, K.; Colet, P.; Strogatz, S.H., Phys. rev. E, 57, 1563, (1998)
[206] Benford, J., Phys. rev. lett., 62, 969, (1989)
[207] Han, S.K.; Kurrer, C.; Kuramoto, Y., Phys. rev. lett., 75, 3190, (1995)
[208] Braiman, Y.; Lindner, J.F.; Ditto, W.L., Nature (London), 378, 465, (1995)
[209] Glass, L.; Mackey, M.C., From clocks to chaos, (1988), Princeton University Press Princeton, ** · Zbl 0705.92004
[210] Winfree, A.T., The geometry of biological time, (1980), Springer New York, ** · Zbl 0856.92002
[211] Murray, J.D., Mathematical biology, (1989), Springer Berlin · Zbl 0682.92001
[212] Kuramoto, Y., Prog. theor. phys., 79, 212, (1974)
[213] Abarbanel, H.D.I.; Abarbanel, H.D.I., Usp. fiz. nauk, Phys. usp., 39, 337, (1996)
[214] Rabinovich, M.I.; Sushchik, M.M.; Rabinovich, M.I.; Sushchik, M.M., Usp. fiz. nauk, Phys. usp., 33, 1, (1990)
[215] Belykh, V.N.; Mosekilde, E., Phys. rev. E, 54, 3196, (1996)
[216] Kaneko, K., Physica D, 41, 137, (1990), *
[217] Kaneko, K., Physica D, 54, 5, (1991)
[218] Kaneko, K., Physica D, 55, 368, (1992)
[219] Kaneko, K., Physica D, 75, 55, (1994)
[220] Crisanti, A.; Falcioni, M.; Vulpiani, A., Phys. rev. lett., 76, 612, (1996)
[221] Vieira, M.S.; Lichtenberg, A.J., Phys. rev. E, 56, R3741, (1997)
[222] Zanette, D.H.; Mikhailov, A.S., Phys. rev. E, 57, 276, (1998)
[223] Hasler, M.; Maistrenko, Yu.; Popovich, O., Phys. rev. E, 58, 6843, (1998)
[224] Manrubia, S.C.; Mikhailov, A.S., Phys. rev. E, 60, 1579, (1999)
[225] Popovich, O.; Maistrenko, Yu.; Mosekilde, E., Phys. rev. E, 64, 026205, (2001)
[226] Pikovsky, A.; Popovich, O.; Maistrenko, Yu., Phys. rev. lett., 87, 044102, (2001)
[227] Belykh, V.; Belykh, I.; Hasler, M., Phys. rev. E, 62, 2000, (6332)
[228] Zhang, Y.; Hu, G.; Cerdeira, H.; Chen, S.; Braun, T.; Yao, Y., Phys. rev. E, 63, 026211, (2001)
[229] Belykh, V.; Belykh, I.; Hasler, M., Phys. rev. E, 63, 036216, (2001)
[230] Wang, W.; Kiss, I.Z.; Hudson, J.l., Chaos, 10, 248, (2000)
[231] Kaneko, K., Phys. rev. lett., 63, 219, (1989)
[232] Pecora, L.M., Phys. rev. E, 58, 347, (1998)
[233] Pecora, L.; Carroll, T.; Johnson, G.; Mar, D.; Fink, K.S., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 10, 273, (2000)
[234] Yang, H.L., Phys. rev. E, 64, 026206, (2001)
[235] Hu, G.; Zhang, Y.; Cerdeira, H.A.; Chen, S., Phys. rev. lett., 85, 3377, (2000)
[236] Heagy, J.F.; Carroll, T.L.; Pecora, L.M., Phys. rev. E, 50, 1874, (1994)
[237] Brunnet, L.; Chate, H.; Mannevile, P., Physica D, 78, 141, (1994)
[238] Kocarev, L.; Parlitz, U., Phys. rev. lett., 77, 2206, (1996)
[239] Pecora, L.M., Chaos, 7, 520, (1997)
[240] Zhan, M.; Hu, G.; Zhang, Y.; He, D., Phys. rev. lett., 86, 1510, (2001)
[241] Osipov, G.V.; Sushchik, M.M., Phys. lett. A, 201, 205, (1995)
[242] Zheng, Z.; Hu, G.; Hu, B., Phys. rev. lett., 81, 5318, (1998)
[243] D.L. Valladares, S. Boccaletti, F. Feudel, J. Kurths, Collective phase locked states in a chain of coupled chaotic oscillators, Phys. Rev. E Rapid Communications, submitted for publication.
[244] Kocarev, L.; Tasev, Z.; Parlitz, U., Phys. rev. lett., 79, 52, (1997)
[245] Parekh, N.; Parthasarathy, S.; Sinha, S., Phys. rev. lett., 81, 1401, (1998)
[246] Hu, G.; Qu, Z., Phys. rev. lett., 72, 68, (1994)
[247] Grigoriev, R.O.; Cross, M.C.; Schuster, H.G., Phys. rev. lett., 79, 2795, (1997)
[248] Boccaletti, S.; Bragard, J.; Arecchi, F.T., Phys. rev. E, 59, 6574, (1999)
[249] Bragard, J.; Arecchi, F.T.; Boccaletti, S., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 10, 2381, (2000)
[250] Junge, L.; Parlitz, U., Phys. rev. E, 62, 438, (2000)
[251] see M. Cross, P. Hohenberg, Rev. Mod. Phys. 65 (1993) 851 and reference therein ∗.
[252] Coullet, P.; Gil, L.; Roca, F., Opt. commun., 73, 403, (1989)
[253] Kolodner, P.; Slimani, S.; Aubry, N.; Lima, R., Physica D, 85, 165, (1995)
[254] Kuramoto, Y.; Koga, S., Prog. theor. phys. suppl., 66, 1081, (1981)
[255] Leweke, T.; Provansal, M., Phys. rev. lett., 72, 3174, (1994)
[256] Arecchi, F.T.; Basti, G.; Boccaletti, S.; Perrone, A.L., Europhys. lett., 26, 327, (1994)
[257] Boccaletti, S.; Arecchi, F.T., Europhys. lett., 31, 127, (1995)
[258] Boccaletti, S.; Arecchi, F.T., J. tech. phys., 37, 285, (1996)
[259] Boccaletti, S.; Arecchi, F.T., Physica D, 96, 9, (1996)
[260] Boccaletti, S.; Farini, A.; Arecchi, F.T., Chaos solitons fractals, 8, 1431, (1997)
[261] Narici, L.; Boccaletti, S.; Giaquinta, A.; Arecchi, F.T., Europhys. lett., 42, 247, (1998)
[262] Maza, D.; Mancini, H.; Boccaletti, S.; Genesio, R.; Arecchi, F.T., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 8, 1843, (1998)
[263] Boccaletti, S.; Farini, A.; Kostelich, E.J.; Arecchi, F.T., Phys. rev. E, 55, R4845, (1997)
[264] Boccaletti, S.; Farini, A.; Arecchi, F.T., Phys. rev. E, 55, 4979, (1997)
[265] Boccaletti, S.; Giaquinta, A.; Arecchi, F.T., Phys. rev. E, 55, 5393, (1997)
[266] Junge, L.; Parlitz, U.; Tasev, Z.; Kocarev, L., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 9, 2265, (2000)
[267] Junge, L.; Parlitz, U., Phys. rev. E, 61, 3736, (2000)
[268] Janiaud, B., Physica D, 55, 269, (1992)
[269] Shraiman, B., Physica D, 57, 241, (1992)
[270] Chaté, H., Nonlinearity, 7, 185, (1994)
[271] Sakaguchi, H., Prog. theor. phys., 84, 792, (1990)
[272] Egolf, D.; Greenside, H., Nature (London), 369, 129, (1994)
[273] Montagne, R.; Hernández-García, E.; San Miguel, M., Phys. rev. lett., 77, 267, (1996)
[274] Torcini, A., Phys. rev. lett., 77, 1047, (1996)
[275] van Hecke, M., Phys. rev. lett., 80, 1896, (1998)
[276] Bragard, J.; Boccaletti, S., Phys. rev. E, 62, 6346, (2000)
[277] Tasev, Z.; Kocarev, L.; Junge, L.; Parlitz, U., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 10, 869, (2000)
[278] Kantz, H.; Schreiber, T., Nonlinear time series analysis, (1997), Cambridge University Press Cambridge, England, * · Zbl 0873.62085
[279] Schmitz, A., Phys. rev. E, 62, 7508, (2000)
[280] Goodridge, C.L.; Pecora, L.M.; Carroll, T.L.; Rachford, F.J., Phys. rev. E, 64, 026221, (2001)
[281] Voss, H.; Kurths, J., Phys. lett. A, 234, 336, (1997)
[282] Voss, H.; Kolodner, P.; Abel, M.; Kurths, J., Phys. rev. lett., 83, 3422, (1999)
[283] Yuan, G.-C.; Yorke, J.A.; Carroll, T.L.; Ott, E.; Pecora, L.M., Phys. rev. lett., 85, 4265, (2000)
[284] Pecora, L.M.; Carroll, T.L., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 10, 875, (2000)
[285] Rosenblum, M.G.; Pikovsky, A.S., Phys. rev. E, 64, 045202, (2001)
[286] Lachaux, J.P.; Rodriguez, E.; Le Van Quen, M.; Lutz, A.; Martinerie, J.; Varela, F.J., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 10, 2429, (2000)
[287] Palus, M., Phys. lett. A, 235, 341, (1997)
[288] Tokuda, M.I.; Kurths, J.; Rosa, E., Phys. rev. lett., 88, 014101, (2002)
[289] Kittel, A.; Parisi, J.; Pyragas, K., Physica D, 112, 459, (1998)
[290] Roy, R.; Thornburg, K.S., Phys. rev. lett., 72, 2009, (1994)
[291] Sugawara, T.; Tachikawa, M.; Tsukamoto, T.; Shimizu, T., Phys. rev. lett., 72, 3502, (1994)
[292] Uchida, A.; Shinozuka, M.; Ogawa, T.; Kannari, F., Opt. lett., 24, 890, (1999)
[293] Otsuka, K.; Kawai, R.; Hwong, S.-L.; Ko, J.-Y.; Chern, J.-L., Phys. rev. lett., 84, 3049, (2000)
[294] Tang, D.Y.; Dykstra, R.; Hamilton, M.W.; Heckenberg, N.R., Chaos, 8, 697, (1998)
[295] Tang, D.Y.; Dykstra, R.; Hamilton, M.W.; Heckenberg, N.R., Phys. rev. E, 57, 5247, (1998)
[296] de Sousa Vieira, M.; Khoury, P.; Lichtenberg, A.J.; Lieberman, M.A.; Wonchoba, W.; Gullicksen, J.; Huang, Y.J.; Sherman, R.; Steinberg, M., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 2, 645, (1992)
[297] Yuan Zhao, Y., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 7, 1401, (1997)
[298] Itoh, M.; Yang, T.; Chua, L.O., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 9, 1393, (1999)
[299] Fisher, I.; Yun, L.; Davis, P., Phys. rev. A, 62, 011801, (2000)
[300] Chak-Nam, W.; Kim-Fung, T.; Ming-Kai, N.; Xiang-Quan, S., Microwave opt. tech. lett., 26, 407, (2000)
[301] Sivaprakasam, S.; Pierce, I.; Rees, P.; Spencer, P.S.; Shore, K.A.; Valle, A., Phys. rev. A, 64, 013805, (2001)
[302] Rogister, F.; Locquet, A.; Pieroux, D.; Sciamanna, M.; Deparis, O.; Megret, P.; Blondel, M., Opt. lett., 26, 1486, (2001)
[303] Rosa, E.; Pardo, W.B.; Ticos, C.M.; Walkenstein, J.; Monti, M., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 10, 2551, (2000) · Zbl 1182.76968
[304] Kiss, I.Z.; Hudson, J.L., Phys. rev. E, 64, 046215, (2001)
[305] Parlitz, U.; Junge, L.; Lauterborn, W.; Kocarev, L., Phys. rev. E, 54, 2115, (1996)
[306] Tang, D.Y.; Heckenberg, N.R., Phys. rev. E, 55, 6618, (1997)
[307] Tang, D.Y.; Dykstra, R.; Hamilton, M.W.; Heckenberg, N.R., Phys. rev. E, 57, 3649, (1998)
[308] Wallace, L.; Yu, D.J.; Lu, W.P.; Harrison, R.G., Phys. rev. A, 63, 013809, (2001)
[309] Kuntsevich, B.F.; Pisarchik, A.N., Phys. rev. E, 64, 046221, (2001)
[310] Pedersen, H.B.; Strasser, D.; Ring, S.; Heber, O.; Rappaport, M.L.; Rudich, Y.; Sagi, I.; Zajfman, D., Phys. rev. lett., 87, 055001, (2001)
[311] Williams, J.G.; Von Herzen, R.P., Geology, 2, 327, (1986)
[312] Stein, C.A.; Stein, S., J. geophys. res., 99, 3081, (1994)
[313] Blackadar, A.K., Turbulence and diffusion in the atmosphere, (1997), Springer Berlin, Heidelberg · Zbl 0889.76001
[314] Guilderson, T.P.; Schrag, D.P., Science, 281, 240, (1998)
[315] Zhang, R.-H.; Rothstein, L.M.; Busalacchi, A.J., Nature, 391, 879, (1998)
[316] Stone, R.C.; Hammer, G.L.; Marcussen, T., Nature, 384, 252, (1996)
[317] Heil, T.; Fischer, I.; Elsässer, W.; Mulet, J.; Mirasso, C.R., Phys. rev. lett., 86, 795, (2001)
[318] Zhu, L.Q.; Lai, Y.C., Phys. rev. E, 64, 045205, (2001)
[319] Duane, G.S.; Tribbia, J.J., Phys. rev. lett., 86, 4298, (2001)
[320] Larsen, P.D.; Trent, E.L.; Galletly, D.C., Brit. J. anaesth., 82, 546, (1999)
[321] Larsen, P.D.; Galletly, D.C., Pflug. arch. eur. J. physiol., 437, 910, (1999)
[322] Kotani, K.; Hidaka, I.; Yamamoto, Y.; Ozono, S., Method inform. med., 39, 153, (2000)
[323] Lotric, M.B.; Stefanovska, A., Physica A, 283, 451, (2000)
[324] Mrowka, R.; Patzak, A.; Rosenblum, M.G., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 10, 2479, (2000)
[325] Stefanovska, A.; Haken, H.; McClintock, P.V.E.; Hozic, M.; Bajrovic, F.; Ribaric, S., Phys. rev. lett., 85, 4831, (2000)
[326] Stefanovska, A.; Hozic, M., Prog. theor. phys. suppl., 139, 270, (2000)
[327] Chen, B.Y.; Vasilakos, K.; Boisteanu, D.; Garma, L.; Derenne, J.P.H.; Whitelaw, W.A., J. appl. physiol., 88, 2159, (2000)
[328] Anishchenko, V.S.; Balanov, A.G.; Janson, N.B.; Igosheva, N.B.; Bordyugov, G.V., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 10, 2339, (2000)
[329] Nomura, K.; Takei, Y.; Yanagida, Y., Eur. J. appl. physiol., 84, 373, (2001)
[330] Nikouline, V.V.; Linkenkaer-Hansen, K.; Huttunen, J.; Ilmoniemi, R.J., Neuroreport, 12, 2487, (2001)
[331] Koskinen, M.; Seppanen, T.; Tuukkanen, J.; Yli-Hankala, A.; Jantti, V., Clin. neurophysiol., 112, 386, (2001)
[332] Bhattacharya, J.; Petsche, H.; Feldmann, U.; Rescher, B., Neurosci. lett., 311, 29, (2001)
[333] Bhattacharya, J.; Petsche, H., Neuroreport, 12, 371, (2001)
[334] Bhattacharya, J.; Petsche, H., Phys. rev. E, 64, 012902, (2001)
[335] Schack, B.; Rappelsberger, P.; Anders, C.; Weiss, S.; Moller, E., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 10, 2565, (2000)
[336] Taga, G.; Konishi, Y.; Maki, A.; Tachibana, T.; Fujiwara, M.; Koizumi, H., Neurosci. lett., 282, 101, (2000)
[337] Toronov, V.; Franceschini, M.A.; Filiaci, M.; Fantini, S.; Wolf, M.; Michalos, A.; Gratton, E., Med. phys., 27, 801, (2000)
[338] Mormann, F.; Lehnertz, K.; David, P.; Elger, C.E., Physica D, 144, 358, (2000)
[339] Le Van Quyen, M.; Martinerie, J.; Navarro, V.; Baulac, M.; Varela, F.J., J. clin. neurophysiol., 18, 191, (2001)
[340] Palus, M.; Komarek, V.; Prochazka, T.; Hrncir, Z.; Sterbova, K., IEEE eng. med. biol., 20, 65, (2001)
[341] Jerger, K.K.; Netoff, T.I.; Francis, J.T.; Sauer, T.; Pecora, L.; Weinstein, S.L.; Schiff, S.J., J. clin. neurophysiol., 18, 259, (2001)
[342] Schnitzler, A.; Gross, J.; Timmermann, L., Acta neurobiol. exp., 60, 271, (2000)
[343] Mima, T.; Hallett, M., J. clin. neurophysiol., 16, 501, (1999)
[344] Varela, F.; Lachaux, J.P.; Rodriguez, E.; Martinerie, J., Nat. rev. neurosci., 2, 229, (2001), *
[345] Glass, L., Nature, 410, 277, (2001)
[346] Elson, R.C.; Selverston, A.I.; Huerta, R.; Rulkov, N.F.; Rabinovich, M.I.; Abarbanel, H.I., Phys. rev. lett., 81, 5692, (1998)
[347] Holstein-Rathlou, N.H.; Yip, K.P.; Sosnovtseva, O.V.; Mosekilde, E., Chaos, 11, 417, (2001)
[348] Blasius, B.; Stone, L., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 10, 2361, (2000)
[349] Palus, M.; Kurths, J.; Schwarz, U.; Novotna, D.; Charvatova, I., Int. J. bifurc. chaos, 10, 2519, (2000)
[350] Bhattacharya, J.; Pereda, E.; Kariyappa, R.; Kanjilal, P.P., Sol. phys., 199, 267, (2001)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.