×

Pensionmetrics: Stochastic pension plan design and value-at-risk during the accumulation phase. (English) Zbl 0989.62057

Summary: We estimate values-at-risk (VaR) in the accumulation phase of defined-contribution pension plans. We examine a range of asset-return models (including stationary moments, regime-switching and fundamentals models) and a range of asset-allocation strategies (both static and with simple dynamic forms, such as lifestyle, threshold and constant proportion portfolio insurance). We draw four conclusions from our investigations.
First, we find that defined-contribution (DC) plans can be extremely risky relative to a defined-benefit (DB) benchmark (far more so than most pension plan professionals would be likely to admit). Second, we find that the VaR estimates are very sensitive to the choice of asset-allocation strategy. The VaR estimates are also sensitive, but to a lesser extent, to both the asset-returns model used and its parameterisation. The choice of asset-returns model is found to be the least significant of the three. Third, a static asset-allocation strategy with a high equity weighting delivers substantially better results than any of the dynamic strategies investigated over the long term (40 years) of the sample policy. This is important given that lifestyle strategies are the cornerstone of many DC plans. Fourth, conservative bond-based asset-allocation strategies require substantially higher contribution rates than more risky equity-based strategies if the same retirement pension is to be achieved.

MSC:

62P05 Applications of statistics to actuarial sciences and financial mathematics

Software:

RiskMetrics
PDFBibTeX XMLCite
Full Text: DOI

References:

[1] Adams, C., 1999. Older people find employers put youth before experience. The Financial Times, January 17.; Adams, C., 1999. Older people find employers put youth before experience. The Financial Times, January 17.
[2] Artzner, P.; Delbaen, F.; Eber, J.-M.; Heath, D., Thinking coherently, Risk, 10, 11, 68-71 (1997)
[3] Artzner, P.; Delbaen, F.; Eber, J.-M.; Heath, D., Coherent measures of risk, Mathematical Finance, 9, 203-228 (1999) · Zbl 0980.91042
[4] Black, F.; Jones, R., Simplifying portfolio insurance for corporate pension plans, Journal of Portfolio Management, 14, 4, 33-37 (1988)
[5] Black, F.; Perold, A., Theory of constant proportion portfolio insurance, Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 16, 403-426 (1992) · Zbl 0825.90056
[6] Blake, D., Efficiency, risk aversion and portfolio insurance: an analysis of financial asset portfolios held by investors in the United Kingdom, Economic Journal, 106, 1175-1192 (1996)
[7] Blake, D., Orszag, J.M., 1997. Portability and preservation of pension rights in the United Kingdom. In: Report of the Director General’s Inquiry into Pensions, Vol. 3. Office of Fair Trading, London.; Blake, D., Orszag, J.M., 1997. Portability and preservation of pension rights in the United Kingdom. In: Report of the Director General’s Inquiry into Pensions, Vol. 3. Office of Fair Trading, London.
[8] Blake, D., Cairns, A., Dowd, K., 2000a. PensionMetrics I: stochastic pension plan design and value-at-risk during the accumulation phase. In: Proceedings of the Third Annual BSI Gamma Foundation Conference on Global Asset Management, Lugano, November 1999. BSI-Gamma Working Paper 19.; Blake, D., Cairns, A., Dowd, K., 2000a. PensionMetrics I: stochastic pension plan design and value-at-risk during the accumulation phase. In: Proceedings of the Third Annual BSI Gamma Foundation Conference on Global Asset Management, Lugano, November 1999. BSI-Gamma Working Paper 19. · Zbl 0989.62057
[9] Blake, D., Cairns, A., Dowd, K., 2000b. PensionMetrics II: stochastic pension plan design and utility-at-risk during the distribution phase. In: Proceedings of the Fourth Annual BSI Gamma Foundation Conference on Global Asset Management, Rome, October 2000. BSI-Gamma Working Paper 20.; Blake, D., Cairns, A., Dowd, K., 2000b. PensionMetrics II: stochastic pension plan design and utility-at-risk during the distribution phase. In: Proceedings of the Fourth Annual BSI Gamma Foundation Conference on Global Asset Management, Rome, October 2000. BSI-Gamma Working Paper 20. · Zbl 0989.62057
[10] Boulier, J.-F., Huang, S.-J., Taillard, G., 1999. Optimal management under stochastic interest rates: the case of a protected pension fund. In: Proceedings of the Third IME Conference, London, Vol. 2, pp. 1-23.; Boulier, J.-F., Huang, S.-J., Taillard, G., 1999. Optimal management under stochastic interest rates: the case of a protected pension fund. In: Proceedings of the Third IME Conference, London, Vol. 2, pp. 1-23.
[11] Box, G. E.P.; Pierce, D. A., Distribution of residual autocorrelations in autoregressive integrated moving average time series models, Journal of the American Statistical Association, 65, 1509-1526 (1970) · Zbl 0224.62041
[12] Brown, S.; Goetzmann, W.; Ross, S., Survival, Journal of Finance, 50, 853-873 (1995)
[13] Cairns, A.J.G., 1995. Pension funding in a stochastic environment: the role of objectives in selecting an asset-allocation strategy. In: Proceedings of the Fifth AFIR International Symposium, Brussels, Vol. 1, pp. 845-870.; Cairns, A.J.G., 1995. Pension funding in a stochastic environment: the role of objectives in selecting an asset-allocation strategy. In: Proceedings of the Fifth AFIR International Symposium, Brussels, Vol. 1, pp. 845-870.
[14] Cairns, A.J.G., 1999a. A multifactor, equilibrium model for the term structure and inflation. In: Proceedings of the Ninth AFIR Colloquium, Tokyo, Vol. 3, pp. 93-113.; Cairns, A.J.G., 1999a. A multifactor, equilibrium model for the term structure and inflation. In: Proceedings of the Ninth AFIR Colloquium, Tokyo, Vol. 3, pp. 93-113.
[15] Cairns, A. J.G., An analysis of the level of security provided by the minimum funding requirement, British Actuarial Journal, 5, 585-610 (1999)
[16] Cairns, A. J.G., Some notes on the dynamics and optimal control of stochastic pension fund models in continuous time, ASTIN Bulletin, 30, 19-55 (2000) · Zbl 1018.91028
[17] Cairns, A. J.G., A discussion of parameter and model uncertainty in insurance, Insurance: Mathematics and Economics, 27, 313-330 (2000) · Zbl 0971.62063
[18] Cairns, A.J.G., Blake, D., Dowd, K., 2000. Optimal dynamic asset allocation for defined-contribution pension plans. In: Proceedings of the tenth AFIR Colloquium, Tromsø, Norway, June 2000, pp. 131-154.; Cairns, A.J.G., Blake, D., Dowd, K., 2000. Optimal dynamic asset allocation for defined-contribution pension plans. In: Proceedings of the tenth AFIR Colloquium, Tromsø, Norway, June 2000, pp. 131-154. · Zbl 1141.91492
[19] Cochrane, J. H., How big is the random walk in GNP?, Journal of Political Economy, 96, 893-920 (1988)
[20] CSFB, 2000. Equity Gilt Study. Credit Suisse First Boston, London.; CSFB, 2000. Equity Gilt Study. Credit Suisse First Boston, London.
[21] Deelstra, G.; Grasselli, M.; Koehl, P.-F., Optimal investment strategies in a CIR framework, Journal of Applied Probability, 37, 936-946 (2000) · Zbl 0989.91040
[22] Derbyshire, G., 1999. Strategic decisions for DC. Pensions Management, October, pp. 56-57.; Derbyshire, G., 1999. Strategic decisions for DC. Pensions Management, October, pp. 56-57.
[23] Dickey, D.; Fuller, W. A., Distribution of the estimates for autoregressive time series with a unit root, Journal of the American Statistical Association, 74, 427-431 (1979) · Zbl 0413.62075
[24] Dowd, K., 1998. Beyond Value at Risk: The New Science of Risk Management. Wiley, Chichester.; Dowd, K., 1998. Beyond Value at Risk: The New Science of Risk Management. Wiley, Chichester. · Zbl 0924.90013
[25] Efron, B., Bootstrap methods: another look at the jackknife, Annals of Statistics, 7, 1-26 (1979) · Zbl 0406.62024
[26] Embrechts, P.; McNeil, A. J.; Straumann, D., Correlation: pitfalls and alternatives, Risk, 12, 5, 69-71 (1999)
[27] Everitt, B.S., 1998. The Cambridge Dictionary of Statistics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.; Everitt, B.S., 1998. The Cambridge Dictionary of Statistics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. · Zbl 0902.62001
[28] Eviews, 1997. User’s Guide Version 3. Quantitative Micro Software, Irvine, CA.; Eviews, 1997. User’s Guide Version 3. Quantitative Micro Software, Irvine, CA.
[29] Flesaker, B.; Hughston, L. P., Positive interest, Risk, 9, 1, 46-49 (1996)
[30] Goetzmann, W., Jorion, P., 1997. A century of global stock markets. Working Paper 5901. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.; Goetzmann, W., Jorion, P., 1997. A century of global stock markets. Working Paper 5901. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.
[31] Hamilton, J.D., 1994. Time Series Analysis. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.; Hamilton, J.D., 1994. Time Series Analysis. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ. · Zbl 0831.62061
[32] Harris, G., Monte Carlo Markov chain estimation of regime switching vector autoregressions, ASTIN Bulletin, 29, 47-80 (1999) · Zbl 1162.91524
[33] Jarque, C. M.; Bera, A. K., Efficient tests for normality, homoscedasticity, and serial independence of regression residuals, Economics Letters, 6, 255-259 (1980)
[34] Kolbe, A.L., Read, J.A., Hall, G.R., 1984. The Cost of Capital. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.; Kolbe, A.L., Read, J.A., Hall, G.R., 1984. The Cost of Capital. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
[35] Lee, P.J., Wilkie, A.D., 2000. A comparison of stochastic asset models. In: Proceedings of the tenth International AFIR Colloquium, Tromsø, Norway, June 2000, pp. 407-445.; Lee, P.J., Wilkie, A.D., 2000. A comparison of stochastic asset models. In: Proceedings of the tenth International AFIR Colloquium, Tromsø, Norway, June 2000, pp. 407-445.
[36] Lo, A.; MacKinlay, A., Stock market prices do not follow random walks: evidence from a simple specification test, Review of Financial Studies, 1, 41-66 (1988)
[37] Lo, A.; MacKinlay, A., The size and power of the variance ratio test in finite samples: a Monte Carlo investigation, Journal of Econometrics, 40, 203-238 (1989)
[38] Merton, R. C.; Samuelson, P. A., Fallacy of the log-normal approximation to optimal portfolio decision making over many periods, Journal of Financial Economics, 1, 67-94 (1974) · Zbl 1131.91345
[39] Miles, D.; Timmermann, A., Risk sharing and transition costs in the reform of pension systems in Europe, Economic Policy, 29, 253-288 (1999)
[40] Mood, A.M., Graybill, F.A., 1963. Introduction to the Theory of Statistics. McGraw-Hill, New York.; Mood, A.M., Graybill, F.A., 1963. Introduction to the Theory of Statistics. McGraw-Hill, New York.
[41] Morgan, J.P., 1997. RiskMetrics Technical Document, 3rd Edition. J.P. Morgan, New York.; Morgan, J.P., 1997. RiskMetrics Technical Document, 3rd Edition. J.P. Morgan, New York.
[42] New Earnings Surveys, 2001. Office for National Statistics. Stationary Office, London.; New Earnings Surveys, 2001. Office for National Statistics. Stationary Office, London.
[43] Perold, A., Sharpe, W., 1988. Dynamic strategies for asset allocation. Financial Analysts Journal, January/February, 16-27.; Perold, A., Sharpe, W., 1988. Dynamic strategies for asset allocation. Financial Analysts Journal, January/February, 16-27.
[44] Politis, D.; Romano, J., The stationary bootstrap, Journal of the American Statistical Association, 89, 1303-1313 (1994) · Zbl 0814.62023
[45] Poterba, J.; Summers, L., Mean reversion in stock prices: evidence and implications, Journal of Financial Economics, 22, 27-59 (1988)
[46] Rutkowski, M., A note on the Flesaker and Hughston model of the term structure of interest rates, Applied Mathematical Finance, 4, 151-163 (1997) · Zbl 1009.91020
[47] Samuelson, P. A., Risk and uncertainty: a fallacy of large numbers, Scientia, 57, 1-6 (1963)
[48] Samuelson, P.A., 1989. A case at last for age-phased reduction in equity. In: Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, Vol. 86, Washington, DC, 9048-9051.; Samuelson, P.A., 1989. A case at last for age-phased reduction in equity. In: Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, Vol. 86, Washington, DC, 9048-9051.
[49] Samuelson, P.A., 1991. Long-run risk tolerance when equity returns are mean regressing: pseudoparadoxes and vindication of ‘businessman’s risk’. In: Brainard, W., Nordhaus, W., Watts, H. (Eds.), Macroeconomics, Finance and Economic Policy: Essays in Honour of James Tobin. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 181-200.; Samuelson, P.A., 1991. Long-run risk tolerance when equity returns are mean regressing: pseudoparadoxes and vindication of ‘businessman’s risk’. In: Brainard, W., Nordhaus, W., Watts, H. (Eds.), Macroeconomics, Finance and Economic Policy: Essays in Honour of James Tobin. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 181-200.
[50] Samuelson, P.A., 1992. At last a case for long-horizon risk tolerance and for asset allocation timing. In: Arnott, R.D., Fabozzi, F.J. (Eds.), Active Asset Allocation. McGraw-Hill, Maidenhead.; Samuelson, P.A., 1992. At last a case for long-horizon risk tolerance and for asset allocation timing. In: Arnott, R.D., Fabozzi, F.J. (Eds.), Active Asset Allocation. McGraw-Hill, Maidenhead.
[51] Siegel, J., 1997. Stocks for the Long Term. Richard D. Irwin, New York.; Siegel, J., 1997. Stocks for the Long Term. Richard D. Irwin, New York.
[52] Silvey, S.D., 1975. Statistical Inference. Chapman & Hall, London.; Silvey, S.D., 1975. Statistical Inference. Chapman & Hall, London. · Zbl 0323.62002
[53] Spanos, A., On modelling heteroscedasticity: the Student’s \(t\) and elliptical linear regression models, Econometric Theory, 10, 286-315 (1994)
[54] Thornton, P. N.; Wilson, A. F., A realistic approach to pension funding, Journal of the Institute of Actuaries, 119, 229-312 (1992)
[55] Van Eaton, R.D., Conover, J.A., 1998. Misconceptions about optimal equity allocation and investment horizon. Financial Analysts Journal, March/April, 52-59.; Van Eaton, R.D., Conover, J.A., 1998. Misconceptions about optimal equity allocation and investment horizon. Financial Analysts Journal, March/April, 52-59.
[56] Vasicek, O. E., An equilibrium characterisation of the term structure, Journal of Financial Economics, 5, 177-188 (1977) · Zbl 1372.91113
[57] Wilkie, A. D., More on a stochastic asset model for actuarial use, British Actuarial Journal, 1, 777-964 (1995)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.