Cohen, Ralph L.; Jones, John D. S. A homotopy theoretic realization of string topology. (English) Zbl 1025.55005 Math. Ann. 324, No. 4, 773-798 (2002). For an oriented, closed smooth manifold \(M^d\), Chas and Sullivan used intersection theory on singular chains to equip the homology of the free loop space \(H_*(LM)\) with a degree \(-d\) product, called the loop product. This paper is an attempt to show how this product arises from an \(A_\infty\)-ring structure on the Thom spectrum constructed from the pull-back of the stable normal bundle along the evaluation map \(LM\to M\). Thus the loop homology \(H_*(LM)\) is isomorphic to the Hochschild/Gerstenhaber homology. The authors (and some others) have realized that the written proof is not complete. Indeed they have assumed that Atiyah duality carried all necessary structure. There is something to prove here. Moreover, in the statement of Theorem 1 one should have that \(M\) is simply connected. If it is not simply connected there may be convergence problems in the cosimplicial spectrum. As written in a recent report: “Among the experts it is not doubted that the loop homology is isomorphic to Hochschild/Gerstenhaber homology in the simply connected case. However, the isomorphism itself may depend on the manifold structure and may not be homotopy invariant. Existence and uniqueness of this isomorphism remain quite interesting questions to resolve”. Reviewer: J.C.Thomas (Angers) Cited in 9 ReviewsCited in 53 Documents MSC: 55P43 Spectra with additional structure (\(E_\infty\), \(A_\infty\), ring spectra, etc.) 55P48 Loop space machines and operads in algebraic topology 57R19 Algebraic topology on manifolds and differential topology 55N35 Other homology theories in algebraic topology 55U99 Applied homological algebra and category theory in algebraic topology Keywords:string topology; Hochschild homology; loop product; spectrum; loop homology PDF BibTeX XML Cite \textit{R. L. Cohen} and \textit{J. D. S. Jones}, Math. Ann. 324, No. 4, 773--798 (2002; Zbl 1025.55005) Full Text: DOI arXiv