##
**Game-theoretic analysis of cooperation among supply chain agents: Review and extensions.**
*(English)*
Zbl 1137.91320

Summary: This paper surveys some applications of cooperative game theory to supply chain management. Special emphasis is placed on two important aspects of cooperative games: profit allocation and stability. The paper first describes the construction of the set of feasible outcomes in commonly seen supply chain models, and then uses cooperative bargaining models to find allocations of the profit pie between supply chain partners. In doing so, several models are analyzed and surveyed, and include suppliers selling to competing retailers, and assemblers negotiating with component manufacturers selling complementary components. The second part of the paper discusses the issue of coalition formation among supply chain partners. An exhaustive survey of commonly used stability concepts is presented. Further, new ideas such as farsightedness among supply chain players are also discussed and analyzed. The paper also opens some avenues of future research in applying cooperative game theory to supply chain management.

### MSC:

91A12 | Cooperative games |

90B05 | Inventory, storage, reservoirs |

90B35 | Deterministic scheduling theory in operations research |

PDFBibTeX
XMLCite

\textit{M. Nagarajan} and \textit{G. Sošić}, Eur. J. Oper. Res. 187, No. 3, 719--745 (2008; Zbl 1137.91320)

Full Text:
DOI

### References:

[1] | Anupindi, R., Bassok, Y., Zemel, E., 1999. Study of decentralized distribution systems: Part II - applications. Working paper, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL.; Anupindi, R., Bassok, Y., Zemel, E., 1999. Study of decentralized distribution systems: Part II - applications. Working paper, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL. |

[2] | Anupindi, R.; Bassok, Y.; Zemel, E., A general framework for the study of decentralized distribution systems, M&SOM, 3, 349-368 (2001) |

[3] | Arrow, K., Aspects of the theory of risk bearing, (Essays in the Theory of Risk Bearing (1965), Markham: Markham Chicago) · Zbl 0215.58602 |

[4] | Aumann, R. J., Acceptable points in general cooperative \(n\)-person games, (Tucker, A. W.; Luce, R. D., Contributions to the Theory of Games IV (1959), Princeton University Press: Princeton University Press NJ), 287-324 · Zbl 0085.13005 |

[5] | Aumann, R. J.; Dreze, J. H., Cooperative games with coalition structures, International Journal of Game Theory, 3, 217-237 (1974) · Zbl 0313.90074 |

[6] | Bacharach, S. B.; Lawler, E. J., Bargaining, Power, Tactics and Outcomes (1981), Jossey-Bass: Jossey-Bass San Francisco |

[7] | Bajari, P., McMillan, R., Tadelis, S., 2002. Auctions versus negotiations in procurement. An empirical analysis. Working Paper, Stanford University, Stanford, CA.; Bajari, P., McMillan, R., Tadelis, S., 2002. Auctions versus negotiations in procurement. An empirical analysis. Working Paper, Stanford University, Stanford, CA. |

[8] | Ben-Zvi, N., 2004. Inventory centralization when shortage costs differ: priorities and cost allocations, M.Sc. thesis, Tel-Aviv Univeristy, Tel-Aviv, Israel.; Ben-Zvi, N., 2004. Inventory centralization when shortage costs differ: priorities and cost allocations, M.Sc. thesis, Tel-Aviv Univeristy, Tel-Aviv, Israel. |

[9] | Ben-Zvi, N., Gerchak, Y., 2006. Inventory centralization when shortage costs differ: priorities and cost allocations. Working paper, Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv, Israel.; Ben-Zvi, N., Gerchak, Y., 2006. Inventory centralization when shortage costs differ: priorities and cost allocations. Working paper, Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv, Israel. |

[10] | Bernheim, B. D.; Peleg, B.; Whinston, M. D., Coalition-proof Nash equilibria, I. concepts, Journal of Economic Theory, 42, 1-12 (1987) · Zbl 0619.90090 |

[11] | Bernstein, F., Marx, L., 2005. Reservation profit levels and the division of supply chain profit, Working paper, Duke University, Durham, NC.; Bernstein, F., Marx, L., 2005. Reservation profit levels and the division of supply chain profit, Working paper, Duke University, Durham, NC. |

[12] | Bonaccorsi, A., Lyon, T.P., Pammolli, F., Turchetti, G., 2000. Auctions versus bargaining: an empirical analysis of medical device procurement, LEM working paper series, Sant’ Anna school of advanced study.; Bonaccorsi, A., Lyon, T.P., Pammolli, F., Turchetti, G., 2000. Auctions versus bargaining: an empirical analysis of medical device procurement, LEM working paper series, Sant’ Anna school of advanced study. |

[13] | Brandenburger, A., Stuart Jr., H.W., in press. Biform Games, Management Science.; Brandenburger, A., Stuart Jr., H.W., in press. Biform Games, Management Science. · Zbl 1232.91079 |

[14] | Cachon, G. P.; Lariviere, M. A., Supply chain coordination with revenue sharing contracts, Management Science, 51, 30-44 (2004) · Zbl 1232.90173 |

[15] | Cachon, G.; Netessine, S., Game theory in supply chain analysis, (Simchi-Levi, D.; Wu, S. D.; Shen, M., Supply Chain Analysis in the eBusiness Era (2004), Kluwer) · Zbl 1138.91365 |

[16] | Chacko, G. K., Bargaining strategy in a production and distribution system, Operations Research, 9, 811-827 (1961) |

[17] | Chen, X., Zhang, J., 2006. A stochastic programming duality approach to inventory centralization games. Working paper, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, IL.; Chen, X., Zhang, J., 2006. A stochastic programming duality approach to inventory centralization games. Working paper, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, IL. |

[18] | Chod, J., Rudi, N., 2003. Strategic investments, trading and pricing under forecast updating. Working paper, University of Rochester, Rochester, NY.; Chod, J., Rudi, N., 2003. Strategic investments, trading and pricing under forecast updating. Working paper, University of Rochester, Rochester, NY. |

[19] | Chwe, M. S.-Y., Farsighted coalitional stability, Journal of Economic Theory, 63, 299-325 (1994) · Zbl 0841.90131 |

[20] | Cutcher-Gershenfeld, J., McKersie, R.B., Walton, R.E., 1995. Pathways to change: case studies of strategic negotiations. W.E. Upjohn Inst. for Employment Res., Kalamazoo, MI.; Cutcher-Gershenfeld, J., McKersie, R.B., Walton, R.E., 1995. Pathways to change: case studies of strategic negotiations. W.E. Upjohn Inst. for Employment Res., Kalamazoo, MI. |

[21] | Eliashberg, J., Arbitrating a dispute. A decision analytic approach, Management Science, 32, 963-974 (1986) · Zbl 0598.90006 |

[22] | Elyakime, B.; Laffont, J. J.; Loisel, P.; Vuong, Q., Auction and bargaining: An econometric study of timber auctions with secret reservation prices, Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, 15, 209-220 (1997) |

[23] | Gerchak, Y.; Gupta, D., On apportioning costs to customers in centralized continuous review systems, Journal of Operations Management, 10, 546551 (1991) |

[24] | Gillies, D. B., Solutions to general non-zero sum games, (Tucker, A. W.; Luce, R. D., Contributions to the Theory of Games IV (1959), Princeton University Press: Princeton University Press Princeton, NJ), 47-83 · Zbl 0085.13106 |

[25] | Granot, D.; Sošić, G., A three stage model for a decentralized distribution system of retailers, Operations Research, 51, 771-784 (2003) · Zbl 1165.90491 |

[26] | Granot, D.; Sošić, G., Formation of alliances in Internet-based supply exchanges, Management Science, 51, 92-105 (2005) · Zbl 1232.91084 |

[27] | Granot, D., Yin, S., 2004. Competition and cooperation in a multi-supplier single-assembler supply chain with complementary products. Working Paper, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada.; Granot, D., Yin, S., 2004. Competition and cooperation in a multi-supplier single-assembler supply chain with complementary products. Working Paper, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada. |

[28] | Greenberg, J., Coalition structures, (Aumann, R. J.; Hart, S., Handbook of Game Theory, vol. 2 (1994), Elsevier Science B.V.), 1305-1337 · Zbl 0925.90081 |

[29] | Greene, D., JVS, alliances, consortia on path to survival for many, Semi Conductor Magazine, June, 2002 (2002) |

[30] | Gurnani, H., Shi, M., in press. A business to business bargaining model with supply uncertainty. Management Science.; Gurnani, H., Shi, M., in press. A business to business bargaining model with supply uncertainty. Management Science. |

[31] | Harsanyi, J. C.; Selten, R., A generalized solution for two-person bargaining games with incomplete information, Management Science, 18, 80-106 (1972) · Zbl 0262.90087 |

[32] | Hartman, B. C.; Dror, M., Cost allocation in continuous-review inventory models, Naval Research Logistics, 43, 549-561 (1996) · Zbl 0846.90033 |

[33] | Hartman, B. C.; Dror, M., Optimizing centralized inventory operations in a cooperative game theory setting, IIE Transactions, 35, 243-257 (2003) |

[34] | Hartman, B.C., Dror, M., 2004. Shipment consolidation: who pays for it and how much. Working Paper, The University of Arizona, AZ.; Hartman, B.C., Dror, M., 2004. Shipment consolidation: who pays for it and how much. Working Paper, The University of Arizona, AZ. |

[35] | Hartman, B. C.; Dror, M., Allocation of gains from inventory centralization in newsvendor environments, IIE Transactions, 37, 93-107 (2005) |

[36] | Hartman, B. C.; Dror, M.; Shaked, M., Cores of inventory centralization games, Games and Economic Behavior, 31, 2649 (2000) · Zbl 0960.91008 |

[37] | Heuth, B.P., Marcoul, 2003. An essay on cooperative bargaining in US agricultural markets. Journal of Agricultural and Food Industry Organization 1, article 10.; Heuth, B.P., Marcoul, 2003. An essay on cooperative bargaining in US agricultural markets. Journal of Agricultural and Food Industry Organization 1, article 10. |

[38] | Iskow, J., Sexton, R., 1992. Bargaining associations in grower-processor markets for fruits and vegetables. Technical Report 104, Agricultural Cooperative Service, US Department of Agriculture.; Iskow, J., Sexton, R., 1992. Bargaining associations in grower-processor markets for fruits and vegetables. Technical Report 104, Agricultural Cooperative Service, US Department of Agriculture. |

[39] | Kalai, E.; Smorodinsky, M., Other solutions to Nash’s bargaining problem, Econometrica, 43, 513-518 (1975) · Zbl 0308.90053 |

[40] | Kemahlıoğlu Ziya, E., 2004. Formal methods of value sharing in supply chains. Ph.D. thesis, School of Industries and Systems Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA.; Kemahlıoğlu Ziya, E., 2004. Formal methods of value sharing in supply chains. Ph.D. thesis, School of Industries and Systems Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA. |

[41] | Kihlstrom, R.; Roth, A. E.; Schmeidler, D., Risk aversion and Nash’s solution to the bargaining problem, (Moeschlin, O.; Pallaschke, D., Game theory and mathematical economics (1981), North Holland: North Holland Amsterdam), 5-71 |

[42] | Klijn, F.; Slikker, M., Distribution center consolidation games, Operations Research Letters, 33, 285-288 (2005) · Zbl 1140.90319 |

[43] | Kohli, R.; Park, H., A cooperative game theory model of quantity discounts, Management Science, 35, 693-707 (1989) · Zbl 0721.90030 |

[44] | Konishi, H.; Ray, D., Coalition formation as a dynamic process, Journal of Economic Theory, 110, 1-41 (2003) · Zbl 1052.91017 |

[45] | Krasner, S. D., Trade in raw materials: The benefits of capitalist alliances, (Rosen, S.; Kurth, J. R., Testing Theories of Economic Imperialism (1974), D.C. Heath) |

[46] | Lass, D.A., Adanu, M., Allen, P.G., 2001. Impact of the northeast dairy compact on retail prices. Agricultural and Resources Econ. Review.; Lass, D.A., Adanu, M., Allen, P.G., 2001. Impact of the northeast dairy compact on retail prices. Agricultural and Resources Econ. Review. |

[47] | Leng, M., Parlar, M., 2005. Allocation of cost savings in a three-level supply chain with demand information sharing: A cooperative-game approach. Working Paper, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON.; Leng, M., Parlar, M., 2005. Allocation of cost savings in a three-level supply chain with demand information sharing: A cooperative-game approach. Working Paper, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON. · Zbl 1181.90015 |

[48] | Mauleon, A.; Vannetelbosch, V., Farsightedness and cautiousness in coalition formation games with positive spillovers, Theory and Decision, 56, 291-324 (2004) · Zbl 1090.91009 |

[49] | Meca, A.; Timmer, J.; Garcia-Jurado, I.; Borm, P. E.M., Inventory games, European Journal of Operational Research, 156, 127-139 (2004) · Zbl 1044.90007 |

[50] | Müller, A.; Scarsini, M.; Shaked, M., The newsvendor game has a nonempty core, Games and Economic Behavior, 38, 118-126 (2002) · Zbl 1018.91005 |

[51] | Muthoo, A., A bargaining model based on the commitment tactic, Journal of Economic Theory, 69, 134-152 (1996) · Zbl 0852.90139 |

[52] | Nagarajan, M., 2005. Computing farsighted stable outcomes in coalitional games. Working paper, UBC.; Nagarajan, M., 2005. Computing farsighted stable outcomes in coalitional games. Working paper, UBC. |

[53] | Nagarajan, M., Bassok, Y., 2004. A bargaining framework in supply chains (the assembly problem). Working paper, University of So. Cal., Los Angeles, CA.; Nagarajan, M., Bassok, Y., 2004. A bargaining framework in supply chains (the assembly problem). Working paper, University of So. Cal., Los Angeles, CA. · Zbl 1232.91322 |

[54] | Nagarajan, M., Sošić, G., in press. Stable farsighted coalitions in competitive markets. Management Science.; Nagarajan, M., Sošić, G., in press. Stable farsighted coalitions in competitive markets. Management Science. · Zbl 1232.91088 |

[55] | Nagarajan, M., Sošić, G., 2006. Coalition stability in assembly models. Working paper, University of So. Cal., Los Angeles, CA.; Nagarajan, M., Sošić, G., 2006. Coalition stability in assembly models. Working paper, University of So. Cal., Los Angeles, CA. |

[56] | Nash, J. F., Noncooperative games, The Annals of Mathematics, 54, 286-295 (1951) · Zbl 0045.08202 |

[57] | Özen, U., Sošić, G., 2006. A multi-retailer decentralized distribution system with updated demand information. Working paper, TUE, Eindhoven, The Netherlands.; Özen, U., Sošić, G., 2006. A multi-retailer decentralized distribution system with updated demand information. Working paper, TUE, Eindhoven, The Netherlands. |

[58] | Özen, U., Fransoo, J., Norde, H., Slikker, M., 2004. Cooperation between multiple newsvendors with warehouses. Working paper, TUE, Eindhoven, The Netherlands.; Özen, U., Fransoo, J., Norde, H., Slikker, M., 2004. Cooperation between multiple newsvendors with warehouses. Working paper, TUE, Eindhoven, The Netherlands. |

[59] | Özen, U., Norde, H., Slikker, M., 2005. On the convexity of newsvendor games. Working paper, TUE, Eindhoven, The Netherlands.; Özen, U., Norde, H., Slikker, M., 2005. On the convexity of newsvendor games. Working paper, TUE, Eindhoven, The Netherlands. |

[60] | Pasternack, B. A., Optimal pricing and return policies for perishable commodities, Marketing Science, 4, 81-87 (1985) |

[61] | Plambeck, E., Taylor, T., 2004a. Implications of renegotiation for optimal contract flexibility and investment. Working Paper, Stanford University, Stanford, CA.; Plambeck, E., Taylor, T., 2004a. Implications of renegotiation for optimal contract flexibility and investment. Working Paper, Stanford University, Stanford, CA. · Zbl 1232.91326 |

[62] | Plambeck, E.L., Taylor, T.A., 2004b. Implications of breach remedy and renegotiation for design of supply contracts. Working paper, Columbia University, New York, NY.; Plambeck, E.L., Taylor, T.A., 2004b. Implications of breach remedy and renegotiation for design of supply contracts. Working paper, Columbia University, New York, NY. |

[63] | Plambeck, E., Taylor, T., 2004c. Partnership in a dynamic production system. Working Paper, Stanford University, Stanford, CA.; Plambeck, E., Taylor, T., 2004c. Partnership in a dynamic production system. Working Paper, Stanford University, Stanford, CA. |

[64] | Plambeck, E.; Taylor, T., Sell the plant? The impact of contract manufacturing on innovation, capacity and profitability, Management Science, 51, 133-150 (2005) |

[65] | Pratt, J. W., Risk aversion in the small and large, Econometrica, 32, 122-136 (1964) · Zbl 0132.13906 |

[66] | Raghunathan, S., Impact of demand correlation in the value of and incentives for information sharing in a supply chain, European Journal of Operational Research, 146, 634649 (2003) · Zbl 1037.90544 |

[67] | Reinhardt, G.; Dada, M., Allocating the gains from resource pooling with the Shapley value, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 56, 997-1000 (2005) · Zbl 1122.91046 |

[68] | Reyniers, D. J.; Tapiero, C. S., The delivery and control of quality in supplier-producer contracts, Management Science, 41, 1581-1589 (1995) · Zbl 0861.90066 |

[69] | Robinson, L., A comment on Gerchak and Guptas “on apportioning costs to customers in centralized continuous review systems”, Journal of Operations Management, 11, 99102 (1993) |

[70] | Roth, A., Axiomatic Models in Bargaining (1979), Springer-Verlag · Zbl 0408.90087 |

[71] | Roth, A., Handbook of Experimental Economics (1995), Princeton University Press |

[72] | Rubinstein, A., Perfect equilibrium in a bargaining model, Econometrica, 50, 97-110 (1982) · Zbl 0474.90092 |

[73] | Schelling, T., The Strategy of Conflict (1960), Harvard University Press |

[74] | Schmeidler, D., The nucleolus of a characteristic function game, SIAM Journal of Applied Mathematics, 17, 1163-1170 (1969) · Zbl 0191.49502 |

[75] | Shapley, L. S., A value for N-Person games, Contribution to the Theory of Games, vol. 2 (1953), Princeton University Press: Princeton University Press Princeton, NJ, pp. 307-317 · Zbl 0050.14404 |

[76] | Slikker, M.; van den Nouweland, A., Social and Economic Networks in Cooperative Game Theory (2001), Kluwer Academic Publishers: Kluwer Academic Publishers Boston |

[77] | Slikker, M.; Fransoo, J.; Wouters, M., Cooperation between multiple news-vendors with transshipments, European Journal of Operational Research, 167, 370-380 (2005) · Zbl 1075.90529 |

[78] | Sošić, G., Transshipment of inventories among the retailers: Myopic vs. farsighted stability, Management Science, 52, 10, 1493-1508 (2006) · Zbl 1232.90094 |

[79] | Sošić, G., 2005. Stability of information-sharing alliances in a three-level supply chain. Working paper, University of So. Cal., Los Angeles, CA.; Sošić, G., 2005. Stability of information-sharing alliances in a three-level supply chain. Working paper, University of So. Cal., Los Angeles, CA. |

[80] | Stallkamp, T.T., 2001. Fixing a broken economic model: A case for supplier alliances, in: Management Briefing Seminars, MSX International, Traverse City, MI.; Stallkamp, T.T., 2001. Fixing a broken economic model: A case for supplier alliances, in: Management Briefing Seminars, MSX International, Traverse City, MI. |

[81] | Stuart, H. W., Biform analysis of inventory competition, M&SOM, 7, 3479-3590 (2005) |

[82] | van Mieghem, J., Coordinating investment, production and subcontracting, Management Science, 45, 954-971 (1999) · Zbl 1231.91287 |

[83] | von Neumann, J.; Morgenstern, O., Theory of Games and Economic Behavior (1944), Princeton University Press: Princeton University Press Princeton, NJ · Zbl 0063.05930 |

[84] | Worley, T.; Folwell, R.; Foltz, J.; Jacqua, A., Management of a cooperative bargaining association: A case in the Pacific Northwest asparagus industry, Review of Agricultural Economy, 22, 548-565 (2000) |

[85] | Xue, L., Coalitional stability under perfect foresight, Economic Theory, 11, 603-627 (1998) · Zbl 0903.90005 |

[86] | Yaari, M. E., Some remarks of risk aversion and their use, Journal of Economic Theory, 1, 315-329 (1969) |

[87] | Yi, S.-S., Stable coalition structures with externalities, Games and Economic Behavior, 20, 201-237 (1997) · Zbl 0894.90186 |

[88] | Young, H. P., Monotonic solutions of cooperative games, International Journal of Game Theory, 14, 65-72 (1985) · Zbl 0569.90106 |

This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.